YMMV / Divergent

The Books:

  • Alternative Character Interpretation:
    • Is Tris a brave, compassionate, sharp but self-doubting heroine who is worth rooting for, or is she an angsty, self-absorbed person with little human decency despite her upbringing, and some sort of constant mild concussion that blinds her to the bleedin' obvious?
    • Was Eric's eulogy to Albert a sincere Pet the Dog moment, or was it a lie simply to make himself look good? While Tris thinks it's the latter, Living Lie Detector Christina didn't point it out.
  • Base Breaker: Al. Some fans were really sad that he died and felt his death was a tragic cautionary tale against withholding forgiveness. Other fans felt that he deserved to die and that Tris was right not to forgive him.
  • Counterpart Comparison: Peter is a knife-wielding, green-eyed, dark-haired enemy of our protagonist with a violent, murderous streak. Similar to Clove from The Hunger Games.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse:
    • Some fans seem to like Fernando.
    • Considering the reaction to his character being cut from the first movie, Uriah seems to be this.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: The fact that the franchise has a lot of similarities with The Hunger Games makes one element very amusing. Both feature a character called Johanna, who debuts in the second book. Despite the franchises' similarities, the two Johannas couldn't be more different. One is a Blood Knight Cluster F-Bomb, while the second is an Actual Pacifist (though later revealed to be a Badass Pacifist).
  • Hype Backlash: Fan reaction to Insurgent and particularly Allegiant has been far milder and in some cases even downright negative in comparison to how Divergent was received.
  • It's Popular, Now It Sucks: Even more so than The Hunger Games, as The Hunger Games is still typically considered to be great dystopian literature, whereas it's harder nowadays to find people who will openly admit to liking Divergent despite it being a major critical and commercial success initially.
  • Moral Event Horizon:
    • Numerous candidates for when Peter crossed this. Shining examples are how he stabbed Edward in the eye while he was sleeping. Then there was the time he hung Tris over the chasm (claimed it was just to scare her) and groped her chest, while mocking her for "feeling twelve".
    • For Caleb, betraying his family to the Erudite. The full information about the outside world and what Jeanine told him has yet to be disclosed. But regardless, it doesn't change the fact that he sided with the faction that killed his parents and helped with the capture and attempted execution of his own sister.
  • Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: In Divergent, Peter was an irredeemable bastard, making him The Scrappy. However, Insurgent showed his more admirable traits. First, he helped Tris escape execution. Sure, it was out of obligation, but it's still something. Near the end, he took the time to comfort his grieving mother after finding out his father died in the invasion. More so in Allegiant when he reveals that he knows he's a horrible person and disgusts himself but can't help it and decides to wipe his own memory in hopes of becoming better. Makes him almost cross into Jerk Ass Woobie territory.
  • Take That, Scrappy!:
    • If Peter, Molly, and Drew do something to irritate you, just breathe a sigh of relief that they'll be humiliated for it later by Tris' hands.
    • Marcus gets one in Insurgent when Tobias gets laughed at for fearing him. So, to prove that he's no coward, he gives Marcus a well-deserved beat-down.
  • The Woobie:
    • Four. He's actually an Abnegation transfer named Tobias who left because his father, Marcus, constantly abused him.
    • Al is arguably the biggest one in the entire series. He didn't belong in Dauntless from the get-go and only joined to make his family proud, when he clearly belonged in somewhere like Amity. His entire initiation experience is agonizing and terrifying to him, and he grows more and more distant until eventually, when it's clear that his only choices are factionlessness and death, he joins with Peter and Drew in their attempt to murder Tris, regretting it immediately afterwards. It gets worse when Tris coldly rejects his pleas for redemption, despite being fully aware of his mental state and the intentions behind his actions, which leads to his suicide. A major What the Hell, Hero? moment for many readers.
    • Tris, by the end of the first book. During initiation, she is bullied, verbally harassed, and sexually assaulted for being a "Stiff", becomes a victim of attempted murder, drives one of her friends to suicide, watches her entire world and society crumble around her, is forced to shoot one of her best friends (who was mind-controlled), loses both of her parents, and is nearly shot and killed by the boy she loves (who was also mind-controlled). Her mental state continues to spiral downwards in Insurgent, to the point where she is nearly Driven to Suicide in the Candor Headquarters, and only holds back because she thought it would be ungrateful towards her parents, who sacrificed their lives for her. She also turns herself in to Jeanine without any escape plan, and the text makes it abundantly clear that she actively wants to die at this point.
  • Wangst: Depending on the reader, Tris's endless agonization over everything might be off-putting.

The Films:

  • Author's Saving Throw: In The Divergent Series: Insurgent, Tris had her hair cut into a pixie cut, much shorter than it was in the booksnote , which received complaints. This led to The Divergent Series: Allegiant having her hair now at chin-length, which is how she cut it in the books.
  • Broken Base:
    • The announcement that Uriah will be cut from Divergent and saved for the sequel, The Divergent Series: Insurgent. Some believe that Uriah's purpose in the first book wasn't that important, while others that love the character still call heresy on it.
    • In Divergent, there's Tris getting the flag instead of Christina like in the books. Those who argue against the change say that Christina needed her Crowning Moment of Awesome after being abused by Eric. Others say that it has much more meaning if Tris is the one who gets it, visually showing that she has finally earned her spot (as Christina had never been in danger of being cut).
  • Critical Dissonance: The film received mixed reviews from critics, but was generally well-received by audiences and fans of the book, and had a massive $55 million opening.
  • Just Here for Godzilla: A large amount of the first film's press came from the fact that Kate Winslet of all people was the villain. Half the interviews asked her about it.
  • Love to Hate: Kate Winslet makes Jeanine such a Magnificent Bitch that she's incredibly entertaining to watch.
  • Memetic Mutation: The fact that Ansel Elgort and Shailene Woodley who play siblings Caleb and Tris Prior, would later star as lovers in The Fault in Our Stars prompted plenty of memes about Tris or Caleb about to have a romantic moment, only to realise they're in the wrong movie.
  • Narm:
    • Some reviewers have pointed out that while Dauntless's habit of doing Le Parkour to board the overhead railway is clearly meant to embody how free spirited and brave they are the movie makes them look more like the cast of Fame or West Side Story than army recruits. Mark Kermode in his BBC review also thought their jumpsuits looked "a bit Blake's 7", which may become Narm Charm for some viewers.
    • Tris's pained squealing in The Divergent Series: Insurgent during the trial in Candor.
  • Signature Song:
  • Unfortunate Implications: Discussed here about a change in Divergent from the book to the film - in the book Tris's fear of intimacy is her third fear, which gets changed to a hallucination of Four attempting to rape her in the film. The post points out that the change (and by extension having Tris conquer the fear with a Groin Attack) opens up a can of worms:
    "...Aren't we just putting the impetus on preventing sexual assault back on the women? So if someone not as strong as Tris is unable to fight off her attacker, is she not responding "appropriately"? Then, aren't we just saying she didn't do everything she could, and thus, it's partly her fault?"

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/Divergent