"So, does anyone else want to drop out?"The Heroes of a story often draw a Line in the Sand, asking "Who's with me?" when proposing a particularly dangerous course of action. Occasionally, the villainous version can also be seen. A villain has a grand scheme, but not necessarily the resources to pull it off. He calls together a room full of potential investors and outlines the plan. But these guys are businessmen, used to being pitched at, and sometimes one will stand up and announce that it sounds too risky (or that guy's just more squeamish than the rest), and he wants out. Sometimes, so as not to risk scaring the rest, the villain will graciously allow him to leave, and remind him not to talk about it. He will ask his henchman to "show him out." The Henchman will nod, smile, escort him from the room and kill him, thus ensuring total loyalty and secrecy for his evil plot. The rest of the time, he'll throw the man out right there and then, usually followed by a quip to the nature of "anyone else?". Compare and contrast Board to Death, where all of the businessmen are killed. Not to be confused with a scene where a someone is literally thrown out of a zeppelin in Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade (or the one in K).
— Max Zorin, A View to a Kill
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- Lady Une does this in spectacularly villainous fashion in Mobile Suit Gundam Wing after tricking General Septem into giving a live speech on behalf of OZ (aboard a plane fleeing the attack of the New Edwards Base) condemning peace with the space colonies and reaffirming Earth's resolve to the war. After telling him "his services are no longer required", she drops Septem out a hatch in the plane. And then shoots him in the head on the way down.
- Outsiders #6; Supervillain cult leader Brother Blood has just engineered a mass prison break and demands that all the villains he freed join him. Airstryke the Pterodactyl Man is less than thrilled with this:
Airstryke: Hey, Jim Jones, what if we don't want to help your religious freakshow ass!
- In Dynamite's The Shadow #10, one of the conspirators gets cold feet and asks to be excused. He gets it... in the head.
Films — Live-Action
- Probably the best known version is from Goldfinger, where the unfortunate investor is killed, then crushed with his car. Goldfinger then gasses the rest of the investors anyway, eliminating any potential competition after gaining their confidence.
- The trope name is taken from another James Bond film, A View to a Kill, in which the meeting is taking place on board Max Zorin's blimp, and the investor is, quite literally, Thrown From a Zeppelin.
- In The Phantom, when the Big Bad presents his plan to steal the magic skulls, one of his associates decides to leave. Oddly enough he objects on the basis that the idea is morally questionable, rather than because it revolves around magical skulls. The big bad impales him with a javelin.
- In the film North Sea Hijack, one of the hijackers gets cold feet and wants to leave with the government representatives who came to investigate (and will be trying to convince the government to pay the ransom). The Big Bad, played by Anthony Perkins (of Psycho fame), pretends to sympathize with him, and tells him he can go, but signals one of his henchmen to shoot him when he's on the lift being carried off.
- In a scene from The Avengers (1998), the villain (Sean Connery) announces his plans for world domination to a room full of scientists then asks if any of them will opt out. Two scientists raise their hands to quit and the villain kills them with poison darts in front of the other scientists, unusual for this trope. The other scientists are eventually killed off anyway.
- In the 1989 Batman movie, where the Joker (Jack Nicholson) brings in the "mob bosses" of Gotham, and introduces himself as the new big boss. One of the mobsters opts out, and as they shake hands he gets the "joy buzzer" from the Joker, which rather gruesomely kills him, as a lesson to the other bosses. ("I'm glad you're dead!")... then goes on to order the deaths of the other bosses. He decides to kill them all on the "advice" of the boss he just killed note . It's the first sign that Jack, who was "just" a psychopath, is now completely unhinged.
- In The Dark Knight, the Joker pretends to have a similar tendency, but is really just planning to kill just about everyone he can, whether or not they want to be his ally.
- In The Legend of Zorro, after the Ancient Conspiracy members hear Armand's evil plans, one disagrees. As a result, Armand demonstrates his secret weapon - nitroglycerin - by throwing a small bottle of it on him.
- Dick Tracy (1990). When Big Boy Caprice offers to let the other gangsters join his operation, Spaldoni is the first to question why he (Big Boy) should be the leader. Big Boy casts an aside glance at Itchy, who steps outside the room. Five minutes later, he returns in time for Spaldoni to turn down Big Boy's offer. Big Boy had the foresight to realize that at least one of his former rivals would be unwilling to go along with the plan, and had Itchy prepared to take them out.
- Lara Croft: Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life has the villain infect his board of potential investors with a strain of "super-ebola," letting one of them die before the others sign up for his plot...and the vaccine.
- A variant occurs in The Sum of All Fears when one of the Russian scientists decides to opt-out. The villain's butler first helps him put his jacket on, then strangles him with his own scarf right in front of the other scientists before any of them can have second thoughts.
- The Jackie Chan movie The Tuxedo had the villain call in an underling who'd been publicly criticizing The Plan, and gave said underling a drink of his dehydrating water. He also uses this later on the water company executives who refuse to give their companies to him.
- Taken to absurdity in the Italian movie Danger: Diabolik; mob boss Valmont meets with his subordinates about the police's offer to team up to fight the eponymous super-crook. Three of them vote against the plan; Valmont shoots two, but misses the third, who begs for his life. Valmont agrees not to shoot... then presses a button that drops the man through a hole in the floor. When the film was riffed on the final episode of Mystery Science Theater 3000, Mike responded to the above moment by shouting "Extreme organized crime!"
- Space Mutiny has a scene where some traitorous engineers hold a meeting (at a suspiciously small table), and when one of the wimpier ones threatens to report their treason, boss engineer MacPhearson kills him with his cane.
- In Kill Bill, O-Ren declares herself the leader of the various Yakuza families, to which one of the bosses objects. She cuts off his head and then tells the remaining bosses (in English, since this is important) that she's not asking, she's telling.
As your leader, I encourage you from time to time, and always in a respectful manner, to question my logic. If you're unconvinced that a particular plan of action I've decided is the wisest, tell me so, but allow me to convince you and I promise you right here and now, no subject will ever be taboo. Except, of course, the subject that was just under discussion.
- Although it's implied that the reason she killed him, or at least killed him so brutally, was because he talked derogatorily about the Chinese and American side of her heritage.
- If Looks Could Kill: Augustus Steranko has this done to the French finance minister at the beginning. The finance minister won't sign France up for Steranko's plan to have all of Europe's gold stored in his chateau, so Steranko has the guy killed by getting bludgeoned to death with a tea tray.
- Ant-Man: When Darren Cross is giving the pitch for the Yellowjacket to the government, one man objects that given what has already happened in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the weapon could be dangerous in the wrong hands. Cross shuts him down and promises to talk about it later. In true Bond villain fashion, Cross then follows him into a restroom and uses an unstable shrinking ray to do away with him.
- Real Genius opens with a table of military and intelligence officials discussing a proposed flying death ray. One of them leaves after the "immoral and unethical" nature of the weapon is explicitly acknowledged. After he's out the door, it's implied that he's about to be silenced, one way or another.
David Decker: Afraid we're going to have to liberate George.
- In a Star Trek novel, a recruiter tells his recruits about a plan to destroy the Federation by pumping a virus through their replicators. When one of the recruits decides not to take part, he's given a pat on the shoulder and allowed to leave. He's dead from the virus 30 seconds later.
- A heroic version happens in Stone of Tears where Kahlan, before leading the remnants of a small army on midnight raids to destroy the larger, more experienced army that destroyed their home, lets a dissenter and a group leave. She then sends another group of soldiers to kill the lot of them, deducing correctly based on...something that they planned to rat them out to the larger army.
- Apparently? That anyone who wouldn't work with her, was obviously against her. With Us or Against Us.
- Moist von Lipwig is presented with two options at the beginning of Going Postal. He can become Vetinari's postmaster, or he can walk out the door behind Vetinari. Moist is smart enough to open up the door and drop an object down the inevitable pit before trying to walk out. The test is subverted in Making Money, the next Moist von Lipwig book. The door by which Moist can exit is perfectly normal and he is free to walk away and go back to his job at the Post Office. When Moist asks what happened to the pit, Vetinari claims to have no idea what he's talking about.
- At the end of Going Postal, Moist's Evil Counterpart Reacher Gilt used the door. It's ambiguous whether he stormed through without checking it or indeed comitted suicide rather than work for the patrician, though the latter would fit better with the book's theme of every freedom being based on the most basic one: the freedom to take the consequences. On the other hand, Reacher Glit is more than once portrayed as being arrogant enough to fall for it.
- The trope was spoofed in Guards! Guards!, when a huge Dragon takes over the city and his human aid explains to the civic leaders that the Dragon demands a monthly Virgin Sacrifice. They're all waiting for someone else to protest, so they can mumble a quiet agreement so that the others know they obviously don't like this deal without having to be so stupid as talk back to the Dragon. When they all turn out to be Genre Savvy enough to keep their mouths shut, they all curse the others for being so cowardly.
- Seems to happen at least once in ever single Alex Rider book.
- In the MacGyver episode "Legend of the Holy Rose", the bad guy has his advisor with a niggling conscience thrown from a helicopter when he is of no further use.
- That Mitchell and Webb Look saw this action denied by a lack of No OSHA Compliance. After several minutes of flashing lights, a safety rail being placed around him, and a voice announcing "Trap door number four is about to open, please vacate the area" he got up and left.
- In the final part of the Doctor Who serial Genesis of the Daleks, Davros does this to his staff to sort out the dissenters from his loyal supporters. After the ones who are with him come over to stand beside him, he has the Daleks do what they do best to the ones still on the other side of the imaginary line.
- Played very straight in the Monty Python's Flying Circus episode titled "The Golden Age of Ballooning." During the inaugural flight of his new airship, Ferdinand von Zeppelin becomes frustrated because the dignitaries on board keep referring to it as a balloon. He begins throwing out anyone who uses the B-word, and keeps it up until most of the German government is dead.
- In an episode of Criminal Minds, a cult leader gives his flock juice, then tells them they'll all die from the poison that was in it. It turned out there was no poison, it was just a test to see who his most die-hard worshippers, the ones who would follow him to the end, were (those who appeared distraught or terrified at the thought of dying were kicked out of the compound).
- Pay attention to the negotiation with the mobsters at the beginning of the campaign in Evil Genius, and you'll see how one of them, after trying to back off, is the victim of your hidden shrinking beam. Incidentally, it's the same one who gave you trouble by being too ballsy and had to be "convinced" to attend by force.
- The front cover of the 8-bit Electronic Arts game Murder on the Zinderneuf depicts a murder victim meeting this fate.
- An odd heroic version occurs in The Venture Bros. episode "Tag Sale You're It". The security guards for Dr. Venture's yard sale are lined up and informed that due to the serious risk involved in working the event, any one of them who doesn't feel up to it has the option to opt out. One does. The leader quietly tells another guard to make sure he doesn't make it to the gate alive. He doesn't.
- Also in the episode "ORB" this gets inverted when Aleister Crowley puts forth a plan that is a little too daring for some people's tastes and promptly finds himself ejected from a zeppelin.
- In Superman: The Animated Series, Lex Luthor pulled this off far more frequently than you'd think a Saturday morning cartoon on the WB in the late nineties would do. Often, this involved having his bodyguard, "Mercy", escort someone home. One memorable quote:
Superman: I know about Dr. Vale. It's just a matter of time before the police find them.Lex Luthor: And what makes you think there's any of him to find?[Superman flinches]
- In Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker, Bonk complains about his gang's latest heists under their new leader, the Joker, and wants out. Joker responds by pulling a gun on Bonk and firing. Subverted in that the gun merely pops out a "BANG!" flag, and everyone sighs in relief. Then Joker immediately fires the gun a second time, killing Bonk with the flag through the torso.
- In Justice League Unlimited, Lord Chronos discovers that one of his henchmen is secretly on Batman's payroll. He sends the henchman to the time of the dinosaurs... the very end of the time of the dinosaurs, just a few seconds before the asteroid impact that wiped them out.
- Played for Laughs in Frosty Returns when Mr. Twitchell sends a board member down a trapdoor for objecting to his Summer Wheeze on environmental grounds.