troperville

tools

toys

SubpagesMain

main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
Special Pleading

Special Pleading

This is the fallacy of asking to be given an exemption to a rule that others are held to. It's typically used as an excuse for special treatment others don't receive, or to win arguments by claiming to have special insights others don't have.

"I'm a judge, so I shouldn't have to stop at red lights."

This is fallacious because even if someone has certain expertise or is part of a specific group, they still have to provide evidence and cogent reasons for their position.

A fairly well-known example is the common argument that the universe must logically have a creator. This goes

Everything that has a beginning has a cause
The universe has a beginning
Therefore the universe has a cause.

The special pleading here is that it's insisted that an ultimate cause exists; to avoid the infinite regress, it's claimed that this cause is the sole exception and does not require a beginning, and therefore does not itself require a cause.
Though this may "disprove" not only a creator, but the Big Bang, necessarily implying that the universe has no beginning, and thus that the Steady State theory is true, even though that has already been disproved, and my oh my I've gone cross-eyed.

Looks like this fallacy, but isn't:

  • When there really is a reason why someone should be given special treatment. For example, an exemption for murder is often granted for someone acting in self-defense.
    • Technically, this is a justification for the 'creator' argument, as a being who is outside of time would never require a regress point, as there would be no point at which it could have changed from non-existing to existing (time only exists where change does). Therefore, this being would have special properties (no beginning) and therefore immune from the recess issue. As logic dictates, infinite recess is impossible and "once you remove the impossible, what remains, however improbable, must be the truth!"
      • There still remains the whole "How does a being outside of time act on time?" problem, though.
      • Some theologians have thrown out the idea that since God is outside of time, He can act at all points at once, like an axle would on all of a wheel. The axle has been turning itself forever, but the wheels (universes?) are on different places on it. HAS YOUR MIND EXPLODED YET?
      • Yes, but axles imparting force upon a wheel is limited by the propogation of that force upon the matter which the force acts upon, requiring time. This does not address the issue.
  • Mitigating circumstances not admitted in trial may be considered in sentencing; after the court has established guilt, it seeks to determine what penalty the particular case warrants.
  • The philosophy of Søren Kierkegaard strikes some—especially atheists—as a kind of special pleading, since it is based on the idea of the "leap of faith", used as a justification for believing in things like miracles (which are special pleadings to the laws of nature). However, Kierkegaard's philosophy—and most sane theology since then—is essentially irrational: it explicitly argues that the rules of logic simply don't work when exploring the deeper questions of human experience. Whether or not you agree, it is highly important to understand this about that area of philosophy, and attempting to make an attack on it on the grounds of this particular logical fallacy is rather like critiquing pop music for ignoring the rules of polyphony.
  • You've done this, probably today. Want to know some good news though? You were right. You didn't drive fast because You're a careless driver but simply because You were late. You didn't get fast food because You're a glutton but because You simply didn't feel like cooking. And You didn't lose Your temper because You're a naturally angry or aggressive person but because You'd simply been pushed to breaking point by circumstances. It's just amazing that we never let anyone else have the same leeway.
Slippery Slope FallacyLogic TropesSpotlight Fallacy
Semantic Slippery Slope FallacyLogical FallaciesSpotlight Fallacy

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
5121
7