The film has been criticized by people on the sides of both Knox and Kercher, with Knox's lawyers trying (and failing) to keep the film from airing on Lifetime and attempting to block its airing on Italian television, and Kercher's parents expressing distress over the film's portrayal of their daughter's murder; those involved with the movie have stated a desire to present the story as impartially as possible, and indeed some criticized Panettiere's performance for not making Knox crystal clear one way or the other. (On the other hand, the movie has gotten several good reviews for its acting - business as usual for Panettiere and Harden, but somewhat unusual for a Lifetime Movie of the Week.)
The movie has since been amended to note Amanda Knox's and Raffaele Sollecito's acquittal on appeal on October 4, 2011. note (Rudy Guede, also found guilty, remains in prison.)
This movie contains examples of:
- Made-for-TV Movie
- Ripped from the Headlines
- What Happened to the Mouse?: While detectives are looking at Amanda's knives, Amanda then experiences a panic attack that's subdued only after she is taken out of the kitchen. Not only was a reason for what brought on her panic attack never given note but it was never mentioned again.