Did whoever write this section actually see Madoka Magica Rebellion?
Hide / Show Replies
The in-depth discussion is mostly in Magic and Chaos Pantheon. Though Lucifer is the main reason of the Upheaval and the Sisterhood acknowledges him as their nemesis, Homura is still enemy no. 1 for betraying Madoka and creating chaos among the Sisterhood. Though more information and potential season2 can cause further retcon.
Edited by 36.70.48.101
TheScrappy and ButtMonkey of the Pantheon Thread
I want to know just how to add Lucia Nanami, Goddess of Idol Singers into this sisterhood. Technically, she's a Magical Girl, albeit her 'specialty' setting her apart from other Magical Girls is through the use of songs to defeat her foes.
TV Tropes Pantheon Group Members Database
Given that Disgaea D2 reveals that Flonne is a magical girl (Pure Pink is her MG identity), I think she deserves a posistion. Problem is where? Her power set is Light 'em Up, healing, and its fueled by her being a Love Freak. Also, in the series, she's also a rather nasty caster if properly trained.
Note: Pure Pink is also a Pretty Cure reference.
Edited by 76.227.148.238
The Ultimate Kamen Rider
Hmmmm, lot of Pretty Cure being staged... any reason to the sudden flood of characters?
Hide / Show Replies
Well as said, there's no rule of how many characters per series are allowed to be in the Pantheon, so it's not just a Sisterhood problem itself. Puella Magi Madoka Magica main characters are ALL there (Madoka, Homura, Sayaka, Mami, Kyouko, Kyubey), and we haven't even brought the Splash Star, Suite or DokiDoki Cures. But most importantly, Precure itself is pretty big, it stood strong as not just one of Toei's Cash-Cow Franchise (aside of Kamen Rider and Super Sentai and other Tokusatsu) but also keeping the positive Magical Girl Warrior stuff up in times where Sailor Moon went incumbent (no offense).
I knew how it felt, someone once complained about the many many of Blaz Blue entries in the Pantheon. Or hell, I'm eyeing at the many many entries of characters in Asuras Wrath or Metal Gear Rising Revengeance. But... that's not against the rules... so far.
I know Sailor Moon also deserve more than Usagi/Serena. So I'm always open for entries about those gals.
Just curious, Leangle, but... you're not very familiar with Pretty Cure, are you?
Edited by 69.172.221.2
As far as PM3 goes... I was trying to avoid having every single character annotated to godhood. But it happened anyway. So I can't say that I am completely responsible for that (I am responsible for the most of it, however).
The only reason that I am asking about it is to insure that characters are being put up for the right reasons, mostly for being memorable. With something like Pretty Cure, I am forced to relay on your judgement unless it is a series that I have seen to some extent.
Sailor Moon does deserve more representation than what is currently, BUT... again, I want to have those in the series that stand out to the genre and are memorable. That limits things but makes for less removals in the long run. I am currently staging Tuxedo Mask for this reason, my conflict on that matter is that the character is... when looking back at it, overwhelmingly negative. Not quite what I was expecting.
Me, Pretty Cure....No, I am not really familiar with the franchise. I have caught a few of them, but that has more to do with the fact that I am a Kamen Rider fan and they show up in a cosponsoring time slot than anything else.
Edited by 216.99.32.45
I know how you feel when a franchise you're not familiar with has gotten a lot of coverages here. But I assure you, there's a reason that it's called one of the Cash-Cow Franchise of Toei, along with Super Sentai and Kamen Rider. It may not be as dark as Madoka, but it's garnered enough popularity and as I said... kept the flag of Magical Girl Warrior flying even when Sailor Moon was incumbent, until it's time for the remake to come out, and even then, it may even air together.
As of a new Sailor Moon rep... hm... try Ami Mizuno/Sailor Mercury (she is one of the more popular/fan-fave Sailor Scouts after all). Wasn't she usually said as the best example of Shy Blue-Haired Girl...? Then again this isn't the proper discussion page to discuss it.
If you're wondering Why I'm replying to this, it's because I'm the person in question who complained about ALL of the Blazblue characters in the pantheon.
Being an optimist is not as fun as it goes.
Well since you're not very familiar with Precure, Leangle... you mind if I take care the applications of the Sisterhood and reasonings to join of the Precures here?
I think Puella's representation has more to do with the impact it had. The work basically redefined how we look at an entire genre.
@troy56: I know, there is a record of it.
@magnum12: As much as I do agree with you, the timing of their entry would bring that into question. I did make the suggestion about a day after the final episode aired... and honestly underestimated the impact of the show. That said, I am not sure that the genre has reacted... half in part due to the fact that what PM3 suggested is not simply hung by the bounds of being Darker and Edgier but by good writing, which is harder to do. There other half would be that, outside of better writing, world-building, etc., doesn't seem to be a need to top PM3... yet. Sailor Moon might have an answer to that, but that might also be wishful thinking on my end. And doesn't account for the unknowns that might answer that....
@ChrisX: You handling application entry into the All-Stars? Sure, but don't be surprised if there is an edit here or there from me.
As to the goddess-hood suggestion, the main discussion page is best place to discuss it.
Edited by 216.99.32.45
.....
Leangle, as much as I know Reika can do piloting once she has the manual of a mecha, I don't think she'd be fitting to become the ambassador for Hikaru/Umi/Fuu. I've watched MKR to know fully the details and thus:
- Rayearth, Selece and Windam doesn't have a frickin' manual to pilot.
- They made it so only their Magic Knights CAN pilot them, The Chosen One and all. I'm not sure if in this Pantheon rules they'd make an exception for a certain Pretty Cure (and stretching that, only Selece would accept being substituted with Reika, Rayearth and Windam have differing elements, and the respective Precures that deal with fire or wind has yet to be deified (can be from Yes! instead of Smile))
So... how will it go?
Edited by ChrisX Hide / Show Replies
Ok, that was unexpected... I guess that I will have to defer to your judgement on this one. Because MKR is something that I am not at all familiar with.
With respect to that, my reasoning was simply to leave her as an assistance due to the manual limitation... it more or less leaves her limited to Mook's and nothing else
Edited by TheLeangle
.....
We need a proper formatting within this new section. First, we have to get into the 'sisterhood' format AKA 'having reason for Sisterhood'. And if it's okay, this seems to be similar to the GUAG Magical Girl Division, so with permission, we'll just transfer those from the Division to the Sisterhood. AND having everyone getting the standard 'reasons to join GUAG, loyalty and threat level things'. (And thanks for getting Nagisa and Honoka there)
And 'friends/allies of the Sisterhood'... is this necessary? It's just so far copy-pasting from the House of Magic, without consideration that they are from the Magical Girl Genre or not. I'm just... gonna remove that for the moment until further notice.
Also usually in the GUAG vs GUAE stuffs, for the moment we do not post pictures, so will be removing that for the moment. Anyway, that's about it for now, Chris X signing out to make those edits. Any complains, we can discuss here. Thank you!
Edited by ChrisX Hide / Show Replies
Also Leangle, next time you put up an edit, don't just look like copy paste-ing from a notepad or something, taking away all the updates I got. First off:
- Every GUAG/GUAE related pages do not use 'Domains'.
- Every GUAG/GUAE related pages always have 'Loyalty to Cosmos' and 'Threat Level to Cosmos'. I'll let this slide for the helpers, but for the sisters, saints, they have to be in.
- Again, every GUAG/GUAE related pages... do not use pics.
I'm gonna re-add my features in this newest edits.
I say keep it. Having them around does serve as a good counter measure to over loading the GUAG Combat Division.
Also, we should place Flonne, Marona, and Raspberyl here (perhaps as helpers) since in their respective series, they are casters.
I was wondering if it's possible to have Twilight Sparkle from MLP here?
She may be a unicorn, but she qualifies as a magical girl in a way. Though her series is more slice of life but each season usually ends with them showing their magical girl prowess, most notably the season 4 finale.
I was thinking she should be more of an ally than a full member.
After hearing the sisterhood's misfortune. Twilight sets out of Equestria to help them as best as she can. With the blessing of Princess Celestia, her motivation is to unite the once proud group to strengthen their bond once again. She feels it's part of her mission to go beyond Equestria in hopes of restoring the magic of friendship to the sisterhood. Along with the help of her friends (the mane six) and her managerial abilities, it attracted the attention of Nanoha as she vouched to let the founders hear her out.
Also with the title Princess of Friendship. Nanoha could be a prominent collaborator to her cause.
Well is it alright? I'll fix this once it gets approved
Edited by MiracleQuartz