Proof that the remaining 10% is worth dying for here.
These are recommendations made by Tropers for Princess Tutu fanfics, all of which have to be signed to stay on the page. Feel free to add a fanfic of your own to the list, but remember to use the template found here.
You can also add to the current recommendations if you want. Refrain from posting Conversation in the Main Page though; that goes in the discussion page.
Synopsis: Crossover with Revolutionary Girl Utena. Pre-Utena Anthy wanders the world and encounters Mytho and Rue. A fleshing out of fairytale archetypes ensues.
Comments: Interesting exploration of the characters of Anthy and Rue. Comparison between both characters sheds light onto some of the weirder parts of Utena. Both Anthy and Rue are trapped in their roles in their stories, and each character tries to make sense of their existential imprisonment.
Synopsis: An Alternate Universe Fic set in Medieval times, in which the characters are intertwined with a town's fate and its last hope: the royal line.
Comments: The best Tutu fic I have ever read (of course, I'm biased on account that I'm the beta editor). Excellent characterization and use of the Princess Tutu canon to create something original, emotional, and just wonderfully written. It'll have you on the edge of your seat. I highly recommend it!
Moo92: This story is beautiful, lovely imagery, and very captivating. I hope this does not end up a dead fic for that would be very unfortunate for this story to go to waste.
Willowleaf: Even though I realize this phrase is thrown around like confetti on the fanfic rec pages, "this is the best fanfiction I have ever read" would not be an overstatement. I've been reading fanfiction for years, have come across some incredible stories, and have a bizarrely high standard for writing. This fanfiction though? It's written in a gorgeous, well-woven fairy tale-esque style that is reminiscent of the tales that inspired its anime. The plot is well thought out with several chilling mysteries and questions that have yet to be answered. The character's development and interactions are in character and develop in ways that parallel the original universe. There is so much more about this story that has been left unsaid, but trust me when I say, most definitely not lightly, that this IS the best fanfiction I have ever read. It may be the best fan written story I had ever read, be it for a fandom or not. Read it. Why are you still looking at this silly recommendation?
Synopsis: An AU Princess Tutu fic set in New York during the Roaring Twenties with copious amounts of Film Noir. Duck Stannus lived a perfectly ordinary life until witnessing a murder by a mysterious white-haired mobster known only as Principe. Soon her life is thrown into unbalance, with the Hardboiled Detective Fakir Romeiras watching over her as he pursues Principe and the Corvo Family.
Comments: Very well-researched into the 1920's, as well as having befittingly meaningful surnames granted to them. It's very, very well written and the characters fit the Film Noir setting perfectly, and each role they've been assigned suits them to a tee, from Rue the Mafia PrincessFemme Fatale to Mytho the young heir to the Corvo Family's name to Charon the police captain and Raestel (here called Rachel for reasons explained in the story) the opera singer. The pacing is done amazingly well, and at times, it's easy to forget you're reading a story.
Now with a page of its own, here. Feel free to contribute.
Synopsis: By choosing Ahiru over Piqué as first target for sacrifice, a prince drastically changes the story's path, and a knight will bear the backlash. As a princess finds her saving grace; another will fall to the darkness. Accepting fate hardly brings happiness while defying fate may not always grant glory. Finding the happy ending? That is the hardest part of them all.
Comments: A very interesting story that deals with the question most of the fans of Princess Tutu made: if Evil!Mytho wanted pure hearts as sacrifice, why didn't he target Ahiru first? Mytho's abusive treatment on Rue increases, there's tons of Ship Tease and the story takes a new course when Ahiru's heartpiece pendant got corrupted in raven's blood and she turns in a darker version of Princess Tutu. Well written and deserves a look.
Synopsis: "Our story may seem lighthearted at first." Drosselmeyer murmured, "but soon it shall become dark, dangerous, and devastatingly gorgeous." His tragedy would be a perfect one, filled with something for every taste: romance and drama, comedy, subtle horror, and heartwrenching sacrifice. But the only question is, do the characters have other plans?
Comments: A Princess Tutu AU. After the failure with "The Prince and The Raven", Drosselmeyer plans a new tragic story for the characters. Ahiru is now a normal girl instead of a duck, Mytho has his heart and is more expressive, Fakir is barely less of a jerk (with a thing for putting stamps in his man card) and Rue is pretty much the same. But everything starts to change after the two girls accept the power of mysterious beings, only known as Odette and Svanna. Divided in five Acts with a good amount of "scenes", the story goes from adorable romance/comedy to drama/tragedy at the end of the 3rd Act. Instead of the threat of The Raven, Fakir now must protect Mytho's heart of a mysterious swan princess, but his doubts on those close to him may be his downfall, specially with a more sadistic and careful Drosselmayer watching over, like a vulture, in order to prevent any trace of hope. 51 chapters and the story is complete and well written, the pacing is excellent and Femio returns, more flamboyant than ever!
Timmah : Consistent characterization and solid plotting make this work. I recommend this to fans of the series who wish to see the fairy tale motifs continue to be explored.
sardns: This sequel fic is so good it's a crying shame it isn't canon.
It should be canon.
GoldenDragon326: Beautifully written with a darkish theme complete with a few cute moments concerning the two central pairings; it's hard to read just once. This troper's only complaint was that the story called her 'Duck,' instead of 'Ahiru.' Easily ignored, however, insight of its terrific-ness.
CelestialPuppet: I adored this fic. Absolutely adored it. It was heartbreaking, deep, complex—absolutely gorgeous. It's very rare to find this kind of quality, fanfiction or original works. I can see that a lot of thought was put into it. This should be season three of Princess Tutu.
Zarclonia: I love the story, I want to make a page for it but I don't know how. Can any one tell me how to make a page?
Synopsis: A few years after, a boy and a girl board a train.
Comments: This is one of the first Princess Tutu fanfics that I read and to this day it is still a favorite of mine. It's bittersweet, well written, and a unique take on what could happen after the show. Worth a read!