History YMMV / Jacksepticeye

* ItsShortSoItSucks: A lot of ''VideoGame/HenryStickmin'' fans were displeased that Jack's playthrough of ''[[GrandFinale Completing the Mission]]'' only covered 5 out of the 16 story routes, nor did Jack go for every fail as he did in prior games. The fact it's clear Jack didn't replay any of the previous games, to refresh his memory of the characters or story doesn't help matters.

* FandomRivalry: Thanks to his ''Undertale'' playthrough, Jack's fans have taken to going after Website/YouTube voice-actors like David Near, [[https://youtu.be/gWruOgh6yac who had to disable the comments on his own Flowey voice video due to the wrath of JSE fans]].

** When Jack first met Sans in Undertale and heard his VoiceGrunting he notes that he sounds like [[WesternAnimation/SpongeBobSquarePants Patrick.]] Several years later, people discovered his VoiceGrunting actually originates from Patrick.

* VocalMinority: In 2019, Jack started receiving criticism from tea blogs about his relationship with LetsPlay/GabSmolders, a lack of ego content in recent months, the humor of his videos, and other reasons that can be found on Tumblr. Aside from one post asking people not to needlessly spread hate, Jack has stayed out of it.

** In 2020, Jack played a game called “Wanking Simulator.” The basic (and obscene) premise of the game was that you beat up citizens in a town called “Gay” and masturbated over them. Not only was the game’s content extremely homophobic, the developers turned out to share those views. After lots of complaints, Jack took the video down.
*** Which then lead to a question among some fans. Should Jack have uploaded the video in the first place after seeing the game’s content?

** The [[HoYay Septi]][[WebVideo/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a while. Originally, Jack and Mark thought of it as harmless fun, but some fans took it way too far, such as thinking Jack and Mark were ''actually'' in a relationship, getting upset when they had actual girlfriends, trashing said girlfriends, and writing and drawing sexually explicit content of the two when Jack directly asked them not to. Due to this, Jack's attitude progressed from laughing at the ship, to tolerating it, to disliking it, to actively hating it.
** The "Jack's dad" memes immediately became this, especially when people found the fact that people were literally dedicating time to making fun of Jack's deceased father to be very tasteless and crude, especially when it's been pointed out to be done by immature younger watchers thinking it was somehow funny.

** Jack and LetsPlay/{{Mark|iplier}}, with their newly dyed hair, are now being referred to as [[WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents Cosmo and Wanda]] respectively.

** The [[HoYay Septi]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a while. Originally, Jack and Mark thought of it as harmless fun, but some fans took it way too far, such as thinking Jack and Mark were ''actually'' in a relationship, getting upset when they had actual girlfriends, trashing said girlfriends, and writing and drawing sexually explicit content of the two when Jack directly asked them not to. Due to this, Jack's attitude progressed from laughing at the ship, to tolerating it, to disliking it, to actively hating it.

** Three days before an incident happened with [[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} Mark's friend Daniel]], [[https://youtu.be/9KsNm0_LFC4 Jack accuses Mark]] of being sad and depressed in a joking manner[[note]]Mark got a new video editor, Matt from Cyndago[[/note]]. After what has happened, it's a lot more chilling than it sounds.

* HoYay: The shipping fandom of [[PortmanteauCoupleName Septi]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]].

* ShipSinking: The HoYay shipping with both Mark and Jack has been this for the both of them as they got sick and tired of the fact that the entire thing grew out of control to the point it became too sexual and uncomfortable for both men.

* ItsShortSoItSucks: A lot of ''VideoGame/HenryStickmin'' fans were displeased that Jack's playthrough of ''[[GrandFinale Completing the Mission]]'' only covered 4 out of the 16 story routes, nor did Jack go for every fail as he did in prior games. The fact it's clear Jack didn't replay any of the previous games, to refresh his memory of the characters or story doesn't help matters.

* WhyFandomCantHaveNiceThings: While at first he thought him getting shipped with Mark was all fun and cool and understands that the fans do need some shipping outlet, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dB6olIOIAjg he started hating it]] as it became too sexual that he asked people to stop making it sexual as he was already getting uncomfortable with it.

** The [[HoYay Septi]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a while. Originally, Jack and Mark thought of it as harmless fun, but some fans took it way too far, such as thinking Jack and Mark were ''actually'' in a relationship, getting upset when they had actual girlfriends, trashing said girlfriends, and writing and drawing sexually explicit content of the two when Jack directly asked them not to. Due to this, Jack's attitude basically progressed from laughing at the ship, to tolerating it, to disliking it, to actively hating it.

* NeverLiveItDown: [[https://youtu.be/hqt33lvPYk0 His gaffe at his PAX West 2016 panel]] in which a person dressed up in [=iDubbbz=]'s "Green Cunt" costume asked him "Have you seen the movie ''Film/{{Chef}}''?", which is a meme from [=iDubbbz=]'s collaborative videos with WebVideo/FilthyFrank, and Jack unintentionally ruined the joke since he didn't know anything about the meme. He ''did'' make up for it when he appeared as a cameo on Frank's "HUMAN CAKE" video where he (alongside WebVideo/{{Jontron}}, [=Makemebad35=], Joey Salads, KSI, LetsPlay/{{Pewdiepie}}, [[WebVideo/TheNeedleDrop Anthony Fantano]], and [[spoiler: friggen ''V Sauce'']] gave Max ''his pubic hair'' for their cake. AuthorsSavingThrow and {{Squick}} rolled in one.

** The [[HoYay Septi]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a while. Originally, Jack and Mark thought of it as harmless fun, but some fans took it way too far, such as thinking Mark and Jack were ''actually'' in a relationship, getting upset when they had actual girlfriends, trashing said girlfriends, and writing and drawing sexually explicit content of the two when Jack directly asked them not to. Due to this, Jack's attitude basically progressed from laughing at the ship, to tolerating it, to disliking it, to actively hating it.

** The [[HoYay Septi]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a while. Originally, Jack and Mark thought of it as harmless fun, but some fans took it way too far, such as thinking Mark and Jack were ''actually'' in a relationship, getting upset when they had actual girlfriends, trashing said girlfriends, and drawing sexually explicit content of the two when Jack directly asked them not to. Due to this, Jack's attitude basically progressed from laughing at the ship, to tolerating it, to disliking it, to actively hating it.

** The [[HoYay Septi]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a long while. Originally, Mark and Jack played around with the ship and were fine with it, but following people taking it too far with the sexual content and getting upset at the sheer idea that Jack and Mark had found girlfriends, the two began to distance themselves from the ship.

** Both Markiplier and Jack constantly tease at this, such as Mark proclaiming himself the wife in ''The Forest''.

** The "Jack's dad" memes immediately became this, especially when people found [[DudeNotFunny the fact that people were literally dedicating time to making fun of Jack's deceased father to be very tasteless and crude]], especially when it's been pointed out to be done by immature younger watchers thinking it was somehow funny.

** A smaller one, but in the part 1 of his VideoGame/HuniePop video, he mentions that changing color of your hair is no big deal and he can do it without breaking a sweat. He eventually actually dyed his hair [[YouGottaHaveBlueHair green.]]

* FunnyAneurysmMoment:
** During his video of ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoV'' with ''Franchise/StarWars'' mods, he tosses a sticky bomb at a helicopter with a cry of "Kobe!". This was uploaded in December 2019. About a month later, Kobe Bryant suddenly and unexpectedly perished in a helicopter crash alongside his teenage daughter.

* VocalMinority: In 2019, Jack started receiving criticism from tea blogs about his relationship with LetsPlay/GabSmolders, a lack of ego content in recent months, the humor of his videos, and other reasons that [[Administrivia/RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment can be found on Tumblr]]. Aside from one post asking people not to needlessly spread hate, Jack has stayed out of it.

** The Wanking Simulator video, for reasons described above.
* DiscreditedMeme: The [[HoYay Septic]][[LetsPlay/{{Markiplier}} plier]] ship became this after a long while. Originally Mark and Jack played around with it and had fun with the ship and were fine with the fans doing so, but following people taking it too far with the sexual content and getting upset at the sheer idea that Jack and Mark found girlfriends, the two began to distant themselves from the ship.
** The "Jack's dad" memes immediately became this, especially when people found [[DudeNotFunny the fact people were literally dedicating time to making fun of Jack's deceased father very tasteless and crude]], especially when it's been pointed out to be done by immature younger watchers thinking it was somehow funny.