Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Music / Garbage

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FreeHandedPerformer: Shirley Manson provided backing vocals and keyboards for the band Goodbye Mr Mackenzie. Following that, the founding members of Garbage were looking for a female lead vocalist and she took on the role. Despite playing guitar on some of the band's albums, she only sings on stage.

Changed: 22

Removed: 165

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* {{Fanservice}}: Played straight most of the time but is zigzagged on occasion. Videos such as "Vow", "Queer", "Run Baby Run" and "Blood for Poppies" downplay this by having Shirley in normal attire while other videos feature her in short dresses. "I'm Think I'm Paranoid" (see PantyShot below), "Cherry Lips" (An invisible Shirley sees her [[DressHitsFloor clothes fall off]] and walks naked to the bathroom) and "Bleed Like Me" turn this UpToEleven. Also, the video for "Androgyny". To quote: "It has men who look like attractive women, women who look like attractive men, Shirley Manson wearing a rather sexy outfit that looks like a weird hybrid between suit and a dress, Shirley Manson wearing suspenders and the aforementioned androgynous people, in various states of undress, doing vaguely hinted at things with each other in a tightly-packed environment. Something for everyone, really."

to:

* {{Fanservice}}: Played straight most of the time but is zigzagged on occasion. Videos such as "Vow", "Queer", "Run Baby Run" and "Blood for Poppies" downplay this by having Shirley in normal attire while other videos feature her in short dresses. "I'm Think I'm Paranoid" (see PantyShot below), Paranoid", "Cherry Lips" (An invisible Shirley sees her [[DressHitsFloor clothes fall off]] and walks naked to the bathroom) and "Bleed Like Me" turn this UpToEleven. Also, the video for "Androgyny". To quote: "It has men who look like attractive women, women who look like attractive men, Shirley Manson wearing a rather sexy outfit that looks like a weird hybrid between suit and a dress, Shirley Manson wearing suspenders and the aforementioned androgynous people, in various states of undress, doing vaguely hinted at things with each other in a tightly-packed environment. Something for everyone, really."



* PantyShot: Parodied in "I Think I'm Paranoid". Shirley plays with her dress in the video and frequently lifts it up slightly or kneels down in front of the camera.

Added: 443

Changed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkerAndEdgier: ''Strange Little Birds'' stands out as one of their most downbeat albums, and it was deliberate, with [[https://web.archive.org/web/20161002020505/http://mushroompromotions.com/bios/album-bio-garbage-strange-little-birds-liberator-musicstunvolume-out-friday-10-june-2016/ Shirley saying]] she found the pop landscape "incredibly happy and shiny and poppy" and needing some dark and dismal.



** "Special" samples Music/{{Pretenders}}' "Talk of the Town". Chrissie Hynde's lawyers denied the band permission to use the sample, but Shirley got Chrissie on the phone and got Chrissie to write a letter giving the band permission to sample "my music, my lyrics; indeed, my very ass".

to:

** "Special" samples similarly has Shirley quoting from Music/{{Pretenders}}' "Talk of the Town".Town", leading to a sample. Chrissie Hynde's lawyers denied the band permission to use the sample, but Shirley got Chrissie on the phone and got Chrissie to write a letter giving the band permission to sample "my music, my lyrics; indeed, my very ass".



* SanitySlippageSong: "The Creeps".



* TakeThat[=/=]SexIsLiberation:
** "Sex Is Not The Enemy" is very much aimed at MoralGuardians and UsefulNotes/GeorgeWBush criticizing their attitudes about love and sex. (Shirley declared that a major inspiration was the outcry following Music/JanetJackson's WardrobeMalfunction).

to:

* TakeThat[=/=]SexIsLiberation:
TakeThat:
** [[SexIsLiberation "Sex Is Not The Enemy" Enemy"]] is very much aimed at MoralGuardians and UsefulNotes/GeorgeWBush criticizing their attitudes about love and sex. (Shirley declared that a major inspiration was the outcry following Music/JanetJackson's WardrobeMalfunction).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cut trope


Garbage are an American AlternativeRock group from Madison, Wisconsin. They basically play [[NeoclassicalPunkZydecoRockabilly alternative rock with heavy pop, electronic, and industrial influences]].

to:

Garbage are an American AlternativeRock group from Madison, Wisconsin. They basically play [[NeoclassicalPunkZydecoRockabilly alternative rock with heavy pop, electronic, and industrial influences]].
influences.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaning


* YouGottaHaveBlueHair: To celebrate the debut album's 20th anniversary, Shirley dyed her hair the same pink featured on the cover. ''Strange Little Birds'', released one year later, still has her with that color.

Added: 317

Changed: 109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMcCoolName: "I read that I'd made it up as a mixture of Creator/ShirleyTemple and UsefulNotes/CharlesManson — and I wish I had — but, yes, it is my name."

to:

* AwesomeMcCoolName: "I read that I'd made it up as a mixture of Creator/ShirleyTemple and UsefulNotes/CharlesManson — and I wish I had — but, yes, it is my name."" Not that Butch Vig, Duke Erikson, and Steve Marker don't roll off the tongue well too.



* EyeScream: "Blood for Poppies" has Shirley's left eye being slit open in a shout out to the 1929 film ''Film/UnChienAndalou''.

to:

* EyeScream: The video for "Blood for Poppies" has Shirley's left eye being slit open in a shout out to the 1929 film ''Film/UnChienAndalou''.



* GenreMashup: The band wanted to break out of the straightforward rock they either played or produced for the previous decade, thus mixing in elements of electronica, pop, funk and hip-hop.



* IntercourseWithYou: At least half of ''Version 2.0''[[note]]"I Think I'm Paranoid", "Hammering in My Head", "Push It", and [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin "Sleep Together"]] are pretty blatantly about sex. "Temptation Waits" and "You Look So Fine" are about sexual attraction, and [[spoiler:"When I Grow Up" has references to unprotected sex and [[{{Squick}} "golden showers"]]]].[[/note]] "Alien Sex Fiend", "Bad Boyfriend", "Sex Never Goes Out of Fashion", "Anonymous XXX" is about prostitution and the lack of emotional connection it involves.

to:

* IntercourseWithYou: At least half of ''Version 2.0''[[note]]"I Think I'm Paranoid", "Hammering in My Head", "Push It", and [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin "Sleep Together"]] are pretty blatantly about sex. "Temptation Waits" and "You Look So Fine" are about sexual attraction, and [[spoiler:"When I Grow Up" has references to unprotected sex and [[{{Squick}} "golden showers"]]]].[[/note]] [[/note]], "Alien Sex Fiend", "Bad Boyfriend", "Sex Never Goes Out of Fashion", and "Anonymous XXX" is about (about prostitution and the lack of emotional connection it involves.involves).



* NewSoundAlbum: ''Bleed Like Me'' focused less on the electronics trying to reflect the band's raw and loud live performances.



* NothingButSkinAndBones: ''Bleed Like Me''.

to:

* NothingButSkinAndBones: ''Bleed "Bleed Like Me''.Me".

Added: 162

Changed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And then ''Strange Little Birds'' ends with "Amends", a particularly resentful and pained BreakupSong, to bring the trope back on full force.

to:

** And then ''Strange Little Birds'' ends with "Amends", a particularly resentful and pained BreakupSong, to bring the trope back on full force. It even makes the follow-up's closer "This City Will Kill You" seem upbeat by comparison.



** "Supervixen", "Vow", "Parade," "Blood For Poppies," "Anonymous XXX," "No Gods No Masters".

to:

** "Supervixen", "Vow", "Parade," "Blood For Poppies," "Anonymous XXX," "No ("anonymous" does appear) "[[TitleTrack No Gods No Masters".Masters]]" ("No master or gods to obey").


Added DiffLines:

* ProtestSong: "Boys Wanna Fight" for Usefulnotes/TheWarOnTerror, "Sex Is Not the Enemy" against MoralGuardians, and most of the songs in ''No Gods, No Masters''.

Added: 543

Changed: 618

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AscendedGlitch: The tape where they recorded "Supervixen" kept skipping, [[ThrowItIn and the band decided to keep it as they felt it worked]]. (And apparently lots of fans complained that their albums were broken, given it's the opening track...)
* AwesomeMcCoolName: "I read that I'd made it up as a mixture of Creator/ShirleyTemple and UsefulNotes/CharlesManson — and I wish I had — but, yes, it is my name." (Three guesses on [[Music/MarilynManson how]] this is HilariousInHindsight.)

to:

* AscendedGlitch: AscendedGlitch:
**
The tape where they recorded "Supervixen" kept skipping, [[ThrowItIn and the band decided to keep it as they felt it worked]].worked. (And apparently lots of fans complained that their albums were broken, given it's the opening track...)
** The opening of "Dumb" features a weird voice, that Butch Vig explained was a Spanish-speaking cab radio that somehow found itself captured as the bass was being recorded.
* AwesomeMcCoolName: "I read that I'd made it up as a mixture of Creator/ShirleyTemple and UsefulNotes/CharlesManson — and I wish I had — but, yes, it is my name." (Three guesses on [[Music/MarilynManson how]] this is HilariousInHindsight.)"



* KidsRock: Both Vig's and Marker's daughters both contributed to the final chorus of "Not Your Kind of People".

to:

* KidsRock: Both Vig's and Marker's daughters both contributed to the final chorus of "Not Your Kind of People".


Added DiffLines:

* PerformanceVideo: "Vow" is a notable case in that the band had not considered playing live, but once they performed together for the video, they decided that it worked and soon afterwards scheduled a tour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CannotSpitItOut: "Blackout" is all about the pain of keeping things inside.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ICallItVera

to:

* ICallItVeraICallItVera: Shirley owns an orange Fender Stratocaster named 'Rita'.



* RecordProducer: The band is always credited for producing its own albums. (the only outside producers were David Arnold on "The World Is Not Enough", and [[Music/TheDustBrothers John King]] on "Bad Boyfriend" and B-side "Space Can Come Through Anyone" — the other ''Bleed Like Me'' songs they worked on with him were re-recorded).

to:

* RecordProducer: The band is always credited for producing its own albums. (the only outside producers were David Arnold on "The World Is Not Enough", and [[Music/TheDustBrothers The Dust Brothers' John King]] King on "Bad Boyfriend" and B-side "Space Can Come Through Anyone" — the other ''Bleed Like Me'' songs they worked on with him were re-recorded).



* ReligionRantSong: "As Heaven is Wide" is a Type 1 [[note]]Although it's really more about somebody who has been hurt by a (supposedly) religious man than about God or religion themselves, so shades of Type 3 are also present[[/note]].

to:

* ReligionRantSong: "Subhuman". Also "As Heaven is Wide" is Wide", a Type 1 [[note]]Although it's really more BreakUpSong about somebody who has been hurt by a (supposedly) religious man than about God or religion themselves, so shades of Type 3 are also present[[/note]].man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* MohsScaleOfRockAndMetalHardness: Usually ranges from 1 (such as "So Like a Rose" and "You Look so Fine") to 5 (such as "Why Do You Love Me" and "Subhuman"), with a couple songs being a 6 (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rb7fLA5ccWg "Vow"]], "Battle in Me" and "No Horses").
* MohsScaleOfLyricalHardness: Aside from rare optimistic songs such as "Big Bright World" and "Not Your Kind of People", their lyrics usually rank from 6 to 8, given that sadness, sex and overall mental instability are recurrent (the latter two in particular peak to the point of violence in "Vow", "#1 Crush" and "Godhead").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeGuestStar: [[Music/JanesAddiction Eric Avery]] is basically all but a full time member now, as he started playing with them in the Bleed Like Me World Tour and has been their live bassist ever since, and even recorded on ''Not Your Kind of People'' and ''Strange Little Birds''.

to:

* FakeGuestStar: [[Music/JanesAddiction Eric Avery]] is basically all but a full time member now, as he started playing with them in the Bleed Like Me World Tour and has been their live bassist ever since, and even recorded on all albums since ''Not Your Kind of People'' and ''Strange Little Birds''.People''.



* LyricalDissonance: Most of their songs are cheery, with gloomy lyrics about [[BreakupSong breakups]] ("Special", ), failed relationships ("Cherry Lips", "Breaking Up The Girl"), or "I'm a really screwed person." ("Bleed Like Me", "I Think I'm Paranoid").

to:

* LyricalDissonance: Most of their songs are cheery, with gloomy lyrics about [[BreakupSong breakups]] ("Special", ), ("Special"), failed relationships ("Cherry Lips", "Breaking Up The Girl"), or "I'm a really screwed person." ("Bleed Like Me", "I Think I'm Paranoid").



* LyricsVideoMismatch: Garbage's "Special" looks like a clip out of TabletopGame/CrimsonSkies and it has nothing to do with the song.
* MaleBandFemaleSinger: The previous page image.

to:

* LyricsVideoMismatch: Garbage's "Special" looks like a clip out of TabletopGame/CrimsonSkies ''TabletopGame/CrimsonSkies'' and it has nothing to do with the song.
* MaleBandFemaleSinger: The previous page image.After demos with Vig singing, the three men decided that they should try with a woman. And then Marker catches the one time Angelfish played on MTV and the rest is history.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "The One":

to:

** "The One":One" has [[ActorAllusion a reference to something Shirley did]]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RefugeInAudacity: The videos for "Tell Me Where It Hurts", "Cherry Lips" and "No Gods No Masters".

to:

* RefugeInAudacity: The videos for "Tell Me Where It Hurts", "Cherry Lips" and "No Gods No Masters"."Anonymous XXX".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Garbage was formed in 1994 by RecordProducer Butch Vig, noted for his work with famous alternative rock acts like Music/{{Nirvana}} (''Music/{{Nevermind}}''), Music/SonicYouth, Music/TheSmashingPumpkins and Music/{{L7}}. Vig took up the position of drummer and brought in some old bandmates and fellow producers, guitarist/keyboardist Steve Marker and bassist Duke Erikson. The lineup was completed with the recruitment of Scottish vocalist Shirley Manson, formerly of alt-rock bands Angelfish and Goodbye Mr. Mackenzie. Their bandname comes from somebody commenting that Vig's remix work sounded "[[ItWillNeverCatchOn like garbage]]", a quote frequently attributed to [[Music/NineInchNails Trent Reznor]] for some reason.

to:

Garbage was formed in 1994 by RecordProducer Butch Vig, noted for his work with famous alternative rock acts like Music/{{Nirvana}} (''Music/{{Nevermind}}''), Music/SonicYouth, Music/TheSmashingPumpkins and Music/{{L7}}. Vig took up the position of drummer and brought in some old bandmates and fellow producers, guitarist/keyboardist Steve Marker and bassist Duke Erikson. The lineup was completed with the recruitment of Scottish vocalist Shirley Manson, formerly of alt-rock bands Angelfish and Goodbye Mr. Mackenzie. Their bandname comes from somebody commenting that Vig's remix work sounded "[[ItWillNeverCatchOn like garbage]]", a quote frequently attributed to [[Music/NineInchNails Trent Reznor]] for some reason.
reason.[[note]]He ''did'' call his contribution to the ''Fixed'' [[RemixAlbum Remix EP]] garbage, but that was less of hatred for his song in particular and more because of his hatred for the project in general.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Inverted with "Beloved Freak", a slow tearjerker-like ballad about accepting and embracing yourself as an outsider.

to:

** Inverted Also subverted with "Beloved Freak", a slow tearjerker-like ballad about accepting and embracing yourself as an outsider.



* ObligatoryBondageSong: "Supervixen". And "Queer". And, well, quite a lot of the first album.

to:

* ObligatoryBondageSong: "Supervixen". And "Queer". And, well, quite a lot of the first album. "Anonymous XXX" also qualifies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Push It" quotes Music/TheBeachBoys "Don't Worry Baby".
** "Special" references Music/ThePretenders' "Talk of the Town".

Added: 480

Changed: 571

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/rsz_grbg_1928.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Left to right: Marker, Manson, Erikson and Vig]]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.[[quoteright:400:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/rsz_grbg_1928.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Left
org/pmwiki/pub/images/garbage2_3.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:400:Left
to right: Marker, Manson, Erikson Vig, Manson and Vig]]Erikson]]



* DeliberatelyMonochrome: A large proportion of their videos are at least partially done in black and white. Such videos include "Queer", "Push It", "I Think I'm Paranoid", "Why Do You Love Me", "Blood for Poppies", "Big Bright World", and "The Chemicals". Part of the video for "Tell Me Where It Hurts" is done in black and green due to the usage of NightVisionGoggles.

to:

* DeliberatelyMonochrome: A large proportion of their videos are at least partially done in black and white. Such videos include "Queer", "Push It", "I Think I'm Paranoid", "Why Do You Love Me", "Blood for Poppies", "Big Bright World", "The Chemicals" and "The Chemicals". Creeps".
**
Part of the video for "Tell Me Where It Hurts" is done in black and green due to the usage of NightVisionGoggles.NightVisionGoggles, "No Gods No Masters" is mostly black and blue, and somes of Shirley's scenes in "The Creeps" are in black and red.



* FlippingTheBird: "Flipping the Bird" quotes this verbatim.



* IntercourseWithYou: At least half of ''Version 2.0''[[note]]"I Think I'm Paranoid", "Hammering in My Head", "Push It", and [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin "Sleep Together"]] are pretty blatantly about sex. "Temptation Waits" and "You Look So Fine" are about sexual attraction, and [[spoiler:"When I Grow Up" has references to unprotected sex and [[{{Squick}} "golden showers"]]]].[[/note]] "Alien Sex Fiend", "Bad Boyfriend", "Sex Never Goes Out of Fashion".

to:

* IntercourseWithYou: At least half of ''Version 2.0''[[note]]"I Think I'm Paranoid", "Hammering in My Head", "Push It", and [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin "Sleep Together"]] are pretty blatantly about sex. "Temptation Waits" and "You Look So Fine" are about sexual attraction, and [[spoiler:"When I Grow Up" has references to unprotected sex and [[{{Squick}} "golden showers"]]]].[[/note]] "Alien Sex Fiend", "Bad Boyfriend", "Sex Never Goes Out of Fashion".Fashion", "Anonymous XXX" is about prostitution and the lack of emotional connection it involves.



* LighterAndSofter: Their first, SelfTitledAlbum is quite easily the band's darkest and angriest[[note]]Since several of its songs were written before Shirley joined the band, she modified the lyrics and music (most notably "Vow") to sound more feminine[[/note]], so the rest of their discography is essentially lighter and softer in comparison. It’s subverted with ''beautifulgarbage''; although it’s musically lighter and softer with the incorporation of hip hop and electronica influences, the lyrics are more melancholic — Manson having [[CreatorBreakdown just gone through a divorce]] may be relevant.

to:

* LighterAndSofter: Their first, SelfTitledAlbum is quite easily the band's darkest and angriest[[note]]Since several of its songs were written before Shirley joined the band, she modified the lyrics and music (most notably "Vow") to sound more feminine[[/note]], feminine. [[/note]], so the rest of their discography is essentially lighter and softer in comparison. It’s subverted with ''beautifulgarbage''; although it’s musically lighter and softer with the incorporation of hip hop and electronica influences, the lyrics are more melancholic — Manson having [[CreatorBreakdown just gone through a divorce]] may be relevant.



* LongestSongGoesLast: Common, with the only exceptions being the first album, ''Not Your Kind of People'' (though the deluxe edition fits), and ''Strange Little Birds''.

to:

* LongestSongGoesLast: Common, with the only exceptions being standard editions of ''Version 2.0'', ''beautifulgarbage'' and ''Bleed Like Me'', as well as the first album, deluxe edition of ''Not Your Kind of People'' (though the deluxe edition fits), and ''Strange Little Birds''.People'', feature this.



** Inverted with "Beloved Freak", a slow tearjerker-like ballad about accepting and embracing yourself as an outsider.



* MohsScaleOfLyricalHardness: Aside from rare optimistic songs such as "Big Bright World" and "Not Your Kind of People", their lyrics usually rank from 6 to 8, given that sadness, sex and overall mental instability are recurrent (the latter two in particular peak to the point of violence in "Vow" and "#1 Crush").

to:

* MohsScaleOfLyricalHardness: Aside from rare optimistic songs such as "Big Bright World" and "Not Your Kind of People", their lyrics usually rank from 6 to 8, given that sadness, sex and overall mental instability are recurrent (the latter two in particular peak to the point of violence in "Vow" and "Vow", "#1 Crush").Crush" and "Godhead").



** Played straight with "Bleed Like Me" ("fuck"), "Cherry Lips", "Why Do You Love Me" and "Boys Wanna Fight" ("shit") and "Shut Your Mouth" and "What Girls are Made Of" ([[BreadEggsBreadedEggs both]]).

to:

** Played straight with "Bleed Like Me" and "The Men Who Rule the World" ("fuck"), "Cherry Lips", "Why Do You Love Me" and "Boys Wanna Fight" ("shit") and "Shut Your Mouth" and "What Girls are Made Of" ([[BreadEggsBreadedEggs both]]).



* RefugeInAudacity: The videos for "Tell Me Where It Hurts" and "Cherry Lips".

to:

* RefugeInAudacity: The videos for "Tell Me Where It Hurts" and Hurts", "Cherry Lips".Lips" and "No Gods No Masters".



* SurrealMusicVideo: "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pmd3UiNfNkA Push It]]", [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpRiSb_Ir-s "I Think I'm Paranoid"]], [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OdTBCgqRt4 "Blood for Poppies"]].

to:

* SurrealMusicVideo: "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pmd3UiNfNkA Push It]]", [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpRiSb_Ir-s "I Think I'm Paranoid"]], [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OdTBCgqRt4 "Blood for Poppies"]].Poppies"]], [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5YFSps8wRU "The Creeps"]].


Added DiffLines:

* VocalTagTeam: Duke joins Shirley on vocals in the ending of "Amends".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The band's gravy train slowed down somewhat after TheNineties ended, thanks to record label problems and a mixed reception for ''beautifulgarbage'' that frequently included charges of both TheyChangedItNowItSucks and ItsTheSameNowItSucks — a reception that translated into poor sales. During the TroubledProduction of their next album, they nearly broke up due to intra-band tensions in 2003, but managed to regroup and finish ''Bleed Like Me'' in 2005, which once again suffered a mixed reception but did slightly better in the charts. They went on a hiatus for five years afterwards, during which time Manson played a regular dramatic role as the liquid metal Terminator known as Weaver in ''Series/TerminatorTheSarahConnorChronicles''. Despite generally positive reactions, she didn't continue with acting. Manson announced in October of 2010 that the group had reformed and was working on a fifth album, which was released in 2012 as ''Not Your Kind of People''. The title track was used in the trailer for ''[[VideoGame/MetalGearSolidVThePhantomPain Metal Gear Solid V]]'', so the group has at least [[Creator/HideoKojima one Japanese fan]]. ''Strange Little Birds'' followed in 2016, and the band were reported to be working on another album as of 2019 (but Manson admits that they’re not the fastest creators in the business).

Their discography as of 2017:

to:

The band's gravy train slowed down somewhat after TheNineties ended, thanks to record label problems and a mixed reception for ''beautifulgarbage'' that frequently included charges of both TheyChangedItNowItSucks and ItsTheSameNowItSucks — a reception that translated into poor sales. During the TroubledProduction of their next album, they nearly broke up due to intra-band tensions in 2003, but managed to regroup and finish ''Bleed Like Me'' in 2005, which once again suffered a mixed reception but did slightly better in the charts. They went on a hiatus for five years afterwards, during which time Manson played a regular dramatic role as the liquid metal Terminator known as Weaver in ''Series/TerminatorTheSarahConnorChronicles''. Despite generally positive reactions, she didn't continue with acting. Manson announced in October of 2010 that the group had reformed and was working on a fifth album, which was released in 2012 as ''Not Your Kind of People''. The title track was used in the trailer for ''[[VideoGame/MetalGearSolidVThePhantomPain Metal Gear Solid V]]'', so the group has at least [[Creator/HideoKojima one Japanese fan]]. ''Strange Little Birds'' followed in 2016, and the band were reported to be working on another album as of 2019 (but Manson 2016 followed by ''No Gods No Masters'' in 2021 (Manson admits that they’re not the fastest creators in the business).

Their discography as of 2017:
2021:



* DownerEnding: [[OncePerEpisode Every album they ever made]] throws a depressing ballad at the end: "Milk", "You Look So Fine", "So Like a Rose" and a few others.

to:

* DownerEnding: [[OncePerEpisode Every album they ever made]] throws a depressing ballad at the end: "Milk", "You Look So Fine", "So Like a Rose" Rose", "This City Will Kill You", and a few others.



** "Supervixen", "Vow", "Parade," "Blood For Poppies".

to:

** "Supervixen", "Vow", "Parade," "Blood For Poppies".Poppies," "Anonymous XXX," "No Gods No Masters".



** OohMeAccentsSlipping: Except in "Stupid Girl", where she pronounces the word "stupid" as "stju-pid" as opposed to the American pronunciation as "stoo-pid", and adds some TrrrillingRrrs to "girl" ([[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJD21xh9Bto&t=89s something that confused the rest of the band]]). This isn't a one-off either, with the same pronunciation also present in the songs "Breaking up the Girl", "Boys Wanna Fight", "If I Lost You" and "Night Drive Loneliness".

to:

** OohMeAccentsSlipping: Except in "Stupid Girl", where she pronounces the word "stupid" as "stju-pid" as opposed to the American pronunciation as "stoo-pid", and adds some TrrrillingRrrs to "girl" ([[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJD21xh9Bto&t=89s something that confused the rest of the band]]). This isn't a one-off either, with the same pronunciation also present in the songs "Breaking up the Girl", "Boys Wanna Fight", "If I Lost You" and You", "Night Drive Loneliness".Loneliness" and "A Woman Destroyed".



* WomanScorned: "Not My Idea", "Vow", "Automatic Systematic Habit", "Fucking With You".

to:

* WomanScorned: "Not My Idea", "Vow", "Automatic Systematic Habit", "Fucking With You".You", "A Woman Destroyed".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''No Gods No Masters'' (2021)

Added: 157

Changed: 454

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EyeScream: "Blood for Poppies" has Shirley's left eye being slit open in a shout out to the 1929 film ''Film/UnChienAndalou''. "The World Is Not Enough" has a particularly notable eye-scream from Shirley Manson when she sees her robotic double enter her dressing room to kill her.

to:

* EyeScream: "Blood for Poppies" has Shirley's left eye being slit open in a shout out to the 1929 film ''Film/UnChienAndalou''. ''Film/UnChienAndalou''.
* EyeTake: In the video for
"The World Is Not Enough" has a particularly notable eye-scream from Enough," Shirley Manson gets a wide-eyed ReactionShot when she sees her robotic double enter her dressing room to kill her.room.



* FauxDeath: A [[https://schonmagazine.com/shirley-manson-is-dead-interview/ photoshoot]] for a 2019 interview featured Shirley first apparently having died, complete with police tape; then as a grisly corpse in a mortuary with foam coming from her mouth; then being made up by unseen hands to look like she's alive (including a bit of {{Fandisservice}} where she appears to be wearing only a transparent vinyl raincoat); until finally her heavily made-up "corpse" is posed in various positions. It's...disturbing and funny.

to:

* FauxDeath: A [[https://schonmagazine.com/shirley-manson-is-dead-interview/ photoshoot]] for a 2019 interview featured Shirley first apparently having died, complete with police tape; then as a grisly corpse in a mortuary with foam coming from her mouth; then being made up by unseen hands to look like she's alive (including a bit of {{Fandisservice}} where she appears to be wearing only a transparent vinyl raincoat); until finally her heavily made-up "corpse" is posed in various positions. It's... disturbing and funny.



* GenreBlindness: "The World Is Not Enough" features the line, "No one ever died from wanting too much." No one apart from every ''Film/JamesBond'' villain ever! It's subverted though when you watch ''Film/TheWorldIsNotEnough'' and realize that it's from the point of view of [[spoiler:[[VillainSong Elektra King]].]]

to:

* GenreBlindness: "The World Is Not Enough" features the line, "No "no one ever died from wanting too much." No one apart from Virtually every ''Film/JamesBond'' villain ever! It's subverted though when you watch ''Film/TheWorldIsNotEnough'' and realize ever to cross the screen died for that very reason. Justified, since it's from the point of view of [[spoiler:[[VillainSong Elektra King]].]]VillainSong.



* KissOfDeath: The video for "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5vSyxzefRE The World Is Not Enough]]" — the android Shirley Manson kills people by kissing them. The real Shirley Manson [[ScrewYourself suffers the same fate]].

to:

* KissOfDeath: The In the video for "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5vSyxzefRE The World Is Not Enough]]" — Enough]]," the android Shirley Manson kills people by kissing them. The is able to kill with a kiss. She uses it to KillAndReplace the real Shirley Manson [[ScrewYourself suffers the same fate]].Manson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Only Happy When It Rains" pokes fun at the depressive lyrics of {{Grunge}} songs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ZettaiRyouiki: The video for "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r21Qza6vadU Bleed Like Me]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "Destroying Angels" (featuring [[Music/{{X}} John Doe and Exene Cervenka]]) (2018)

to:

* "Destroying Angels" (featuring [[Music/{{X}} [[Music/XUSBand John Doe and Exene Cervenka]]) (2018)



* AwesomeMcCoolName: "I read that I'd made it up as a mixture of Creator/ShirleyTemple and UsefulNotes/CharlesManson — and I wish I had — but, yes, it is my name." (Three guesses on [[Music/MarilynManson how]] this is HilariousInHindsight)

to:

* AwesomeMcCoolName: "I read that I'd made it up as a mixture of Creator/ShirleyTemple and UsefulNotes/CharlesManson — and I wish I had — but, yes, it is my name." (Three guesses on [[Music/MarilynManson how]] this is HilariousInHindsight)HilariousInHindsight.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The album also has a ProtestSong against [[TheWarOnTerror Dubya and friends' foreign policies]], "Boys Wanna Fight".

to:

** The album also has a ProtestSong against [[TheWarOnTerror [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror Dubya and friends' foreign policies]], "Boys Wanna Fight".

Added: 51

Removed: 51

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrrrillingRrrs: "I'm only happy when it rrrains!"


Added DiffLines:

* TrrrillingRrrs: "I'm only happy when it rrrains!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrrrillingRrrs: "I'm only happy when it rrrains!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MaleBandFemaleSinger: The current page image.

to:

* MaleBandFemaleSinger: The current previous page image.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Marker, Manson, Erikson and Vig]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Marker, [[caption-width-right:350:Left to right: Marker, Manson, Erikson and Vig]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MaleBandFemaleSinger: Shirley Manson is also TheFaceOfTheBand (and the page image).

to:

* MaleBandFemaleSinger: Shirley Manson is also TheFaceOfTheBand (and the The current page image).image.

Top