The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Don't know, and I'm not inclined to push the matter in that direction. I'm just complaining because I've been seriously questioning my ability to judge accurately for the past couple of weeks.

Hm, with Pyrite's assessment, I'm gonna zap and re-flag Iron Virgin Jun, too, because I need to change my vote. Man, what was I thinking at the time...?

No.

edited 16th Jul '12 5:08:18 PM by Komodin

Based on the two chapters that have been released, I agree that Manga.Kanojo No Kagi Wo Akeru Houhou is borderline, but I don't think it's explicit enough to cross into porn territory.

I'm going to resolve it as "Keep, clean, and monitor" so that we can keep an eye on new chapters as they come out.

Good news everyone, we're down to only 75 items right now.

Things that currently have 2 votes one way. (devil:angel)

• Page 1
  • Patalliro! - 0:2
• Page 2
  • Ironwood - 2:2
  • Morefuyu - 2:2
• Page 3
  • Sengoku Rance - 2:1
  • Sundome - 0:2
  • Animamundi Dark Alchemist - 0:2
  • Da Capo - 0:2
  • Wicked City - 0:2
  • Shiro - 2:0
  • Maka Maka - 2:0
  • Hoshizora no Memoria - 2:0
  • Kamidori Alchemy Meister - 2:0
  • Bliss Stage - 0:2
  • Iron Virgin Jun - 0:2

We're actually making progress... excellent!

Amen, hallelujah and peanut butter.

XD There's 2 items on page 2 with a 2:2 voting favor, and none of the other pages have two votes on both sides, too!

Thats pretty good.

...This is just begging for Harvey Dent to make an appearance.

Well said.

I'm tempted to flip a double-headed, defaced-on-one-side coin (or better yet, a pair of them!), just to see if it's gonna make a Harvey Dent/Two-Face sockpuppet (or one for each!) comes up.

Re-indexed the recently-restored Bliss Stage on Tabletop Games. Good work, people.

edited 17th Jul '12 1:30:25 PM by TwoGunAngel

Da Capo review in progress. This may take a while.

Goosebumps is flagged.

Either a misclick or a troll, most likely. I remember Goosebumps from school, and if I recall correctly, there's nothing in the way of porn or pedo-bait at all.

There is one episode that comes close, to be fair. A grandmother uses a type of medicine to "age up" her grandsons so she can sell them to some elderly ladies.

But other than that, don't see it. And I'm pretty sure the "age up" part would be enough to say "Yeah, no" for some.

Remember the target audience is kids and this is in every middle school library I think the exception apples to this one.

edited 17th Jul '12 3:17:16 PM by shadis

No, just explaining why somebody would flag it. It's a legitimate reason.

Except that it's not. The series (both books and television series) is for children. That plot description isn't even that iffy, and there's no way it was played in such a way that it runs afoul of the guidelines, because, again, it was for kids.

And that's besides the fact that it falls firmly in the exemption zone. It's not even close to having a borderline rating.

edited 17th Jul '12 3:47:45 PM by BadWolf21

Meeble: What are you investigating? The anime? I haven't watched that, but if you need to know anything about the VN let me know.

And in turn, if you need to know about the anime, just ask me (anything, really. I've watched all the anime that is available of the franchise, methinks)

edited 17th Jul '12 4:32:34 PM by Marche90

@Bad Wolf: No, that situation is questionable as Pedophile-pandering. It's really the only reason why someone would flag it if they were being serious.

Albeit, it should be zapped, since it's not an issue.

@Arha & Marche: Thanks. I'm starting with the anime and will expand to the other media from there. If I have any questions I'll let you guys know.

Update on The List of Works/Tropes To Be Axed/Spared:

• Page 1:
  • Patalliro!: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.

• Page 2:
  • Ironwood: 2 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Morefuyu: 2 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.

• Page 3:
  • Sengoku Rance: 1 Angelhead, 2 Devilheads.
  • Sundome: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Animamundi Dark Alchemist: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Da Capo: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Wicked City: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Shiro: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Maka Maka : 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Hoshizora no Memoria: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Kamidori Alchemy Meister: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Iron Virgin Jun: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.

Bliss Stage: Love Is Your Weapon is pretty much resolved as "do nothing" so that can be marked done.

Main.Variable Geo is still deleted and locked, but a page on the OVA has been made under Anime.Variable Geo, and the PS games under VideoGame.Advanced Variable Geo.

edited 18th Jul '12 9:51:46 AM by KuroBaraHime

Are we still doing flags of things that we thing might get flagged in the future, just as a preventative measure? Because I am about 900% certain that someone is going to get into their head to flag Fritz the Cat eventually.