- Accidental Innuendo: Sometimes seen in Colemanballs / Commentatorballs, and they also occasionally publish examples of this from newspaper articles (this used to be a much more prevalent feature, back when manual typesetting meant that amusing typos were more common in newspapers).
- Broken Base: Their treatment of Julian Assange is unrelentingly negative - as far as the Eye is concerned, he is a shifty, anti-Semitic, irresponsible, vain sex offender. This has fractured the base into people who agree with this treatment and people who think that the Eye and Assange are natural allies.
- Life Imitates Art: Following the abduction and murder of Sarah Payne in 2000, the News of the World ran a name and shame campaign against alleged paedophiles. An Eye cartoon showed a hate mob chasing a paediatrician, mistaking him for a paedophile. Whilst the issue was on sale, a paediatrician in South Wales had her house vandalised by people who had taken her job title to mean she was a paedophile.
- Memetic Mutation: The Eye's nicknames for newspapers are regularly used by people who have never read and have barely heard of Private Eye. For a more narrow, political audience, their euphemisms such as "tired and emotional" and "discussing Uganda" are well known.
- "Weird Al" Effect: Some phrases the Eye has kept going are now more associated with it than their original progenitors, such as "as any fule kno", which comes from molesworth.
YMMV / Private Eye