These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
Bowser can't do anything (not even rearrange hisspice rack) without either Mario, Luigi, Peach, Toad or all four coming to beat him up. As well, he's invited to everything they do except for the parties. As Ted puts it:
Base Breaker: Amanda. To clarify, it's not because she's a girl. It's because she has no charisma or sense of commentary identity, likely due to lack of experience. Because of this, she comes across to some as trying too hard to be funny and being awkward as a whole when talking when compared to the others, seemingly ending sentences abruptly with irrelevant topics and then just stopping, leading to an awkward silence. Some people will endlessly bitch about her even when she's not in a commentary. Others are more optimistic and say she's getting better.
Ryan gets a lot of flak for complaining a lot, having a perceived unfair advantage in multiplayer games (he DOES win most of the times. This is particularly on display with Mario Party), and coming off as an elitist.
Hell, pretty much every commentator is a base breaker to varying degrees - Johnny is probably the only commentator without a significant hatebase. The only thing that comes close is a minority of people sometimes getting annoyed with his "philosophical reasoning" about some things, like his reasoning for keeping most of his Wii U games digital. If that's not petty, I don't know what is.
Everybody discusses their haters in their 2014 Black Friday Smash Bros 4 Video.
Bizarro Episode: Micheal Jackson's Moonwalker. Lampshaded by Ted in the opening.
Ted: John, what were you drinking?
Blatant Lies: A lot of fans, and the entirety of the BSC crew (with the exception of Ted), believe that Ted got lost in front of dungeon 3 in Zelda 1. This is because Ted made a jump cut in front of the dungeon, and Ted stated previously that whenever Ted made a jump cut, he's looking at the guide. He claims that he was just starting a new recording, but very few people believe him.
Later revealed in the crew's Let's Play of Return to Dream Land that they were just teasing Ted the whole time and they did believe him.
Ryan is the one that most often makes factual mistakes about the topic at hand, such as repeatedly stating Pokemon Gold and Silver came out in 2001, when it was actually 2000, and saying Captain Planet isn't in Cartoon Network: Punch Time Explosion, when he is actually the last character you unlock. He also said that Mega Man 9 and 10 were for the Virtual Console, when they were actually for WiiWare. This one could be written off as a slip of the tongue. The team also seemed all convinced that the period between The First Movie and Gold and Silver was extremely brief, when in reality it was almost a full year after the movie came out that the games hit America.
Every. Damn. Time. Fritz was on screen during the Frankenstein commentary, the team repeatedly called him Igor, even when his real name is said in the movie.
In Part 2 of the Sonic 4: Episode 1 commentary, when Johnny goes into Special Stage 4, the very first instant he hits a bumper...
In their Portal playthrough, the crew constantly says "Wheeeee!" when flying through the portals. GlaDOS joins in on their fun, trying to be one of the guys.
Too many things from the F-Zero GX commentary to list.
Through the magic of clipping, Lewis gets murdered by a ring box in Sonic 3.
In Sonic 06, Silver ends up hurling Sonic into outer space during Sonic's playthrough. This is arguably topped when the battle is revisited while Solaris is playing as Silver... "Super Machine Gun Table Attack!"
Dude, Not Funny!: In one part of the Super Mario Sunshine playthrough, when Ryan finally gets to the Mecha-Bowser fight, Lewis and Johnny joke about how the face makes it look like it has Down Syndrome.
John by default, considering he's the only main commentator not listed below in the Scrappy listing. Much of his relative popularity is likely because he is the most well-known of the main four, with the most active personal channel (only Ted's even begins to approach his activity), and even when he doesn't like a game, he won't complain nearly as much as the other crew members unless the game reallydeservesit. There is often disappointment in the comments for videos that he is unable to attend.
Clement and Gareth enjoy noticeable popularity over the other guest commentators.
Pretzal Bag, too. Before he died.
The Mario Party videos. They provided a lot of laughs and many fans requested them to do more playthroughs of them.
A lot of people also seem to like the longer videos, like lists, retrospectives, and impressions. They ARE nice to have going in the background while working on something or playing a game on mute. The impressions videos in particular seem to make people forget that videos take time to record and render.
Out of the guest commentators, Nathan and Masae have both been very popular. This may be due to them naturally fitting in with the chemistry of the group (tone, style, etc), as opposed to being overly quiet or self-pitying at times (Donnie and Typing ), beating jokes into the ground (Al), trying too hard to be funny but just coming off as forceful and inexperienced (Amanda), or just plain too loud (Matt).
Fan Hater: Though Gen 4 of Pokemon is not any of the crew's favorite, this is the reason Ted receives the the brunt of the resulting backlash (aside from bringing it up more often than the other two just to bash it). It's not difficult to look through the comments of Pokemon commentaries (or pretty much any game that he has a controversial or contrarian opinion on) and find several points where he argues with viewers, something the other two have never done. He was far worse about it in the past but it's not all the way gone.
He states that he's in Joking Mode, though whether it comes off as such depends on the viewer. Even then, this only (potentially) applies to IGN's Top 100 RPGs and B2W2 First Impressions when he said in an admittedly somewhat lighthearted tone that people liking Gen 4 are wrong. Everything else, like the aforementioned arguments or saying in the Bullshit Video that he doesn't see how anyone can like Platinum, plays this trope straight.
Ted got a lot of this (especially from Matt) with his favorable opinions of the first Legend of Zelda. To be fair, having never played the game before making a bet with Johnny, he had to keep a walkthrough open the entire time; even Zelda 1 fans will admit that the game can't be enjoyed without memorizing how to complete it. He was also heavily picked on by the other commentators for his constant deaths.
On the topic of Pokémon, Ryan with Gen 3. It's not that he outright bashes it so much as that he feels the need to repeatedly say that he doesn't know about its Pokémon nor considers them worth learning about. Johnny actually has a similar attitude toward Gen 3, but gets off with relatively little hate for it because he's not saying "Gen 3, don't care" every time he sees one of its Pokémon. Ted's apathy toward Gen 3 has also netted him some ire, but not nearly to the extent of Gen 4. Gen V seems to be the first generation since Gen II all 3 that still care have completely embraced, particularly Black and White 2.
Interesting, an aversion of this trope with Pokémon has somewhat helped Amanda's popularity, with her usually being the only commentator in Pokémon videos without a bias toward any generation, such as Ted's blind nostalgia for II and hatred of IV, or Ryan's indifference that still somehow causes him to compulsively bash them with III. In fact, Amanda has almost no bias to speak of.
Basically anything that comes within the borders of Ryan's PC mic, although it has been stopped by him buying a headset... mostly
That damn dog that barks at times and is picked up by someone's mic. You can tell it's the same dog, too. The worst part is that nobody acknowledges it.
Hilarious in Hindsight: Watching Lewis' kleptomania in the Sonic the Hedgehog (1991) playthrough prompts Johnny to ask what will happen if Lewis ever decides to play Pokémon for the channel. Cut to two years later, as Lewis begins his playthrough of Pokémon Leaf Green, which, before being commandeered by Johnny, is insanely slow-paced (it takes 2 and a half parts to get to BROCK). Lewis catches multiple fodder Pokémon, takes the time to explore every aspect of the game ad nausea (as in talking to EVERY NPC and reading EVERY sign at the lowest possible text speed), and remains consistently lax at actually editing bits out (enough to make even Ryan complain).
To add to this, Ryan made jokes during the Sonic playthrough about a Pokémon playthrough by Lewis having hundreds of parts and taking forever. Johnny points out at one point during the actual playthrough that if it were to continue in that manner, it would take them well over two years to actually get through it.
During a random bout in brawl, Johnny told Clement Megaman wouldn't be in Super Smash Bros 4. Come the official announcement and Megaman was the HIGHLIGHTED new character.
Later, in their final Brawl livestream, Johnny specifically invokes Clement's prediction while saying Palutena should be in Smash 4. Guess who was announced for the game.
During the Pokémon 2000 movie commentary, when Ash asks for a boat to fulfill the prophecy, the crew jokingly says he's going to use it to climb a mountain. Later on, that same boat is actually used to climb a mountain on one of the three islands and helps Ash obtain a MacGuffin. The boat goes on to become the most important thing in the movie.
In part 4 of the Sonic Heroes commentary, Lewis mentions that Sonic Shorts had ended. While it's debateable at the time it was recorded if it happened, but by the time the part was uploaded, the Sonic Paradox team had finally put their Grand Finale out.
In Part 9 of Shadow The Hedgehog, the guys have a debate about the president in the Sonic universe until Lewis says "Mr. President should have vetoed Sonic 06, but he didn't.", and Johnny follows up with "And that's why we have Obama." what puts this here is that this part was recorder before, and uploaded after, the 2012 presidential elections, where presumably everyone voted for him.
In Part 6 of Devil May Cry, John talks about him wanting hover boards before 2015. Later in March...
In Part 4 of New Super Mario Bros Wii, the guys talk about wanting a Luigi's Mansion for the 3DS (It should also be noted that they discused potential names for what would become the Wii U earlier in the Playthrough).
In Part 3 of Link: The Faces of Evil, Ryan mocks fans of Gen 3 for their expectations of remakes that won't happen, and Ted agrees that such fans should stop getting their hopes up. About a month after the recording was posted, look what was announced....
In Part 3 of Sonic 06, Ryan jokes about how Lewis is so good at the game, that he'll be the one playing Superman 64 for the channel. When they got around to playing that game, Lewis ended up being the most competent at controlling Superman.
It became even funnier when it turned out that Ryan was way better at the game than both Lewis and Ted combined. And it was his second time playing it.
In Part 2 of Mario Party, Lewis claims that chance time is only good "when it gets me a free star." And then in Part 3, Lewis ends up stealing Mario's star via chance time.
In the Space Jam commentary, Lewis claims that SlamJam is the Guile's theme of the next generation. There is a remix that combines Slam Jam and Guile's theme.
When Ryan wins the first board of their Mario Party 3 playthrough, he quotes "You're Winner!" and John replies with "you're always winner!" Ryan would then go on to win all three boards that they played.
During the Majora's Mask commentary, Ted comments on the unlikelihood of a 3DS remake of the game. An official remake had been announced just before the part came out. Johnny (the editor of the commentary) lampshades this by showing the remake's box art while repeating and slowing down Ted's voice.
Lewis: I know, but apparently he was also in Super Mario Sunshine.
To add more hilarity, a YouTuber commented that Mario would turn into Hump Man when Peach is rescued.
The crew has expressed some degree of concern when they learned their handle "Brain Scratch" was being abbreviated as "BS", which is also an abbreviation for bullshit. This ironic revelation caused much hilarity to ensue.
Kudzu Plot: Played with in Kid Icarus: Uprising part 16 where Lewis reveals a bunch of plot twists that make no sense that lead to more plot twists that make even less sense.
Amanda's outburst in part 23 of Shadow the Hedgehog, when Shadow is revealed to have been created with Black Doom's blood. Everyone found the revelation stupid, but Amanda ran around screaming "WHAT THE FUCK!?" for so long that even the other commentators became impatient. This moment is responsible for the most hateful comments Amanda has received.
In general, loud outbursts in an attempt to be funny are the main reason Amanda is so controversial.
Ryan's raspberry noises in the IGN Top 25 3DS Games is considered this. The effect still lingers in later videos whenever he does it.
"Peach is useful!" A particular phrase used extensively by Lewis during Super Mario 3D World that very quickly wore out its welcome for most viewers, compounded by his deadpan delivery and his inexperience with the game that caused deaths for all four players. He eventually apologized for using the phrase too much.
When it comes to co-op games, Ryan absolutely loathes griefing since he finds it incredibly annoying and stops the team's progress. He mentions his hate for griefing during the group's Super Mario 3D World run and asks the others to keep griefing to a minimum. Ryan also tells Johnny that he's glad that Matt (Johnny's friend) wasn't playing because he knew Matt would be griefing the entire time as he did in SGB's let's play of New Super Mario Bros. Wii and New Super Mario Bros. U.
Ted goes absolutely nuts whenever anyone blatantly ignores items or power-ups in the game since he believes that every item, no matter how little of a purpose they serve, all have some use and should be picked up. Ted gets on Johnny's case a lot for ignoring items during the Metroid: Fusion commentary and he also gets annoyed in the The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask commentary when he hears Johnny and a few others don't bother collecting maps for the regions of Termina. Ted has been compared to Lewis with their kleptomania many times; Lewis collects everything in the game for the sake of collecting them while Ted collects stuff that are helpful to him, even if he won't ever use it.
Amanda has gotten many more defenders in her recent appearances, partly from belief that she's getting better, and partly from belief that her haters (some of whom abandon commentaries the second they hear her voice) have gone too far.
Lewis was controversial in earlier videos, as he was constantly questioning logic in video games that throw logic out the window, but toning this trait down to more snarky levels, along with his frequent absences, have garnered more positive reception.
Scrappy Mechanic: The Curse in Paper Mario is this to Ted, especially shown in the playthrough since it ends up doing the worst possible things at the worst possible times, the worst being in the battle with the Superboss in part 36 in which it ups his attack on the turn he's CHARGING HIS ATTACK.
Lewis has gotten heat for constantly questioning oddities in video games that don't try to be realistic in the first place, spawning the phrase "It's a video game!" He also became this to some anime fans when he said "I like Naruto more than Dragon Ball Z" in Final Fantasy 6.
Ryan: Can I punch you over the internet?!
Ted is steadily becoming the most divisive member of the crew. Examples include his voice being grating to some (it's probably his accent), the aforementioned excessive bashing on Gen 4 of Pokémon and unpleasant attitude toward those who defend it, occasionally being quite a Know-Nothing Know-It-All (like treating Pokemon's metagame as too unbalanced to play and competitive players as ignorant for not realizing this, while frequently displaying incompetence about how the metagame works), his tendency to overstate his issues with games that he has distaste for, and to some, coming off as preachy and stubborn. It's worth noting, however, due to some fans dicking with him, he's stated he's trying to become better about this sort of thing.
Alexander (Spax 3) is regarded as one of the more annoying commentators. He tends to yell loudly in general, especially when trying to crack jokes, and he has a bad tendency to talk over the other guys when he's trying to get something across. Some people believe that the guys (Lewis, Johnny, and Ryan at the time) were equally annoyed with him, as he hasn't shown back up to guest commentate since 2009.
Amanda gets this treatment the most. It's a rather love or hate thing she's got going. It's gotten to the point that the crew Lampshaded her presence will piss people off.
Some people have showed hatred towards Ryan's friend Andrew, some making fun of his speech impediment.
It is worth noting that some of Andrew and Amanda's haters do come up with legitimate reasons to not like them. Examples include Andrew's speech impediment being hard to understand coupled with him trying to be very vocal, and Amanda with her rather loud, high-pitched laughter. This does not excuse (and unfortunately seems to be outnumbered by) those who openly mock or insult the two, although Amanda seems to be getting better treatment as of late.
Ryan shows many shades of the trope during the group's play through of Super Mario 3D World. Ryan screws up the least due to having the most experience of the game and he is quick to complain the minute someone in the group screws up and makes everyone else suffer for it.
Ryan (who plays as Waluigi) wins on the Waluigi board by going in a circle pretty much the entire game. The other players (Johnny, Ted and Lewis) are understandably infuriated.
Johnny: YOU MOTHERFUCKER!!!! YOU SON OF A BITCH!!!
The commenters are also getting annoyed by Ryan winning almost every Mario Party board, even saying that what were once the most popular playthroughs are getting boring due to knowing how they will likely turn out.
The Woobie: Amanda, a nice, energetic commentator who is often hounded by the viewers for some forced attempts at humor to the point that some will leave the video the second they hear her voice.