Film / Legends of the Fall

Legends of the Fall is a 1994 film based on the 1979 novel by Jim Harrison. Directed by Edward Zwick. Starring Anthony Hopkins, Brad Pitt, Aidan Quinn and Julia Ormond. It's a Generational Saga about the lives and loves of the Ludlow clan. John Toll won the award for Best Cinematographer at that year's Academy Awards.

The film's time frame spans the decade before World War I through the Prohibition era, and into the 1930s, ending with a brief scene set in 1963. It centers on the Ludlow family of Montana, including veteran of the Indian Wars Colonel Ludlow (Anthony Hopkins), his sons, Alfred (Aidan Quinn), Tristan (Brad Pitt) and Samuel (Henry Thomas), and object of the brothers' love, Susannah (Julia Ormond).

Legends of the Tropes:

  • Aerith and Bob: Tristan definitely stands out compared to his brothers Alfred and Samuel's ordinary sounding names.
  • All Girls Want Bad Boys: Susannah falls for edgy, rebellious, roguish and adventurous Tristan.
  • Artistic License History: The First World War scenes are set in the Second Battle of Ypres which occurred in April 1915. A title card proclaims the date as February. (At that time the Canadian Division, depicted in the film, had not yet fought a major battle.) Weapons and equipment worn by the extras are more correct for 1916 or later - in February-April 1915, the Canadians in France were wearing Canadian pattern uniforms, leather Oliver pattern web gear, and using the Ross rifle. The film shows them in British uniforms, gear and with Lee Enfield weapons, which would all be correct if the film took place a year or so later.
  • Bears Are Bad News: Two battles with a particular bear, the second lethal to the sole surviving protagonist.
  • Beard of Sorrow: Brad Pitt doesn't shave when he's depressed.
  • Big Brother Instinct:
    • Alfred is protective of his younger brothers.
    • Tristan is highly protective of Samuel.
  • Big "NO!": When Tristan failed to save Samuel from being killed by Kaiser soldiers, which leads to his Roaring Rampage of Revenge.
    • He lets out several when he sees that Isabel II has been shot.
  • Big "YES!": Alfred screamed this during his argument with Tristan.
    Alfred: "Damn you, Tristan. You will marry her."
    Tristan: "And make an honest woman out of her?"
    Alfred: "YESSS!!!"
  • Boisterous Bruiser: Tristan. He is a friendly and rebellious rogue.
  • Brainy Brunette: Susannah. Appears to be educated, smart, logical and practical.
  • Break the Cutie: Tristan and Susannah both suffer from the loss of Samuel. Susannah especially goes from hopeful fiancee to despairing suicide.
  • Chickification: Susannah. She appears to be one of the few female characters in the film which is predominantly male in casting. Not to mention that Susannah serves as a love interest to all three Ludlow brothers.
  • Chekhov's Gun: Literally. The shotgun Tristan gives to his father after Walking the Earth plays a big part in the finale.
  • The Chick: Susannah, who is the lone woman with any kind of screen time amongst the main cast.
  • Comforting the Widow: Susannah attempts this after Isabel II's death, to no avail. Earlier on, Tristan's affair with her was a partial example - since she and Samuel had not married yet.
  • Crapsack World: None of the characters lead particularly happy lives, even when not considering the one who committed suicide out of despair.
  • Death Is Dramatic: Tristan's final encounter with the bear at the end of the film. Also most of the other deaths scattered throughout.
  • Deadly Distant Finale: Tristan is killed by a bear in 1963, after outliving the rest of his loved ones.
  • Disposable Woman: Isabel II doesn't get much screentime until her death. And even the sole purpose of that appears to be to send Tristan off the deep end again
  • Dogged Nice Girl: Susannah repeatedly tries to get Tristan to understand the love that they share and tries to stop him from leaving her.
  • Driven to Suicide: After Tristan rejects Susannah, she shoots herself in despair.
  • Dude Magnet: Susannah. She manages to have all three Ludlow brothers falling in love with her.
  • The Dutiful Son: Alfred. Unfortunately, his idea of duty doesn't always match up with his father's idea.
  • Dying Moment of Awesome: Invoked In-Universe by the narrator on elderly Tristan's Defiant to the End death fighting with the bear he'd maimed when he was young.
    Narrator: It was a good death.
  • Foreshadowing - Mrs. Ludlow left because of bears. A bear is what kills her last surviving son years later.
  • Failure Hero: Tristan, summarized by One Stab below in Walking Disaster Area. Most of Tristan's life is avenging the deaths of loved ones he failed to protect.
  • Firing in the Air a Lot: One of the cops does this at a roadblock with a Tommy Gun to get Tristan's attention. He ends up killing Isabell.
  • Happily Married: Tristan and Isabel II have a happy marriage, in contrast to Tristan's wild and destructive affair with Susannah. Unfortunately, Isabel dies.
  • I Will Wait for You: Susannah says this to Tristan before he leaves. Subverted in that Susannah didn't wait and ended up marrying Alfred.
  • Impaled with Extreme Prejudice: This is how the younger O'Banion brother met his end.
  • Important Haircut: Susannah hacks off her hair prior to committing suicide.
  • The Irish Mob: The O'Banions, the only group of bootleggers prominently depicted, are Irish.
  • It's Personal: Implied heavily by the narrator at the end that the bear Tristan had maimed decades ago was looking for payback.
  • Karmic Death: Tristan is killed by the bear he maimed.
  • Love at First Sight: All of the Ludlow brothers in regards to Susannah.
  • Love Confession: Alfred confessed his love for Susannah in a rather awkward situation.
  • Love Hurts: What do you expect when all three brothers fall in love with the same girl? Or when a girl's fiance dies tragically in battle? Or when unrequited love takes place? Or when the man you love abandons you, never comes back for years at a time, and then writes you a letter telling you: "All that they had is dead. MARRY ANOTHER"? And when the woman couldn't be with the man they really love, they commit suicide?
  • Love Triangle: More like a love rhombus or love square, with all three Ludlow brothers falling in love with Susannah.
  • The One That Got Away: Tristan for Susannah. She always loved him but eventually, the love was unreciprocated.
  • Parental Abandonment: The Ludlow brother's mother left because she wasn't comfortable with the living situations. She felt there were too many bears.
  • Parental Favoritism: Col. Ludlow seemed to show favoritism towards Tristan.
  • Perfectly Arranged Marriage: Tristan and Isabel II. From the time that Isabel was a girl, she has said that she was arranged to marry Tristan when she is of age.
  • Please Don't Leave Me: As Tristan was leaving the Ludlow Ranch to find himself, Susannah begged him to stay. Despite her best efforts, Tristan was adamant. She responded, "I Will Wait for You. Even if it takes forever."
  • Precocious Crush: Isabel II, a child, has one on the much older Tristan. When she grows up, it turns into actual love.
  • Proper Lady: Susannah. She is ladylike and polite.
  • Rapunzel Hair: Susannah in true period tradition has beautiful waist length hair. Notably she still keeps it into the 1930s when shorter hairstyles were the fashion.
  • Rebellious Spirit: Tristan. He is adventurous and carefree by nature.
  • Regal Ringlets: Susannah. She is long, curly hair.
  • Removed from the Picture: After Tristan went away for many years without any communication, Alfred managed to marry Susannah after years of unrequited love. When Tristan came back, that was the beginning of Susannah's emotional descent which ended with her being Driven to Suicide.
  • Roaring Rampage of Revenge: Tristan is none too pleased when Isabel II is killed.
    • Nor when Samuel was killed earlier. He'd actually already killed the Germans who killed Samuel during his rescue attempt. The ones he scalped were just another set of enemy soldiers.
  • The Roaring '20s: Part of the Prohibition-related chapters.
  • Sanity Slippage:
    • Tristan pulling a knife on Susannah when he woke up.
    • When Tristan beat the racist bartender with his own billy club after he refused to serve One Stab.
    • And again when he nearly beats the cop to death with his own machine gun after he inadvertantly killed Isabel II
  • Scenery Gorn: Trenches littered with decaying fallen soldiers during World War I.
  • Scenery Porn: From the Ludlow ranch to the African Safari.
  • She Is All Grown Up: Tristan' s reaction to Isabel II when he returns.
  • Shoot the Shaggy Dog: By the end, what has been accomplished? Everyone Tristan loved died, and then he died too.
  • Shirtless Scene: Tristan has a few shirtless scenes throughout the film.
  • Single Woman Seeks Good Man: Susannah. First with Samuel and then with Alfred.
  • The '60s: The final scene takes place in 1963, though you'd never know it.
  • Snow Means Death: They buried Samuel's heart during the winter.
  • Spurned into Suicide: Susannah kills herself after Tristan rejects her.
  • Star-Crossed Lovers: Tristan and Susannah oh so much. When they first meet, Susannah is engaged to (and seems to love) his younger brother. They have an affair after his death, but Tristan abandons her and marries Isabel II. Even after Isabel's death, he rejects Susannah and she ends up killing herself. Tristan lives out the rest of his days without marrying another.
  • The Three Faces of Eve: Interestingly enough Susannah fits into all three roles depending on what brother she's with. When she is with Samuel in her youth, she is the Child (an Ingenue; sweet and innocent). The brother she actually marries - Alfred - turns her into the Wife. In her passionate affair with Tristan, she becomes the Seductress.
  • Tragedy: Most of Tristan's loved ones died tragically while he outlived them.
  • Tragic Dream: Susannah wanted to bear Tristan's children when they were still together. Unfortunately for her, Isabel II filled that role. Despite what her letter says regarding her fond wishes for the birth of Tristan's children, she was in reality utterly devastated.
  • The Unfair Sex: Inverted. In a scene from the trailer, the Colonel yells at Susannah for being nothing but trouble since she came to the house. Rather than the son that made a pass at his brother's fiancée.
  • The Unfavorite: Even from the beginning the Colonel doesn't favor Alfred nearly as much as he does Tristan or Samuel, and their relationship only grows colder. Alfred knows it, too.
  • Unrequited Love: Susannah for Tristan. Susannah is madly in love with Tristan but he insists that Susannah moves on and marries another. She does end up marrying Alfred after not being able to wait for Tristan forever.
    • Also, Alfred for Susannah. Alfred was in love with Susannah, but she was in love with Tristan. This is subverted when Susannah marries Alfred.
  • Victorious Childhood Friend: Isabel II marries one of the three guys that grew up with her.
  • Walking Disaster Area: Tristan. Everyone he loved died young. According to One Stab:
    I thought Tristan would never live to be an old man. I was wrong about that. I was wrong about many things. It was those who loved him most who died young. He was a rock they broke themselves against however much he tried to protect them.
  • "Well Done, Son!" Guy: Alfred's decisions constantly alienate him from his father. When he compromises his ethics in a Big Damn Hero moment, he finally reconciles with the Colonel, giving each other a long, heartfelt hug.
  • What Happened to the Mouse?: The Sheriff and the O'Bannions arrive at the ranch looking for someone, who's picture resembles ranch hand Decker. Decker even leaves upon seeing them come to up before they can get a good look at him. The Colonel and Albert make up a story about the man in the picture having been there years earlier, but left to go oversees. We never find out why the O'Bannions are looking for Decker, nor why they show no interest when he's in the car when Isabel II is shot. It's entirely about having an excuse to introduce the villains and corrupt Sheriff.
  • When She Smiles: An epic one given by Julia Ormond's character. Siskel & Ebert raved about it in their review.