- Every time you see Slender Man/The Administrator, take a sip.
- Take a small sip every time Noah says 'fuck', or some variation of it.
- If you have a liver of steel, any foul language will do.
- Two sips if it's a Cluster F-Bomb.
- Every time there's a Shout-Out to Marble Hornets, take a sip.
- Every time you see the Observer symbol, take another sip.
- Two sips if it's followed soon after by a disembodied eye
- Every time there's a crossover with another series, take a sip (but only if the characters of said series actually appear on camera).
- Every time a Collective member is mentioned by name, take a sip.
- Every time the Slender Man is mentioned, take a sip.
- Every time Noah's bare feet appear on camera, take a sip.
- Every time Firebrand does or says something that mirrors Noah's words/actions, take a sip.
- Every time you find a Freeze-Frame Bonus flashing across the screen in the episode Fortunes take a sip.
- Every time you see a Freeze-Frame Bonus in general take a sip.
- Every time you hear Mongo's screeching in the background during the Fortunes Arc, take a sip.
- Any time Future Noah says something that makes no sense in "Sisyphus", take a sip.
- Every time a version of Noah or a fortune makes a pop culture reference, take a sip.
Drinking Game / Tribe Twelve