Pages that need the YMMV banner:

Total posts: [1,546]
1 ... 46 47 48 49 50
51
52 53 54 55 56 ... 62
Looking more closely at the description for Scenery Porn, I think the actual problem with it is Trope Decay. The description says it's about "emphasis on detailed backgrounds", yet pretty much every example I have ever seen is just gushing about how freaking awesome the visuals are.
1252 AnotherDuck23rd Sep 2013 10:04:25 PM from Stockholm , Relationship Status: Chocolate!
No, the other one.
I agree with that. The trope should be about when more effort than necessary is spent on backgrounds, or when they're significant in their own right. Not just above the bare minimum, or just pretty backgrounds.
Check out my fanfiction!
1253 SeptimusHeap23rd Sep 2013 10:41:49 PM from Zurich, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
A Wizard boy
Trope Decay (real or possible; can't check right now) aren't on their own a reason to make something YMMV, so I've downvoted Scenery Porn.
[up]I never said it was. I'm saying the problem is not what I originally thought it was. That's why I've changed my vote.
1255 SeptimusHeap24th Sep 2013 02:25:14 AM from Zurich, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
A Wizard boy
You did originally propose to make it YMMV. That is what I was responding to.
1256 MagBas26th Sep 2013 05:41:15 AM from In my house
Bumping to votes.
1257 MagBas28th Sep 2013 03:25:12 PM from In my house
Bumping to votes again. Common Knowledge is with 7 yes and 0 nays makes two days.
1258 MagBas2nd Oct 2013 10:04:18 AM from In my house
Bumping to votes. Common Knowledge is 8 yes and 1 nay and Do Not Do This Cool Thing is 6 yes and 3 nays.

edited 2nd Oct '13 10:04:52 AM by MagBas

1259 MagBas4th Oct 2013 09:19:34 AM from In my house
Bumping to votes again.
1260 MagBas6th Oct 2013 12:51:30 PM from In my house
Common Knowledge is 8 yes and 1 nay makes at least 4 days. Well, at least Do Not Do This Cool Thing received votes(2 nays, to be more exact).
1261 MagBas8th Oct 2013 05:54:16 AM from In my house
Bumping to votes.
1262 MagBas12th Oct 2013 10:37:57 AM from In my house
Bumping to votes again.
1263 MagBas13th Oct 2013 02:12:39 PM from In my house
Calling Common Knowledge( 9 yes and 1 nay)
1264 MagBas15th Oct 2013 08:08:21 PM from In my house
All the blue examples were called. I guess that a new crowner is a good idea.
1265 MagBas24th Oct 2013 07:48:43 PM from In my house
Bump. I do not know how create a new crowner.
I see that Do Not Do This Cool Thing is nominated, but is there some kind of discussion on it?
1267 MagBas25th Oct 2013 07:34:24 AM from In my house
Post 1244: "I propose we add the banner to Do Not Do This Cool Thing since "cool" is subjective."

Post 1245: "...While that's a strange way to put it, I can support that. A description that's written largely in second-person is not the sign of an objective trope."

Post 1246: "I awould rather worry about that first folder first. What is up with it?"

Post 1247: "Well, including Do Not Do This Cool Thing in the crowner."

edited 25th Oct '13 7:34:44 AM by MagBas

Does Age-Inappropriate Dress have an objective standard?

It talks about the "cultural norm", but fails to specify if it is the cultural norm of the viewer, the creator, or the in-universe culture.

Also, even within a given culture, such as "Western culture", "American culture" etc, there is a lot of diverse opinion as to what constitutes appropriate dress for various groups of people. One person's idea of normal teenage fashion might have their neighbors going "I can't believe they let their kids dress like that!"
Contemptible Cover seems like a clear case of an Audience Reaction to me. Added to the crowner.

[up]I believe Age-Inappropriate Dress is about characters that dress inappropriately *according to in-story norms*, and are perceived as such by other characters within the story.
It's perfectly possible to admire building a cannon to destroy the moon, whilst lamenting the act of destruction.
1270 SeptimusHeap12th Nov 2013 12:36:58 PM from Zurich, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
A Wizard boy
Most examples don't specify the standard used, though.
[up] True. I see what I said is what the trope should be.

I believe Age-Inappropriate Dress is a case for a Trope Repair Shop then. I don't think it should get YMMV status, as this means revoking its trope status. A viewer making a subjective observation in a show is not a trope.

edited 12th Nov '13 1:50:05 PM by LordGro

It's perfectly possible to admire building a cannon to destroy the moon, whilst lamenting the act of destruction.
1272 DracMonster2nd Dec 2013 10:41:58 AM , Relationship Status: Singularity
Gambit Roulette appears to be an Audience Reaction. Its very first paragraph includes one.
Seeking for Light
I don't think it actually is; I think it's just not necessarily written in the best way. A Gambit Roulette is a series of gambits, each of which relies on the previous ones coming off exactly as expected, even though the factors which affect success depend on chance (i.e. are unpredictable). As noted in the description, this long string of events coming off perfectly can strain suspension of disbelief, which is why one way of identifying a gambit roulette would be to pay attention to when you go "that couldn't have worked that perfectly!". But that's not the only or the most reliable way; the improbability of things working exactly as planned can be judged objectively.

edited 2nd Dec '13 11:11:45 AM by Nocturna

Could we just... not have Death anymore?
It would be an audience reaction if one rare thing needed to happen, but the roulette always depends on several factors that are improbable. The definition is simply difficult to write objectively.
1275 DracMonster2nd Dec 2013 04:10:36 PM , Relationship Status: Singularity
[up] and [up][up] Hmm, ok fair enough.

Page Action: YMMV Banner 4
17th Aug '14 8:08:24 AM
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
YMMV is for items that are reactions of the audience to works and tropes that need a significant judgment call to tell whether they exist objectively or not.

Should these items become members of YMMV?

Total posts: 1,546
1 ... 46 47 48 49 50
51
52 53 54 55 56 ... 62