When an Italian-American insurance salesman tries to get Michael to buy a policy for the branch, the staff become convinced that hes in the Mafia. Meanwhile Kevin is hanging out in Jims office while he and Pam are on their honeymoon but ends up accidentally stealing his personal information.
- Idiot Ball: The rest of the staff, save Oscar, for thinking Angelo Grotti the insurance salesman is in the Mafia. Notably Michael actually needs a little convincing from them before he believes it, too.
- Only Sane Man: Oscar is the only one who doesnt think that Angelo is in the Mafia. He says that with Pam and Jim away and Toby having mentally checked out, the coalition for reason is extremely weak.
- Shout-Out: Inevitably a couple to The Godfather and The Sopranos.