TV Tropes Org
site search

A review is one person's opinion. TV Tropes doesn't have an opinion. The person who signed the review does.

sort by: type:
correct subject add a review about reviews
Last Forever-The Finale
At the time of typing this review up I just finished the Finale after quickly burning through the last season. And well to quickly sum up the finale disappointing. That's all I really have, I mean yeah there's a lot wrong with it especially from a character development and devolving stand point. But I'm somebody who burned through the entire series just last year, watched the second to last season as it aired and now the last season in a night.

The first thing I'll note is that the end, I mean the actual true ending (last 5 minutes of the episode) was written WAY before this final season was even penned. It was also filmed WAY before the last season was filmed (something you can easily tell by how young David Henrie is in scenes.) Which leads to what I feel is the biggest problem with the finale. It's something I call "Already completed ending syndrome". To qualify for "already completed ending syndrome" a show/game/other media needs to on awhile or at least enough time for characters to have significant character development, however the finale ending feels like it was written for character near the beginning or maybe the middle of the story. Jokes and elements from the beginning make a sudden reappearance for no explained reason, characters jump down several levels of character development, and in some cases (like HIMYM) the ending would have made sense years ago.

For those who have seen the Finale you can probably tell what I'm talking about. So the main reason I think many people are mad at the ending is because it was written many years ago. It's an ending the writers wanted from the beginning rather than what the characters deserve from all their character growth.
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
Last Forever Review- I am going to get maimed for this (Spoilers)
I’ve been afraid to express my opinion over vocal majorities, but I cannot sit quietly while Ted’s name stands under The Scrappy. I for one like the finale, and there are lots of people who do, they just aren’t as loud as those who hate it for some reasons I see and some that I think are highly exaggerated.

The Mother is a baby machine and Ted is a horrible person for moving on after six years of mourning her death? I think the finale established pretty well that having Tracy die was the last thing Ted would’ve liked to happen. In fact, after Ted told the story and his kids came to the conclusion that it was just an attempt to get their permission for asking out their Aunt Robin, it took some convincing before even he accepted it. With his response of “What, I just call her?” it seems to me like he hadn’t given it much thought, and his decision to approach her with the smurf penis was obviously made on the spot.

Also, Robin gets sentimental about letting Ted go for a very brief period of time and that’s it. I never really got the impression that she regretted every life decision she ever made that led them to not being together. And Barney falling in love with his daughter is absolutely hated from what I’ve seen on the internet. Why!? Yeah, so Robin couldn’t provide him with a kid, but that doesn’t mean Barney didn’t genuinely feel for her! And did people want him to fucking throw the baby on the ground!? Anything besides what I saw happen with Barney in the heartwarming scene with his daughter would’ve derailed his character even further, which people were already complaining about to begin with, so accept that Barney's true love is his daughter. Robin had nothing to do with his kid, so drop it!

As for Lily, she hardly had any loose ends to tie up. They got home from Rome, she gets pregnant, and obviously that’s portraying women in a weak way. That part is definitely stretching it.

Look, obviously they didn't nail this finale. The entire ninth season takes place at Robin and Barney’s wedding and their divorce is undermined. But people hate the sinking of their ship so much that I believe a majority of the finale hate is just looking for things about it to loath besides the divorce. Yes, I would’ve preferred if Tracy stayed alive too, but don't blow everything out of proportion with the Unfortunate Implications.

  # comments: 1
flag for mods
It's the most overrated sitcom since Friends...
Which makes sense, given that it feels like little more than Friends 2.0. The characters are just about the same, the dynamic is just about the same - to the point where, for clarity's sake, I will refer to this show as 2.0, and Friends as 1.0. The only real differences are:

A) Better actors. 1.0 only had great talent in the form of Matthew Perry (David Schwimmer was okay too, but nowhere near as good.) Here on 2.0 we have Neil Patrick Harris, Jason Segel, Alyson Hannigan, and Cobie Smulders.
B) A stupid gimmick that barely ties everything together - it's the story of one guy explaining how he got married.

Over the course of eight years and counting?

Uh, no. That concept strains credulity beyond the breaking point. I'm all for Willing Suspension Of Disbelief, but that really only applies where it's actually necessary - like, in genre stories, not sitcoms fueled by canned laughter. This is not to say, of course, that all multi-cam sitcoms are bad because they have canned laughter. It's only when the canned laughter is the only laughter in the room that it's a bad thing. I tried the first episode and, while the 2030 opening was funny, after that it went downhill fast, no matter how many supposedly funny things the four talented actors mentioned above would do. Knowing that even now, eight years later, the answer to the series' basic concept hasn't been answered, I wisely decided to give up. (I have recently heard that the next season, the ninth, will be 2.0's last. All I can say is...THANK GOD!)

The main reason why I can't stand this? Because 1.0 did the same sort of jokes 10-20 years ago, and it really wasn't funny then, either.

If I were responsible for making something like this, I would probably do it in a two-hour Apatow-like comedy film (and probably without the excessive raunch, which only Two And A Half Men and 21 Jump Street really get away with.) The comedy would actually be funny, too, and it would feel a little more real. This is why so many people watch Chuck Lorre's creations - they're not quite a reflection of reality, but they're closer to it than this dumb, gimmicky miscreation.
  # comments: 12
flag for mods
Not What I Was Expecting
I checked this show out because my friend Jonny told me to. I wasn't really expecting much, just common sitcom cheese. I was however, pleasantly surprised at what I saw. The concept was interesting, the characters were appealing, and the jokes were all around funny. I've seen most of it by now, and while it has its problems just like every other show on TV, I think it's great.

For one, the concept of making the show a sitcom may have been what drew me away. There have been some great sitcoms in the past (none of which I've actually watched, I'm just going by what I've heard), but there's no denying that there's been a noticeable drop in quality in recent years. I can only name a few good ones going on at the moment that don't operate solely on overused cliches, groan-inducing jokes, and characters that irritate me, and How I Met Your Mother is one of them.

One of the main reasons that it stands apart from other shows is all of the continuity. This, of course, stems from its unique concept of being told twenty five years before the start of the series' events. All of the continuity gives it a feeling of reality, despite other smaller details that don't, such as life-changing obstacles becoming minor plot points. I also like the show's characters. A good show always contains likable characters, and while the fan base is divided about some, namely Lily and Barney, I happen to like them all. I like that they have defining personality traits without being exaggerated to the point where they are reminiscent of cartoon characters, except for probably Barney, and yet Neil Patrick Harris is still one of the show's main attractions in my opinion (along with Jason Segel of course). I think my favorite character might be Ted, because he's a Nice Guy, The Woobie, a Butt Monkey, and The Determinator all in one character, and the show does a good job to equally balance out those characteristics.

The biggest complaint to date is that the show has overstayed its welcome and that Ted is just rambling to his kids at this point, and I know the show has to end eventually, but I'm happy with its length, because it has stayed consistently funny throughout, and it's one of those shows that you don't want to end, but you can't wait for the Grand Finale (which you know there's gonna be one).
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
A Surprisingly Entertaining Show
It's a sitcom about how a guy met his future wife, and as of eight and a half seasons, he still hasn't. And yet it's still an entertaining show. Why? Because it's one of the few sitcoms that uses its format in an interesting way. Being a story told through flashbacks, the writers are able to use a lot of callback jokes and even call forward jokes to parts of the future that we've already seen. It also has a strong continuity for a sitcom, and even eight seasons later, a gag can be remembered, like the sword duel. But even disregarding that, the show has a firm base with its characters. Barney, of course, is one of the main attractions, but Neil Patrick Harris isn't the only strong actor of the bunch. Josh Radnor can actually hit those emotional scenes really well, and is able to pull off some good comedy when given the right material. I think it says something when you find out the script for the scene in 'The Final Page' where he's telling Robin to go after Barney never called for him or Cobie Smulders to cry. Cobie is great too, and I look forward to seeing her more in the Marvel movies/Agents of S.H.E.I.L.D. Jason Segal has a strong comedic talent, but can do good emotional stuff when needed. Alyson Hannigan is probably the most down-to-earth out of all of them, but incredibly funny at the right moments. But the really great thing is that they all mesh together, and really feel like a family. How fitting that in a show about relationships, chemistry is a large part of what makes it good. Sure, it's not an award winner, and it's not very artistic (though I challenge anyone to watch 'The Time Travelers' and not feel a little sad). But at the end of the day, it's fun, and it provides lots of laughs. It's one of the few sitcoms that gets the comedy part right.
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
I'm Just Here fo Jason Segel and Neil Patrick Harris
As the title says, I only watch this show because Jason Segel and Neil Patrick Harris are among my favorite actors. Everyone else is just...bland and boring. I can't really summon up any other strong feelings about the show. That is not a good thing. Even hatred would be better than straight up apathy. None of the other characters are interesting enough for me to care about at all. I don't really think its a coincidence that Jason Segel and Neil Patrick Harris are the only actors to have careers outside of the show.
  # comments: 6
flag for mods
back to article
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy