History YMMV / Caddicarus

-->'''Caddy:''' [[LackOfEmpathy You've lost at least twelve friend points giving me this game.]]

** One in the ''VideoGame/PlaystationAllStarsBattleRoyale'' review when they claim that "the game forces you through the tutorial". This (slightly paraphrased) transcript of the leadup to the claim explains everything:

* RetroactiveRecognition: Caddy's sister started making regular appearances on ''WebVideo/PlaystationAccess'' in 2019, making her appearances in his videos this for ''Access'' fans.

--> '''Game''': Would you like to play the tutorial?
--> '''Caddy''': No.
--> '''Game''': Are you sure?
--> '''Caddy''': No.

** Caddy's praise about ''[[VideoGame/SilentHills P.T.]]'' becomes uncomfortable when Konami removed the game from the PS Store, which in turn later on led up to the cancellation of ''Silent Hills,'' but would eventually be rebirthed into ''VideoGame/DeathStranding''.

** The more positive-leaning review on ''VideoGame/CrashTeamRacingNitroFueled'' became less fun to watch now that {{Microtransactions}} have been added to the game. When Caddy found out about this, he was ''genuinely angry''. As an extension, the "Cash Banooca" RunningGag ended up being used as a joke that Creator/{{Activision}} took the "Cash" part seriously.

-->'''Caddy:''' But hey. At least I know that if I want to get to heaven, [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror all I have to do is fly a plane into a building]].

* MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales: Reactions to the Christian satire made all throughout ''The Unholy World of Jesus Games'' from Caddy's Christian fans has been mainly positive, with them citing that Caddy has clearly [[ShownTheirWork Shown His Work]] in the topics present, and overall finding the lighthearted jabs made at their culture to be ActuallyPrettyFunny.

* GrowingTheBeard: Quite literally. The quality of his show seems to have grown along with his beard.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: The initial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney [=PS1=] Games" was criticized immediately for having a transphobic slur. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: His intitial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney [=PS1=] Games" was criticized immediately for having a transphobic slur. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally (Though to be frank, he only really used the Slur just to make fun of a scene from Mulan being very "of its time" compared to today).

* AuthorsSavingThrow: His intitial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney [=PS1=] Games" was criticized immediately for having a transphobic slur. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally (Though to be frank, he only really used the Slur to make fun of a scene of Mulan being very ''of its time'' compared to today).

* AuthorsSavingThrow: His intitial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney [=PS1=] Games" was criticized immediately for having a transphobic slur. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: His intitial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney [=PS1=] Games" was criticized immediately for having two transphobic slurs. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally.

** Caddy's constant snark at ''WesternAnimation/PeppaPig'' and by an extent, his constant PapaWolf / ThinkOfTheChildren attitude in many of his videos have slowly grown into this as well. Some find his attacks at ''Peppa Pig'' to be justified, as is his heavy PapaWolf elements due to caring for Cerys's daughters because of it, but some feel the constant snark and videos on ''Peppa Pig'' have overstayed their welcome and his heavy defensive towards children at times invoke the BiasSteamroller for some.

** In his review of the video game adaptation of the [[WesternAnimation/GeorgeOfTheJungle 2007 animated series George of the Jungle]] on the UsefulNotes/PlayStation2, he mistakes the Dr. Scott for a chef, since said character is working on a cure for common cold in the game, it’s made even more jarring by the fact that Caddy mentions that it’s a job for a scientist rather than a chef, and even looked up [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_of_the_Jungle_(2007_TV_series) the series’ Wikipedia page]] which has list describing the show's main characters, but he only mentions that the show was made in [[UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash Flash]] and that the titular character had two different voice actors over the span of its two seasons.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: His intitial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney PS1 Games" was criticized immediately for having two transphobic slurs. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: His intitial release of his "The Demonic World of Disney PS1 Games" was criticzed immediately for having two transphobic slurs. He immediately removed the video and edited them out and rereleased it the following day, apologizing profusely for having them in the video originally.

** Mostly averted with his ''VideoGame/DeathStranding'' review. Though many of the game's fans were perturbed that he gave up just before the game "gets good," most seemed to agree that he shouldn't have to wait ten hours for a game to get good, even if he was nine hours in.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: He ends his review of the ''Crash Bandicoot'' cartoon by slaughtering it, the gag being that he shoots directly at his screen, therefore [[RealityEnsues destroying his computer]] and remarking he now needs a new [=PC=]. In early 2021, building a new computer brought him a lot of problems that would culminate with him spending roughly $10,000 on faulty tech and cancelling an episode after accidentally deleting all gameplay footage of it.

* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: Some people feel Caddy doesn't offer anything new and is just repeating himself through his Caddicarus show. Most fans now are just waiting until he finally does his retrospective on ''Franchise/SpyroTheDragon''.

** Caddy plays a ''VideoGame/{{Columns}}'' clone in the ''Net Yaroze'' video and praises it for being an interesting take on ''Tetris'', seemingly unaware that it's an already-established video game series best known for being on the UsefulNotes/SegaMegaDrive. When someone mentioned this on his Tumblr, he admitted he never heard of the game due to not being familiar with Sega growing up.
** A similar case happens in the same video as above. In this case, Caddy doesn't seem to be aware that ''Bouncer 2'' (which is praised in the same way as how he commented on ''Columns'', albeit comparing ''Bouncer 2'' with ''VideoGame/{{Breakout}}'') is basically a clone of ''Atari Circus''. People had begun pointing that out in the comments as well.

** In his otherwise-very-positive review of ''VideoGame/{{Cuphead}}'', he complains that you can't buy everything in the shop in one playthrough. While you can't buy everything if you only get the coins from the run-and-gun stages, there are enough coins hidden throughout the overworld that you ''can'' buy everything in the shop.
** In his "Peter Pancreas" review, he miscredits Creator/DingoPictures as the creator of both ''Peter Pan'' and ''Snow White and the Seven Clever Boys'', despite the fact that Phoenix Games only ported Dingo's library to the [=PS2=] and Dingo themselves fizzled out around the turn of the century. In actuality, Aqua Pacific was the developer of ''Seven Clever Boys'' and ''Peter Pan''. He corrects this in his review of Animal Soccer World, noting the differences between the two creators.
** The order of his reviews of the ''Kingdom Hearts'' series. Most games he takes a look at are in the correct order of release...however, he reviewed ''358/2 Days'' '''before''' ''Kingdom Hearts II'' (it's an {{Interquel}} game set before II, but made after it) and reviewed ''Dream Drop Distance'' before ''Birth By Sleep.'' To compound the issue, his original title of his ''Kingdom Hearts II'' review was (and he's since moved this sentence to the description of the video), "it should really be called 'Kingdom Hearts IV'" and also says that he doesn't care about the right order in his description of it. Yeah, because ''that's'' how chronology goes within the ''Kingdom Hearts'' series for sure, Caddy!

** In his ''Resident Evil'' review, a Fun Fact segment claims the original soundtrack was composed by Mamoru Samuragochi who had hired a ghost composer because he was going deaf. The original music was actually done by Masami Ueda, and Samuragochi (and his ghost composer) only did the ''Dual Shock'''s replacement music. Samuragochi's deafness has also been exposed as a lie since the mid [=2010s=] with his hiring of a ghostwriter as an attempt at covering his lie up. Furthermore, Caddy claims that because of licensing issues with Samuragochi and his composer, all rereleases of the game would be of the ''Dual Shock'' version with the replacement music...which is completely untrue for the European PS Store version of the game, which is the previous ''Director's Cut'' version with Ueda's soundtrack, is also untrue for the DS version of the game, ''Deadly Silence'' which uses Ueda's music unaltered and would also make no sense for the Gamecube remake which uses remixed versions of Ueda's music which, if licensing issues were apparently a thing, would not be the case.
** In his ''Caddy's Retrospectives'' episode on ''[[VideoGame/{{Tekken}} Tekken 3]]'', he states that Jun Kazama "gets decapitated" after her fight with Ogre. For the record, Jun is canonically [[HesJustHiding missing]]; Ogre hoding her head the arcade intro was shown in her son Jin's (who spent most of the fight having been knocked out by Ogre) perspective, and is based on what he thinks happened during that duel.
** In his video on ''[[VideoGame/CrashTwinsanity Crash Twinsanity]]'' he gets upset over the game invoking the EvilTwin trope with Evil Crash, despite the fact that Evil Crash is ''not'' Crash's brother but instead an EvilCounterpart from the 10th Dimension. The fact that Caddy even looked into the cut content of ''Twinsanity'' makes this more baffling as the morality-swapped versions of the main cast are some of the more well-known pieces of cut content from the game.

** In both ''Peppa Pig HAS A MUSIC CAREER'' and ''The [=PS5=] LEAK looks....problematic....'', Caddy criticizes lines[[note]]"best"/"dress" in the former and "keep"/"seat" in the latter[[/note]] for not rhyming going so far as to say they "don't work at all." This is despite the fact that near rhymes - rhyming in which the words sound the same but do not rhyme perfectly - are widely used and are seen as an acceptable substitute for "perfect" rhyming, especially in music. The example in the former video is especially baffling as the words sound so alike that it should be negligible, yet he treats it as though it is a major problem on par with his other criticisms.

** '''''ROSIE''''', Caddy's sister, who appeared frequently at times, who's maybe even ''more'' of a CloudCuckooLander [[UpToEleven than Caddy himself]]. [[https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9XJTgiunZKkqLu2O7o7_wA Helps she has her own YouTube channel]]!

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: He ends his review of the ''Crash Bandicoot'' cartoon by slaughtering it, but because he shot at his screen, [[RealityEnsues he destroyed his computer]] and remarked he now needs a new [=PC=]. In early 2021, building a new computer brought him a lot of problems that would culminate with him spending roughly $10,000 on faulty tech and cancelling an episode after accidentally deleting all gameplay footage of it.