YMMV / Charlotte's Web

All versions

  • It Was His Sled: Charlotte dies.
  • Protagonist Title Fallacy: The title spider is more the mentor to the actual protagonist, Wilbur.
  • Tear Jerker: Charlotte's death. Wilbur's reaction in the 1973 film sells it pretty well, too.
  • Values Dissonance: Apparently bringing a gun to school was acceptable in the fifties, as Avery is casually mentioned to do.
    • In certain cultures and areas. A lot of people going out hunting and stuff and people were a lot less reactionary because mass school shootings really didn't happen.
  • I Am Not Shazam: If haven't read the book or watched any of it's adaptations but have seen the book's cover art online, you'll be forgiven to think that Charlotte is the pig. Nope, the pig's Wilbur, and it's a he. Charlotte is the spider who dies near the end of the story.

The 1973 film

  • Ink-Suit Actor: Charlotte's facial features seem to vaguely resemble those of Debbie Reynolds, who provides her voice. The same can be said for Templeton and his voice actor Paul Lynde
  • Awesome Music: Arguably the entire soundtrack, but especially "Mother Earth and Father Time". Its hope-filled lyrics about enjoying our short time on Earth is really emotional. This IS the Sherman Brothers we're talking about here.
  • Do Not Do This Cool Thing: Templeton is derided by Wilbur and Charlotte when he returns from his smorgasbord immensely obese and his gluttony utterly satisfied. Many viewers actually enjoyed his binging sequence for how delicious the food looked, even though it was scraps and trash!
  • Ear Worm: "Chin up, Chin up. Everybody loves a happy face!"
    • Oh wow! Look at him now. Zuckerman's famous pig.
    • A fair is a veeeritable smorgasbord-orgasbord-orgasbord...
  • Tastes Like Diabetes: This was the author's main complaint.
  • Vindicated by History: Didn't do so well in the box office - however on VHS, it managed to become a bestseller. (One of the few non-Disney movies to do this.)
  • Wangst: Wilbur is over-the-top even when he has real reason to be upset.
    • Angst? What Angst?: Templeton's reaction to Charlotte's impending death, and Wilbur ordering him to transport her eggs into the crate, is his usual "What's in it for me?" schtick.

The 2006 film

  • Awesome Music: Instead of the cheery vocal songs of the 1973 film, it instead features an excellent instrumental score by Danny Elfman that is in many ways just as moving.
  • Billing Displacement: The poster mentions almost everyone in the main cast - except Dominic Scott Kay, who voices Wilbur.
  • Ugly Cute: Charlotte. Aside from having only two eyes and several "eyespots," she otherwise looks like a real spider. And yet, somehow, she comes off as beautiful.