The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

They alllook adult to me!

Naw...

Finished Shortbus. Struck me as being more about how utterly miserable the characters were. The sex just kind of happened. Give the page a scrubbing if necessary and keep an eye on it. Provisional angelhead.

edited 3rd Aug '12 4:20:53 PM by tdgoodrich1

... Eh, works for me. Giving it an angelhead, too.

Series.Merlin got flagged again.

Can you guys give that person a talking to?

I would ask a mod to check in to it, but it was already zapped by the time I read that.

In entirely unrelated news, I gave Druuna Morbus Gravis an angel, since everything seems to suggest it's just a terrible adventure game and not in violation of or content policies.

Cool. Thanks, Shima.

edited 4th Aug '12 7:43:19 AM by tdgoodrich1

They've been taken care of. They're just someone repetitively careless who doesn't use the forums so we just gave them a P5 ban.

Can someone remind me what a "P5 ban" entails?

No flagging, no posting here and access to the edit-banned thread.

Oh hey, one of us resolved both Albedo Erma Felna EDF to keep and Strange Acquaintances to cut. What should we focus on now?

Here's the stuff that's close to done.

• Koihime†Musou - 2 angel, 0 devil
• Daiteikoku - 0 angel, 2 devil
• Darling - 0 angel, 2 devil
• An Ordinary Sex Life - 0 angel, 2 devil
• Hoshizora no Memoria - 0 angel, 2 devil
• The Sex Star - 0 angel, 2 devil
• Shortbus - 2 angel, 0 devil

And here's the stuff we don't have any links/info for (based on a cross-reference with the links thread), in case anyone cares to take a look or wants to prepare a case:

• Deserving
• Druids
• Retarded Animal Babies
• The Anatomy Of A Fall
• Miss World 96 Nude (this is obviously something that probably doesn't need a lot of review, being some porn tacked onto an arcade/puzzle game)
• Slave World (think there might have been some discussion on this, but it's not in the links thread)
• Ethereum Gladiator (has a link, but probably needs a more in-depth look).
• Gore Screaming Show (I thought there was some discussion on this, but I don't think we have any links)
• Darling (2 devil heads already though)
• Legend of the Blue Wolves (1 link, may need a more in-depth look)
• Fill The Moon (1 link, may need a more in-depth look)
• Shintaro Kago
• CaptainGerBear (creator page. Not a work to review as such.)
• Grant
• Bartleby Tales
• An Ordinary Sex Life (2 Devils already though)
• Hell MOO (1 link, may or may not need a more in-depth look)
• Suika
• The Sex Star (2 devil heads already though)
• Zestar Apple Flambe
• Shortbus (discussed earlier this page in fact)
• Marquis de Sade (This was also discussed just a little way back too)

edited 4th Aug '12 5:06:10 PM by UltimatelySubjective

Suika

• When are the sex scenes located?: Near endings. There's a fairly low amount of them, from what I recall.
  • Are they spread out over the game?: Technically, but only because there are multiple separate stories.
    • How much gameplay is there between sex scenes?: Considerable amounts of story telling occurs in every chapter before sex scenes occur.
  • Are they only at the endings?: More or less, yeah.
    • How hard do you have to work to get an ending?: Multiple hours of reading.
    • Are they in every ending? Every good ending?: They're in every ending that I can think of, including at least one bad ending.
• Are the sex scenes optional via a choice in the menu?: Don't remember and I don't think I have this one anymore. Probably not.
• Would the story make sense without them with minimal or no rewriting?: Yes. I don't believe any of the sex scenes are really that necessary for the storytelling.
• Are the scenes made up of stills, or are they animated?: Stills.
• How explicit are the sex scenes?: Sex occurs. Not enough to be porn, however, at least one of the girls is wayyyy too young looking. However, there are multiple clean editions of it and the page doesn't even mention the sex scenes.

Overall, this looks like a pretty clear case of using a bleached underpants version of the work to me.

All of the Retarded Animal Babies shorts are on Newgrounds. Looking through a few, it's mostly crude humor with some nudity. Not porn, not pedopandering.

FanficRecs.Death Note Smut Fic is flagged.

Is that even a proper namespace?

Apparently so.

Huh. I stand corrected. As it appears to be a repository for smut fics, it violates the rules for fanfic recommendation, but is that a P5 issue?

I don't know. It only has one fanfic on there, so I guess you could see if that's safe and either cut or the page or cut the page and move the fic rec to another page.

Already looked through the fic. First thing I did. It breaks our policies, plain and simple.

Then I'd just vote for the page to be cut.

On a similar topic, there aren't supposed to be links to Kink Memes on the fanfic recommendation pages, right?

edited 4th Aug '12 8:45:54 PM by Butterfinger

Taking a look at the works Subjective listed:

• Deserving: Would someone else take a look at it in my stead? I have enough issues with slashfic, but Mister Seahorse is where I draw the line. Even after Litchi Hikari Club.
• Druids: Probably a little too porny to keep. Alternates between several strips without sex and about as many with.
• Retarded Animal Babies: see here
• Anatomy of a Fall: I'll get back to this one later.
• Miss World 96 Nude: devilhead, I guess. Play puzzle, get porn. Not much else to say judging by our page.
• Slave World: More data needed, and even still may take some time.
• Gore Screaming Show: some discussion beginning here. After thinking things over, it seems like it will ultimately come down to the question of "Are the sex scenes with Yuka pedopandering?" She's in that same borderline region as (forgive me for reusing this example) Pink-Hair in Hoshizora no Memoria

edited 4th Aug '12 9:03:43 PM by tdgoodrich1

Etherum Gladiator is porn. Porn with awesome plot, but it is ultimately porn. I gave it a read a while back, was in a Warcrafty mood. Good plot, but it's essentially divorced from the Warcraft Lore, as I know it.