Drosselmeyer's failure was inevitable due to a fault in his storyFakir seems to be unable to write an "unrealistic" story - he has free reign with mysterious powers, especially character-themed ones, but he is unable to force people to behave out of character, which is why his attempt to force the ravens to let Ahiru go was unsuccessful. It's not much of a stretch to assume that it works the same way with genre limitations. For example, you can't make a fairy-tale character suddenly turn into a detective and investigate, say, why his wife has been bearing animals instead of real kids, according to the letters he got. So Drosselmeyer, after having his fairy-tale stopped, manages to continue it as a Magical Girl series - he finds a pure-hearted girl and gives her a power to transform into a prettier and more capable version of herself that no-one can recognize for some reason... yeah. It goes all according to his script as one - there's a Dark Magical Girl to oppose her and a suitable reason for Heroic BSOD at the darkest moment... basically, the manga is one version of how the story should have been, and would have been with a more, ah, Genre Savvy author. But Drosselmeyer tries to force it to be a tragedy as it nears the conclusion... how many Magical Girl series with classical tragedy-style endings do you know? Yeah. Of course, the already-shaped story, already a mix of a fairy tale and Magical Girl series, can't conform, the three styles would just contradict each other too much.
Princess tutu is related to Mytho in someway.Inspired by a fanfic. Princess Tutu seems to share Mytho's white hair, if Ahiru's Princess Tutu form is any indication. Admittedly, this could also be a side-effect of using Mytho's heartshard to transform, but none of the people in possession of heartshards have shown such a side-effect.
Fakir and Rue are siblings.Fakir's mother—shown in a brief flashback in episode 20—looks remarkably similar to Rue (for being seen only in shadow, anyway). Also, on Autor's family tree, the person that he identifies as Fakir on the tree has a sibling...that's been crossed out. Rue was kidnapped by her family as a baby, and so doesn't remember what they were like. Fakir has suppressed most of the memories before his parents died, and he and Rue are also close in age, so if she is his sister it makes sense why he wouldn't recall her. Also, if you compare how the two looked as children, they appear very similar. (Although, admittedly, it could just be due to the art style.) As one last final interesting tidbit, Fakir appears briefly in the background of Rue's flashback of her childhood when the story goes backwards in episode 23—you can see him fighting attempting to fight off crows with a toy sword to save a small animal (possibly a cat). Plus, don't they just ACT like siblings fighting over a favorite toy?
Autor actually is a descendant of Drosselmeyer.He's the first one in akt 23 to realize that the story is going backwards—Fakir has to ask him what's going on, and Drosselmeyer seems (pleasantly) surprised by the story going backwards, as if it's never happened before. If it hasn't happened before, then Autor couldn't know about it through research alone—in actuality he can sometimes hear the story being told because of the vague bits of Drosselmeyer's DNA that's in his blood. This also means that his claim that he heard the Oak Tree sigh is actually true. (Probably it was sighing in exasperation from how insane the kid tapping into her roots is.) However, he's too distant of a descendant to be able to control a story through pen and ink—he's cursed to be able to hear the words of Story Spinners, but never truly become one himself. Or, alternatively...
Autor's too logical to be a writer and use the Story-Spinning powers.Perhaps he does have the potential to use the powers, but he's so fond of logic and formulas ("blue and black ink at a 7/3 ratio", "Drosselmeyer's special blend of tea—three parts Darjeeling and then added Assaam"...) that he can't understand the creative process. (Similar to how Drosselmeyer tells Fakir that he has to "let go and be irresponsible with your writing.") It's not that he doesn't have the right bloodline, he's just not a talented writer. At all.
Ahiru/Duck is a character Fakir wrote in a story as a child.Think about it: Fakir is obviously fond of animals. As a child, one of Fakir's stories was about a little duckling with a big heart and the mind of a human girl. Since he wrote her as a "duckling" she was never able to grow older, but with the mind of a little girl she was able to mentally and emotionally mature to the age she appears as in the show. This is one of the reasons why Fakir can write about Ahiru, and why Drosselmeyer has such a difficult time controlling her—she's Fakir's character, not Drosselmeyer's. Tutu, however, is Drosselmeyer's character. This means that the girl Ahiru is a character shared between the two. (And also why Fakir has to call out her true name, and not "Princess Tutu"—he has no power or right to call one of Drosselmeyer's characters out from his realm.)
Autor and Malen are brother and sister.Not my theory, but one that I've seen appear in a few fanfics. The general logic probably stems from the fact that they have glasses and similar hairstyles, both are attracted to/obsessed with Rue, and they both throw themselves wholeheartedly into their passions.
Lilie is Drosselmeyer's true sucessor.Either another one of his descendants, or simply his spiritual successor chosen to highlight the tragedy of the story. Autor isn't creative enough and Fakir isn't sadistic enough to be considered worthy by Drosselmeyer. Sadly for Lilie, Drosselmeyer was unable to contact her to carry out his will before Fakir finished his story.
Edel is made from the wood of The Great Oak Tree.Not my theory—thought up by Tomoyo on the LiveJournal community. Notable because this was confirmed by Word of God at the Princess Tutu Cast Party held at Ushicon. This is why Edel and the Oak Tree repeat similar phrases.
Haruhi Suzumiya is a descendant of Drosselmeyer, possibly through Fakir.Or Kyon, depending on if you believe the theory in Haruhi's WMG. This is the source of her reality-bending powers—although, of course, she's a prodigy that has refined the Story-Spinning powers beyond the level that Drosselmeyer and Fakir reached. She no longer even needs a pen and paper to use her powers!
The novelist in Stranger Than Fiction is a descendant of Drosselmeyer.Pretty straight-forward. Drosselmeyer writes tragedies that become reality until his characters rebel. Karen Eiffel is a writer of tragedies that become reality until one of her main characters contacts her and asks her to not kill him. Of course, Karen isn't nearly as cruel as Drosselmeyer—a descendant that Drosselmeyer would probably be disappointed in.
Autor's father trained him to be a Story-Spinner since he was a young child.Autor is careful to note that one of the Story Spinners on his family tree is "the man who saved my father when he was a boy." That was the even that lead his father to be obsessed with Drosselmeyer—he started much of Autor's research, and trained him to become a Story-Spinner. (If you combine this with the theory above that Autor is an actual descendant of Drosselmeyer, it's possible Autor's father purposefully married into the family if he wasn't one himself.) Much of the (really weird) ideas Autor has about what one needs to be a Story Spinner were actually taught to him as a child—which would mean that, yes, Autor's father made him stand in the middle of his study for three days without sleep or food. (Which also explains why Autor is rather...interesting.)
The Princess Tutu manga is a Fix Fic written by Autor.This explains a lot of the changes to the story in the manga:
The Story is actually part of The Tradition.With The Tradition, individuals are forced down paths already chosen for them until they a) accomplish their "happily ever after", b) die, or c) have something else happen that allows them to break from it.
The final five heart shards can all be identified by their dialogueNot sure how, but they can be guessed at.
Drosselmeyer is into LoliconI don't think I have to explain myself.
The narrator that speaks at the beginning of each episode is the REAL author of the story.It sort of makes sense. In the last episode, Drosselmeyer himself ponders if he's in someone else's story since his didn't go the way he wanted.
Drosselmeyer, Fakir or one of their descendants created the Death Notes and maybe the shinigami tooWriting = reality, and one of them was playing around with their powers too much. The rules at the beginning of the death note, while supposedly written by Ryuk, could just be the writer who made them writing the story about the death note itself. Also, Fakir can make writing look dramatic while Light... eh.
Every Tear Jerker Downer Ending book you've ever read is that way because Drosselmeyer got a hold of it.It's his mission to depress us all, to the point of suicide if possible, in revenge for losing his hands. He obviously believes in Disproportionate Retribution.
Mytho is Dios.Once his heart is restored, he is the glorious ideal of the Knight In Shining Armour. He is self-sacrificing to a near suicidal degree (even before he was emotionless ). In Rue's flashback, we seen her as a little girl while Mytho still looks the same as he does at the time of the series - it's as though he doesn't age. Once fully awakened, he is able to save the woman he loves and defeat ultimate evil. Dios is described as "That which is eternal, that which shines, the power of miracles, the power to revolutionize the world..." and is shown as having been around since a golden age. He, too, has temendous powers of swordsmanship and defends the world form evil , at a great cost to himself. This could mean that Raven!Mytho is in fact Akio.
Revolutionary Girl Utena and Princess Tutu occur in the same universeWith all the similarities and f* cked up fairy tales running around, it's no wonder. The former takes place in Japan and the latter takes place in Germany.
Drosselmeyer is the predecessor of Franz Kafka.Upon realizing his other descendant Fakir wasn't playing along with the story, Drosselmeyer went into the life of his however-great grandson and manipulated him into continuing the line of tragic tales by striking him with clinical depression.
When Autor grew up......he decided to leave town to find his place now that it was finally physically possible, somewhere along the way his mental instability increased before finally, er, "stabilizing" at its own odd point in its own odd way, his obsession with the all-powerful Drosselmeyer ended up as some kind of segue, his paranoias led to him using an alias for whatever reason, and he ended up as a
Lilie is Kinkan Town's Kafuka Fuura.The reason she loves suffering so much is because she can't understand it; when something bad happened to her, she brushed off the circumstances as being too unrealistic, and now just enjoys the sensation so she can coddle her friends. Also, she's got a huge amount of physical strength and doesn't notice when she hurts Ahiru.
Drosselmeyer is Joss Whedon.The first syllable of his name sounds like "Joss", and he loves angsty stories. Hence, Princess Tutu was secretly written by Joss Whedon, and conversely, Firefly was secretly written by Drosselmeyer. The reason it ended so early was that the characters revolted.
Mytho held on to one emotion to keep himself alive.Knowing he couldn't live without a heart, he figured he could at least manage to survive with a small piece of it. Which emotion was it, you ask? His desire to protect the innocent. This explains why he would go out of his way and risk his life to save the lives of others, no matter how insignificant.
The entire series is a tabletop RPG game successfully derailed.The PCs are Ahiru, Fakir, Mytho, Rue, and Autor. Ahiru and Fakir's players were upset because they realized their characters were doomed to die no matter what, and Autor was upset because his character barely had any inclusion in the game. Story Spinning is a power granted through some obscure splatbook that the GM approved without looking through, and they used it to the fullest extent to derail the game. The Bookkeepers are DM fiat in physical form. Drosselmeyer was a cool framing device the GM thought up.
The transformation into Princess Tutu includes an age up.Princess Tutu is taller than Ahiru, has longer face, smaller eyes (large eyes being indicative of youth) and has a bigger chest than Ahiru. Additionally her increased grace and poise might be in part due to growing up out of an awkward phase.
Drosselmeyer was taught Story-Spinning by Featherine Augustus AuroraAnd ended up like Bernkastel. Unfortunately.
Mr. Cat is related to The Royal FamilyThe King Cat in The Cat Returns keeps trying to get Haru to marry either the Prince or (at the end) him. However, a third option is taken. Somewhere down (up?) the line, Mr. Cat was born and ended up in Kinkan town where things got... Screwy.
Captures a good guy lady and Mind Rape and invokes a Painful Transformation to turn the lady into an evil evil evil puppet?
Uses mindless drones. This one differs a little since the soul-raped victims are pretty much used exclusively by The Raven (crows) while the Dark Voice's Zerg can make some (Infected ____) but don't have to.
Drones tend to Zerg Rush.
Fakir is part Arab.If his name and physical features compared to the rest of the cast is anything to go by. Of course, not fully because of Drosselmeyer.
The reason Rue doesn't become a crow despite having been exposed to raven's blood for so long......is because she isn't fully part of the story. The characters of The Prince and the Raven that were mentioned were the prince, a knight, and Princess Tutu. Duck took on Princess Tutu's role, Fakir was the knight, and the prince was... Well, himself. But it never mentioned any kind of crow princess. Even when she became a character, she was still separate from the original story, and that's why the power of the Raven, the villain of the original story, didn't affect her as strongly as it did Mytho. In her veins, there was the most literal mixing of fiction and reality possible, and her "real" form was strong enough to resist the outside influence. As for why the raven's blood affects the townspeople so quickly, well, my only thought so far is that the story did spread to the town, and since they weren't major characters, there was nothing to protect them at that point. Still, just a thought.
The short narrations at the beginning of every episode are abridged versions of the stories that Drosselmeyer wrote while he was still alive.Hence why some of the short stories fit better than others at times; they aren't meant to give incite to the actual plot of the episode, only it's theme and the ensuing tragedy that Drosselmeyer would work it into were he given the chance to. (Yes, this also implies that he wrote his world's versions of Cinderella and Swan Lake.) This is also why the first few episodes' prologues so closely mirror the situation that created the story we're seeing. Drosselmeyer is currently working on the story that the audience is viewing, and as the audience views it, the characters within the story follow its plot until they slowly become more aware and start to change it. Thus, despite the opening narration ending the stories darkly, Princess Tutu moves the story of the episode into a more hopeful direction with each episode, building up into Ahiru and everyone else fighting against their own unhappy endings at the end of the series.
The Drosselmeyer we see is actually a character.The narrator never says outright that Drosselmeyer came back from the dead, she only point out that he died, and thus one would expect him to not be doing anything (aside from occasionally rolling). The only possible way he could have come back from the dead is if he (or one of his descendants) wrote it into reality, but if so, why would he stop at resurrecting his spirit so that it could live in an alternate dimension? Why wouldn't he resurrect his body, or give himself greater power? Or (if he wrote it himself) just stop himself from dying? Because it's not the actual person of Drosselmeyer that we meet - it's a Drosselmeyer character. One of his descendants wrote about him (or rather, his vengeful spirit), creating the hammy tragedian we know and love. He was kept as a spirit because either the writer was Genre Savvy enough to know not to mess with actually resuscitating dead bodies, or wasn't aware of his power and just made it that way because it fit the story he was writing. While the writer was at it, he gave Drosselmeyer different ways of changing reality without the need to write (you'll notice that Drosselmeyer rarely actually writes anything, even though he has functional hands). The creation of Drosselmeyer's character may have been unintentional, or it may have been to counteract the Raven or some other dangerous character that had escaped from Drosselmeyer's stories.
Pique and Lilie were written in when Duck turned into a girl.Episode 1 must have been Duck's first day as a human, since A) She didn't recognize Mr. Cat and B) Knowing her, she wouldn't have been able to go more than a day or two before turning back into a duck. She clearly thought that she had been human all her life, so Drosselmeyer could just as easily have made her think that she had been at the Academy for a while, too. But if that was her first day, how could Pique and Lilie be best friends with her? Because they were written that way, in order to help incorporate her into the community. And it just figures that Drosselmeyer would give her "friends" who would explain things without offering any real emotional support.