Follow TV Tropes

Following

Alternative Character Interpretation / Dhar Mann

Go To

  • Redeemed Dhar Mann villains have often been subject to this. Are their Heel Face Turns a result of truly seeing the error of their ways, or do they simply change their tunes when they realize the person who they harassing before turns out to be rich and influential/did something that benefited them or someone they loved? The mom from "Mom Accuses Her Son's Black Friend of Stealing" is an almost infamous example.
  • Often times, Dhar Mann videos centering around a child and their parent who refuses to accept the career path they wish to pursue end with the parent coming around and accepting their child's ambitions. However, in these cases, this acceptance comes after the child's career has led to them becoming successful and wealthy. So are these parents truly repentant of their actions or are they simply greedy vultures giving fake apologies and support now that their children have become rich through the career they once dismissed as a waste of time? The latter interpretation is especially felt in videos like "Mom Forces Daughter to Marry Rich" or "Straight "A" Student Drops Out of College," where the parent's lack of support segues into what could be considered straight-up child abuse.
  • If one looks at most of the situations in various episodes and sees it through different perspectives, many of the friendships, relationships, and families that the protagonists have could pretty much be a toxic and dysfunctional mess if put in a different light.
  • As some viewers point out, Mikey's family could be interpreted as abusive and dysfunctional if the situations' put in a different light and context. His mom plays favorite over Jayden and him, with her obviously favoring the former and his dad is heavily implied to be abusive, if his anger and punishments towards Mikey and Jay, as well as the former flinching at him in "Kid Fakes Sick Note To Skip Class," is any indication. And while Jayden does try to genuinely help his brother, as soon as his mom outright says something along the lines of not getting Mikey's hopes up, Jayden happily goes along with the very blatant favoritism since he's enjoying himself. This in the long run causes Mikey to slowly resent Jayden. This type of family dynamic is practically an example of Parental Favoritism, Abusive Parents, and Sibling Rivalry rolled in one huge toxic mess. This Tumblr post goes into deep detail on just how messed up Mikey's family situation really is.
  • In a similar sense, Jay's mom is shown to be just as bad and problematic as Mikey's mom. She also engages in the harsh punishments of her son's bad behaviors, as clearly shown when both moms gang up on their sons in "Kid Steals Tickets At Fun Center" and snitching on Mikey for helping Jay fake a broken arm when she could've easily just left it alone since it wasn't even that serious of a scheme. And these are just a few examples of how problematic both moms can be.
  • Adding to the two paragraphs above, the Mikey and Jay storylines could be interpreted as two troublemaking kids trying to cope with their Abusive Parents and escape their oppressive school by rebelling against the system, no matter how far and dangerous each scheme gets, only to fail and get harshly punished each time, with their peers agreeing with the strong punishments and nobody ever siding with them in the end, leaving the two to only have each other to fall back on.
  • The ex-wife from "Wife Sues Ex-Husband Over Child Support." While her withdrawing her bid for sole custody is painted as her having a Heel Realization about how her ex-husband's love for their daughter matters more than money, it's possible that she's actually Secretly Selfish. After all, she only does this after she and her rich boyfriend break up, so it's possible she's only dropping her lawsuit out of a desire to continue receiving the child support payments her ex was presumably paying her before she decided to take him to court.
  • In "Single Mom Shamed by Soccer Mom," is Tina's harassment of Samantha solely based on her belief that a child can't thrive in a single parent household? Or is she a Politically Incorrect Villain acting on racism and classism? It's notable that Samantha seems to be the school's only Black parent and the only one not in a cushy financial situation. A similar question is applicable to Miss Karen from "Teacher Accuses Student of Doing Drugs" and her accusations against Marcus. Are they simply a result of her recklessly jumping to conclusions, or did she already have a racial bias against Marcus and used him apparently being a drug addict as her opening to humiliate him in front of her class and attempt to have him expelled? Incidentally, both characters are played by Katherine Norland.
  • Coach Garrison from "Coach Kicks Gay Athlete Off Team." Is his recruiting Liam to play on his team after Coach Brown throws him off his original team the benevolent act the video portrays it as? Or is he just an Opportunistic Bastard who sees Liam's unjust dismissal as the chance to poach his rival's star player? Garrison not making any mention of reporting Brown for his blatant discrimination against Liam fuels the latter interpretation.
  • Brittney and Carla's father from "Babysitter Abandons The Child". Is he a good father who genuinely cares for both his daughters and wants his eldest one to learn to be more responsible? Or is he actually an emotionally abusive parent who plays Parental Favoritism towards his daughters with Carla obviously being his favorite?
  • Amelia from "Dad Abandons Wife And Teenager". Is she genuinely happy for her dad being a better father to his other kids and really did move on from that part of her life? Or does she secretly still hold some resentment towards him and possibly jealousy towards the other kids and is hiding it to look strong in front of her mother? Is she being influenced by toxic positivity as well and is forcing herself to accept everything?
  • Nadia from "Little Sister Steals From Big Sister". Is she a genuine friend who cares about Kenzie's wellbeing and doesn't want her to get in trouble, while also sympathizing with Rachel's feelings? Or is she a Dirty Coward who tries to avoid any conflict to help Kenzie with by not telling Rachel and/or the sisters' mom anything and not comforting Kenzie after the whole arresting scheme was revealed? Only wanting to keep herself safe from Kenzie's family drama?
  • In "Kid Makes Teacher Quit Job", with how harsh she is about her son's gradesnote , and how she still punishes Elliot for a small prank he played on Mr. Smiley (who was clearly caught being aggressive towards the students by the principal), which she does in front of his classmates, complete with an ear-drag, despite him also improving his grades, it can be assumed that Elliott's mother is too strict and/or worse, just as bad as Mr. Smiley. While this wouldn't excuse his actions, it would explain all of Elliot's acting out throughout the story.
  • Was Falynn from "Mean Girls Shame Teen's Skin Issues" bullying Sasha solely on the basis of her having vitiligo? Or was there also a racial component to her harassment? She's shown being just as nasty towards Sasha's supporters (all of whom are people of color) and at one point, even threatens to call the police on them if they don't vacate the area she reserved for her makeup shoot—a classic Karen move. The deliberately classist undertones of her harassment of Sasha (she keeps mocking her by saying she doesn't have the money or connections to make her makeup line successful) provide support to this interpretation.

Top