Ask The Tropers

open

A DMOS entry for Frozen 2 being removed Film

bookworm 11 has just removed a The Lucky Cat's Dethroning Moment of Suck page for Frozen II with them claiming only one moment allowed and that the entries are but the thing is, the troper who added this page didn't even have another entry in the page not to mention that regardless of what was stated are true or not, it's their own opinion they can do whatever they want. Here's the entry in question before it's removed:

• The Lucky Cat: This movie is such a mess when it comes to plot, but definitely my biggest gripe is how rushed the climax is. After Elsa "dies", Olaf begins to melt and Anna sings a song about her grief. Then she has a vision of her grandfather killing the tribe leader while his back was turned. Which already comes off like kind of an Ass Pull, because how does she know it's a trustworthy vision? But she deduces that in order to lift the curse on the forest, she has to destroy Arendelle dam. So she gets the earth ogres or whatever they are to chase her to the dam, only to be blocked by her father's kingsguard. She explains to them that they need to destroy the dam because her grandfather betrayed the tribe and Elsa died to learn this information. The Kingsguard instantly believe Anna, because...reasons? Seriously, they instantly take her word for it because she's her father's daughter. They don't question how she knows Elsa's dead, how Elsa died, how she knows these visions are valid or how she can be sure flooding Arendelle is really the solution. So the earth orges manage to destroy the dam, Anna falls, on no! Oh...Kristoff and the head guard saved her, nevermind. Then a giant flood comes to destroy Arendelle! Oh, nevermind, Elsa freezes the waves by arriving just in time on her magical ice horse. (Okay, admittedly that bit is pretty cool.) Then Anna gets made into Queen of Arendelle because Elsa wants to go live with her mother's tribe instead. I'm sorry, but Anna's actions in this movie really don't make her seem like she'd be a suitable Queen. She constantly prioritises clinging onto her sister over Arendelle's future, like when she gets mad at Elsa for making Kristoff take her out of the forest (when Elsa rightly points out Anna has no powers, Anna replies that didn't stop her chasing Elsa in the previous movie, even though doing that meant she'd left Hans in charge and got struck in the heart for her troubles), then she tries to follow Elsa to the iceberg that contains the mystery of her parents. Again, Elsa points out that they can't both go, but it never seems to occur to Anna that if both of them died out there (and Elsa comes very close), the family line is extinguished and it would leave Arendelle ripe for someone like Hans or the Duke of Weselton to come and take it with nobody on the throne, but it takes Elsa putting Anna and Olaf in a boat and sending them back down the mountain to get rid of Anna at all and Anna still doesn't concede that maybe Elsa insisting someone stay behind to watch over their people is a sensible idea. But she's just made into Queen because yadda yadda, two bridges between clans, blah blah. Considering the movie felt like it had time to waste in the beginning with the characters farting around playing charades or Kristoff singing a love song with a bunch of reindeer, the pacing is shockingly bad.

What do you guys think? Did the moment felt specific enough? Do they broke any of the established DMOS rules?