It turns out that people have opinions about just how well works of fiction turn out. Go figure.
We figured we had better give folks a place to talk about those opinions, since we don't want that sort of judgement in the Main articles. So here we are. This is a list of the most recently edited reviews. Opinions belong to the writers. TVTropes itself obviously doesn't have an opinion about good or bad storytelling. We leave all that to these folks.
Work / Review Title Troper |
Date/ Comments |
---|---|
American Hustle /
Poor balance, but some good
Scardoll |
01/04/2014 23:58:54 |
Acolyte of Zero /
A different type
RakuroKamigama |
01/04/2014 23:00:47 |
Steven Universe /
I underestimated this show
WhaleShark |
01/19/2014 13:33:15 2 |
Agents Of SHIELD /
So-So Super Secret Spies
Blacknumber |
01/23/2014 10:47:30 9 |
Arrow /
Aims High And Rarely Misses
Blacknumber |
01/04/2014 20:59:53 |
Your Other Family /
Rather lack luster
Kishou |
01/04/2014 19:58:47 |
Spec Ops The Line /
Admirable, but extremely flawed.
LDragon2 |
11/25/2015 14:16:25 16 |
A Curse Of Truth /
Best Self-Insert fic, no doubt
TheWiseAsp |
01/03/2014 16:58:06 |
The Human Centipede /
It is what it is.
Bagpiper |
01/03/2014 16:03:33 |
The Ugly Barnacle /
Doesn't Live Up To Hype, But Still Worth the Read
Luigilewis889 |
07/13/2014 13:22:58 1 |
Dudley Dursley And The Quest For Truth /
Not worth it, I'm afraid
TheWiseAsp |
01/03/2014 15:30:02 |
Prisoners /
I'm Torn Apart
TommyNinja |
01/03/2014 06:34:44 |
In Blood Only /
Best "Severitus" fic
TheWiseAsp |
01/02/2014 20:45:15 |
Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull /
Would Be As Good As Raiders, Except For 2 Things
Lale |
02/03/2014 23:20:42 5 |
Outsourced /
Manages to be both funny and respectful
Terrie |
01/02/2014 12:02:23 |
Music And Lyrics /
Sweet and Charming
Terrie |
01/02/2014 11:48:21 |
Tangled /
Believe the hype.
Sikon |
01/02/2014 08:47:23 |
The Secret Life Of Walter Mitty /
Uneven, but its heart is in the right place.
Sikon |
01/02/2014 08:01:07 |
Being Human US /
What You Are In the Dark
Blacknumber |
01/02/2014 20:25:07 1 |
Enders Game /
Interesting premise, objectionable morality.***Spoilers***
imperium |
09/14/2018 10:07:19 7 |
Sounds Like A Breakfast Cereal /
This is GOOD.
TheWiseAsp |
01/01/2014 20:55:42 |
The Potions Masters Nephew /
I disagree.
TheWiseAsp |
01/01/2014 20:52:37 |
Jurassic Park The Game /
Here Be Spoilers
Emp |
01/01/2014 14:09:41 |
Substitute School, First Semester /
Passable
mito9 |
01/01/2014 10:59:42 |
Another Story /
Why?
mito9 |
01/01/2014 10:34:31 |
Avatar The Last Airbender /
Good, but not God's gift to western animation
Eagal |
05/01/2020 09:51:25 107 |
Neds Declassified School Survival Guide /
Classic, if not Instantly
Lucymae2 |
09/11/2018 18:58:25 1 |
Planet Sheen /
Really Just Not That Good
Lucymae2 |
12/31/2013 10:57:04 |
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei /
It is exactly how it seems
dylanmc12 |
12/31/2013 10:53:16 |
GI Joe The Rise Of Cobra /
Pointing Fingers and Blaming People
ZeroCredibility |
12/31/2013 06:37:47 |
Duck Amuck /
One of the greatest cartoons of all time, if not THE greatest.
AdelePotter |
09/30/2018 10:30:37 1 |
Latias Journey /
Good Plot Marred by Excreable Execution
DialgaX |
10/10/2015 10:30:38 9 |
Problem Children Are Coming From Another World Arent They /
Despite appearances
caimthehero |
12/30/2013 18:54:39 |
Puella Magi Madoka Magica /
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica Review
mahounekoshoujo |
12/30/2013 18:48:02 2 |
Superman Vs The Elite /
The best Superman movie
winchesterbros |
12/30/2013 13:49:13 |
Planet Of Dinosaurs /
Predecessor of Walking With Dinosaurs.
laplaneteetlesoleil |
01/01/2014 09:29:50 2 |
Folly To Be Wise /
Case-fic meets Character Study
StarValkyrie |
12/29/2013 20:18:01 |
The School For Good And Evil /
An Experienced Writer, and it Shows
SilverWings |
12/29/2013 19:15:25 |
Albus Potter Series /
This series was great!
hunterman |
03/02/2014 16:15:39 1 |
Xenon /
Try Tube Shot
Yeah,Imsweet. |
12/29/2013 06:36:28 |
Mystery Babylon /
Mystery Babylon and Gender Flips
Alrune |
12/29/2013 02:46:58 |
Fire Emblem Awakening /
Once back into the frey!
VanceXentan |
12/28/2013 22:36:19 |
PAYDAY The Heist /
Left 4 Dead 2 Meets Cops vs. Robbers
VanceXentan |
12/28/2013 22:28:39 |
Oblivion Island Haruka And The Magic Mirror /
A Japanese Wizard of Oz
Sijo |
12/28/2013 21:26:46 |
Divergent /
A Decent Series
gneissisnice |
12/28/2013 18:55:22 |
Guide Me Home /
Gets right what so many other fanfics get wrong
Blazar |
12/28/2013 10:15:44 |
The Wind That Shakes The Barley /
A ludicrously perfect film.
Lt.Fred |
07/20/2014 14:49:40 1 |
Star Wars The Old Republic /
Bounty Hunter Story
SpectralTime |
12/27/2013 23:09:09 |
Alfies Home /
don't know how this would work as a bedtime story, awful read
iliketurtles |
12/27/2013 16:04:03 |
My Little Pony Equestria Girls 1 /
Not Great, But Worth a Watch
twixieshores |
09/20/2014 12:17:10 3 |
To The Moon /
Some spoilers here
xpikch3rxframex |
01/01/2014 17:16:13 2 |
Bio Shock Infinite /
Whether you are killing for a cause, you're still killing people!
ArthurS |
01/12/2019 18:39:26 15 |
Kingdom Hearts /
A story about The Chosen One now focuses on Fansservice
ADOGSNIPER |
12/27/2013 14:06:43 1 |
A Clash Of Kings /
The War Has Begun
RoyFlowers |
12/26/2013 22:57:29 |
My Immortal /
WTF did I just read
Yuki-chan |
06/29/2014 19:14:21 1 |
Elf /
Couldn't finish watching this sleigh reck
iliketurtles |
09/11/2018 19:03:59 2 |
Beyond The Wall /
Beyond The Wall
WhatTheSpoot |
12/26/2013 07:51:46 |
Pokemon X And Y /
A beautiful, amazing game with a slightly awkward story. [Spoilers ahead, don't read if you don't want any]
KitWolf |
01/29/2014 17:28:46 12 |
My Little Pony Equestria Girls 1 /
It's kinda horrible.
CodaFett |
12/25/2013 15:50:42 |
Iron Druid Chronicles /
Do not buy the hype
seekquaze1 |
12/25/2013 16:03:19 5 |