![[up]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]"){kind=icon}
Agreed. Voting "no" for that reason.
Calling Casual-Competitive Conflict(8 yeas and 2 nays,)
Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 4 nays(total of votes:6), Broken Aesop is currently with 5 yeas and 9 nays(total of votes:14)
Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 3 yeas and 3 nays(total:6 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 5 yeas and 10 nays(total:15 votes)
Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 3 yeas and 5 nays(total:8 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 5 yeas and 10 nays(15 votes in the total)
edited 24th Sep '14 7:01:50 PM by MagBas
Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 6 nays(8 votes in the total), Broken Aesop is currently with 4 yeas and 11 nays(total:15 votes)
Master Spy
Shocking Elimination. Looking at many examples, such as the Hell's Kitchen ones, it seems that it is as subjective as Elimination Houdini, which is YMMV.
No, the other one.
Yeah, Shocking Elimination is definitely YMMV. I don't find a lot of the examples shocking, even as written.
Check out my fanfiction!Shocking Elimination is currently with 7 yeas and 0 nays(7 votes in the total), Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 6 nays(total:8 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 4 yeas and 12 nays(total:16 votes).
Shocking Elimination is currently with 7 yeas and 1 nay(total:8 votes), Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 8 nays(total:10 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 4 yeas and 12 nays(total:16 votes)
Shocking Elimination is currently 8 yeas and 1 nay(total:9 votes), Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 8 nays(total:10 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 4 yeas and 12 nays(total:16 votes)
Shocking Elimination is currently with 8 yeas and 1 nay(total:9 votes), Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 8 nays(total:10 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 4 yeas and 12 nays(total:16 votes)
Note:Shocking Elimination needs 1 vote to a total of 10 votes.
Calling Shocking Elimination(9 yeas and 1 nay)
Awful British Sex Comedy is currently 2 yeas and 8 nays(total:10 votes), Broken Aesop is currently 4 yeas and 12 nays(total:16 votes)
Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 2 yeas and 8 nays(total:10 votes), Broken Aesop is currently with 5 yeas and 12 nays(total:17 votes)
edited 13th Oct '14 4:50:40 AM by MagBas
These ones can be called as "don't make YMMV", I'd say.
edited 13th Oct '14 4:50:59 AM by SeptimusHeap
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard FeynmanHmm... Looking to the no real life examples thread, this policy really exists... and mention the same tropes in red hundreds of times is boring... okay.
Well, i am nominating Sturgeons Tropes. The reasoning to the inclusion of most of the tropes is based in the reaction of the audience- including objective tropes(as Status Quo Is God and Flat Character). Beyond this, if a specific use of a trope was good or bad is subjective.
edited 16th Oct '14 10:42:37 AM by MagBas
Sturgeons Tropes is currently with 1 yea and 2 nays(total:3 votes)
Well, considering the current votes, Sturgeons Tropes probably will be called as non-ymmv, but in this case, i guess that at least a clean-up in the examples of the page is a good idea(Static Character? As 99% of all the characters in fiction, specially minor characters?)
edited 18th Oct '14 8:43:26 PM by MagBas
No, the other one.
I'd suggest looking through the tropes in question and see how many positive examples there are. If there are more than 10% (and not just marginally more than that), I'd say the tropes can be removed.
I'm also kind of tempted to add Sturgeons Tropes to that list, because people add their own Pet-Peeve Trope rather than those that have almost entirely negative examples.
edited 21st Oct '14 1:38:49 AM by AnotherDuck
Check out my fanfiction!Sturgeons Tropes is currently with 2 yes and 4 nays(total:6 votes)
edited 24th Oct '14 7:50:56 AM by MagBas
Sturgeons Tropes is currently with 2 yeas and 5 nays(total:7 votes)
Crown Description:
YMMV is for items that are reactions of the audience to works and tropes that need a significant judgment call to tell whether they exist objectively or not. Should these items become members of YMMV? Note: Audience Reactions need to be subjective, emotional responses and things that are likely to cause arguments and disagreements. Merely being outside a work or inside an audience don't make things YMMV
Casual-Competitive Conflict is currently with 7 yeas and 2 nays(total votes:9), Awful British Sex Comedy is currently with 3 yeas and 1 nay(total votes: 4), Broken Aesop is currently with 5 yeas and 9 nays(total votes: 14)