These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
The final boss of the main game only has a flock of crows to defend itself once you get within shooting range, and you get a chest with unlimited flare gun ammo.
The final boss of The Signal can be dispatched with a few flare gun shots and boosting the flashlight for about 15 seconds or so. There's a reason one of the achievements requires you to beat it in a minute and a half. The final boss of The Writer is legitimately difficult, though certainly not in That One Boss territory.
Breather Level: There are several places in the game, albeit brief ones, where Alan moves about during daylight. These sections are safe, allowing the player to relax a little while some exposition goes on, and occasionally enjoy some Scenery Porn of the local environment.
The very last level of the main game has no danger whatsoever, just various things to shine the flashlight on which causes objects to appear.
Complaining about Shows You Don't Watch: There are quite a few complaints about being in the forest for the entire game, but this is not the case; You're only in the forest for about three levels in the game. The rest of the game is spent in much more varietal environments after the three forest levels.
Plus those are reallygoodforests, so the people making said complaints were missing the point even if they knew what they were talking about.
Barry, for his constant pop culture references from Zork to Mordor and for taking a couple of levels in badass from Episode 4 onwards. He's also liked because he gives Alan some Pet the Dog Moments. Once Alan starts snarking back and forth with Barry you realize, hey, Alan's not just a mopey jerkass. He's got a sense of humour!
Remedy has stated that they like Agent Nightingale's character and would like to explore his mysterious backstory further.
The Dark Crows, which are about as close to the trope namer as possible without actually being mammals. Also those damned Bear Traps in certain parts of the woods.
The Super Speed Taken and the lesser Fragile Speedster Taken. Neither are terribly threatening as long as you're attentive, but their speed means you can lose track of them in the Multi Mook Melee, and that tends to be a deadly mistake.
Although you no longer have to fight crows, which is nice. They do appear in the game, but they take a human form to fight you, and only turn into a flock of crows as an evasive manoeuvre.
Grenadiers constantly heft grenades at you to slowly wear you down and keep as much distance between you and them as they can. It's not too bad during the story mode, but they will screw up you scoring streak during the arcade mode.
There are people out there who dislike the game for some very odd reasons such as not enough gore, different weapons, or that there are lots of trees around. It becomes really bad, however, when a person buys the $80 limited edition and complains about the overall tone of the game. Apparently, they didn't even read the box before they bought it.
Hell Is That Noise: When the wind starts blowing hard, and the shadows start moving of their own accord, it's time to run like hell.
Internet Backdraft: PC gamers are bitter about Alan Wake being moved from a Direct X 10-only Windows title to the Xbox 360 console.
Jerkass Woobie: Alan Wake himself. Considering the situation he was in.
Agent Nightingale Can be seen as this if you've read his backstory in The Alan Wake Files bundled with the limited edition of the game.
And carried on with the Novel which goes into even more detail; He and his partner were two By The Book Cops, until the latter's death at the hands of the Dark Presence
Mondegreen: In the very first line of "Children of the Elder God" - "Warriors, torchbearers, come redeem our dreams." - the first two words can easily be misheard as "Warriors touch their ass".
Moral Event Horizon: Agent Nightingale, after capturing Alan, taunts him about putting him in jail for a long time.
Most Wonderful Sound: Maine's late night radio broadcasts really help take the edge off of fighting shadow monsters alone in the woods.
Narm Charm: As strong an element of Lake's writing as ever. His occasionally stilted and unnatural dialogue(possibly deliberate, in this case), often propped up with gratuitous film references right in the fore-text, is still very sincere in its desire to entertain and has won him many new fans.
Judging by some interviews, Lake is a native Finnish speaker (as is the company) with a really heavy accent so English may not be his first language resulting in some translation issues.
Nausea Fuel: In one of Mr. Scratch's recordings in American Nightmare, he slashes the throat of one of Alan's female fans while gently massaging her head. The gurgling noise she makes as she dies is very disturbing.
Nightmare Retardant: Having a deranged hybrid of the Heartless and the Ganados flail at you wildly with a rusty sickle is unnerving right up until he kindly informs you, "Omega-3 fatty acids are GOOD for your health!".
But then swings back to Nightmare Fuel when you realize that the random phrases are all that's left of the original person.
But then another shouts "It's rabbit season!" to which you reply, "No it's duck season!" and blow his beak off with a hunting rifle.
At one point during Episode 2, if you go into a certain cabin, a Taken walks by one of the windows, before disappearing. Nothing happens, but it's still Paranoia Fuelto the max.
After finishing Episode 1, fighting off the Taken in the middle of the night, you're probably still tense and maybe a bit afraid of the dark. Episode 2 starts in a flashback at Alan's apartment. Alan's looking at cover mock-ups done by Alice - when the lights suddenly go out.
Near the entrance of a logging camp, there's a large machine with a claw for carrying logs. Stepping near it causes the claw to open and close menacingly while an Elite Taken starts yelling in his constantly shifting voice. While the machine doesn't do anything else, the Elite Taken is nowhere to be seen.
After Alan ends up in the Sheriff's Station, he walks out into the lobby, and the lights flicker. It's just Cynthia Weaver, local Talkative Loon, checking the bulbs.
Quite a few people dislike Barry for being annoying and trying to be plucky comic relief in what is otherwise a very dark game.
According to the manuscript, Barry thinks of himself in one scene as The Hero. Or at least a hero. Also, making jokes is and actually one of the healthier reactions to a crisis, as long as it's still being taken seriously.
That One Level: The battle after you find the radio that plays "War". It's a very cramped warehouse full of the large Taken that take forever to light up and have a tendency to bum rush you. It's also full of smaller, faster guys who can sneak up behind you very easily. Oh, and did I mention that you have recently lost all of your stuff and only get three flares to go along with your revolver? If you're lucky, you'll find a shotgun just before the radio, but it doesn't help that much.
That is, until you realize you can simply run past/dodge them all to the checkpoint outside, but you'd be forgoing the items inside.
Getting caught by the Bear Traps is annoying, since it spawns a Taken each time it happens. However, in one part of the game with bear traps, you also have no weapons, and they still spawn Taken when you get caught by them.
Uncanny Valley: Multiple reviewers have made note of the somewhat "off" character models in the game, particularly Alice Wake. The poor lip-syncing, particularly in the first few cutscenes, doesn't help matters either.
Villain Decay: A minor example. The Taken who has a specific grievance against Wake in the beginning of the game, during the nightmare, and who speaks lucidly, is more intimidating than the ones who randomly shout gibberish based off of their lives.
It's never quite clear if this is actually a Taken or just a part of Alan's nightmare. It could be intentional decay on Alan's part, remembering the nightmare and making that into what the Taken are, or it could be that this is what the Taken really are but he toned them down in his book. Suffice it to say the game isn't going to explain it.
It's just a part of Alan's nightmare. "The Writer" ends with a Boss Rush of Dr. Hartman, the Anderson Brothers (both at once), and then Barry three times in a row; all of whom are lucid Taken, and the DLC takes place in Alan's nightmares.
Might also be a case of Not Brainwashed. The guy was pretty upset about Alan killing him off in his book.