These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
Alternate Character Interpretation: Is Nathan Drake a happy-go-lucky adventurer who regrets but doesn't dwell on the high human cost of his endeavors, or is he a high-functioning clinical sociopath hiding behind a jokey facade, whose friends are mostly unaware of the true depths of his ruthlessness?
Broken Base: In Uncharted 3, aiming was changed in that the lag between moving the controller's joystick and the reticule moving on the screen was dramatically increased, and there is resistance to movement when aiming over an enemy. Some people are very upset about this, while others accuse them of nitpicking. Naughty Dog themselves addressed the issue by asking fans to provide them input for perhaps a future patch and has since uploaded a patch to help fix the aiming.
Central Theme: It's right in the titles of each game; luck, honor (or lack thereof), and deception.
Complete Monster: Zoran Lazarevic, the Big Bad of Among Thieves. From the backstory we learn he's a known war criminal, responsible for murder and torture on a large scale. The first time you see this guy up close, he shoots Jeff, Elena's wounded cameraman, whom Nate has been trying to carry to safety for a level. After failing to kill Drake when the latter boarded his train, he attacks the village Drake had been staying at, killing many civillians in the process. Later on, when Nate tries to pull a Put Down Your Gun and Step Away by taking one of Lazarevic's men captive, he simply laughs and shoots the hostage in the head after giving a speech about how Hitler, Stalin, Genghis Khan and Pol Pot were all "great men" because they "had the will to do what other men would not."
8.8: No matter the score given, every review of the third game has pissed someone off. Hundreds of scathing comments were made on Eurogamer's site for daring to give the game an 8 out of 10, while detractors of the series aren't pleased at the near-universal acclaim.
Tenzin in Among Thieves seems to have quite a fan following, despite most players not speaking Tibetan, even after he first appeared in the second multiplayer beta. It may be because one of his first acts is a Crowning Moment of Awesome — stabbing the shit out of a suited Guardian with a massive kukri just before it bitchslaps the life out of you. Or perhaps his awesome hat.
Eddy Raja in Drake's Fortune. A little bit crazy wise-cracking rival with a (slight) sense of honour? What's not to love? Some people found him more interesting than the actual main antagonist of the game.
Charlie Cutter in Drake's Deception. He's cocky, sarcastic, and has excellent banter with Nate. He's also one of the better representations of a British character. He's even got a more vulnerable side to him that's just endearing, and fits into the main cast like he's been there all along. You can't help but feel sorry for the guy when he's tripping balls on the hallucinogenic water, or freaking out about small spaces.
Escapist Character: Nathan. Highly skilled gunfighter, ladies' man, expert in adventurous archaeology, smart enough to know every bit of world history (and language) that's relevant, excellent climbing skills? Check. Average outlook, frequently panics? Check.
Subverted in Uncharted 3. It turns out that Nate's an escapist character for himself as well. In actuality he was never related to Francis Drake and was just an orphan abandoned by his parents
Even Better Sequel: Among Thieves improves on all the good points that its predecessor already held, as well as the few things where there were problems. The critics couldn't stop gushing over how awesome it was. It ended up winning more than twenty-five game of the year awards. The contests where it didn't win, it definitively clinched either Action Game Of The Year or PS3 Game of the Year. Sometimes both. Frequently all three.
Guide Dang It: Good luck finding all the treasures on your own, unless somehow you're extremely proficient at finding tiny little sparkles tucked away in every freaking nook and cranny.
Hell Is That Noise: The creepy deep breathing of the 'Choker' mooks in Uncharted 3 Co-op/Multiplayer. If you hear that, you need to run, and try and find out what direction they're coming from. Made even worse if you're playing with someone on the same console; you can't tell if the Choker is coming after you or after them.
The sounds of the Descendents scuttling about in Drake's Fortune. Made even more creepy by the fact that you can hear these noises in one of the first locations, even if you don't actually encounter them until later on.
The spiders in Drake's Deception make this nasty, chattery scuttly sound, and are accompanied by creepy high pitched music. If you hear that noise or music, basically, RUN.
Hilarious in Hindsight: General Ironicus kept insisting during Chip Cheezum's Let's Play of Drake's Fortune that Nate was going to England (due to the map coordinates UK2642 found in Chapter 3). It becomes much funnier when it was revealed that the primary anatgonist/Mooks in Uncharted 3 are British.
Ho Yay Shipping: Sully and Drake have various Ho Yay moments and are close. Easy to see how this ship can happen in the fandom.
The Scrappy: Chase gets some hate because she needs rescuing far more than Chloe and Elena ever did, and the fact she doesn't even help with any of the fighting until later in the game. Even then she's not a good shot. The Almost Kiss at the end of the game didn't win her any points with the Nate/Elena fans, despite the game being set before they got together.
Arguably, the levels with the Descendants in the Nazi bunker in the first game, especially if one dislikes Survival Horror type games. The enemies are very fast, hard to aim at, can kill Nate with 1-2 very quick melee attacks depending on difficulty, love to sneak up behind you to surprise you with said move while you're fighting one of their friends, or otherwise appear from behind corners right as you're about to turn them, you're basically stuck with a fairly weak submachinegun through the entire level (so no shotguns), and the level itself is quite dark and mostly lit through your Infinite Flashlight.
Gets even more frustrating right after, when Roman's men are fighting the creatures, since the game is otherwise a cover-based shooter, but the creatures will sneak up and kill you from the other direction while you're in cover, and waiting for them to kill each other doesn't work because fresh enemies pour in the further you progress. At least the Yetis/natives in the sequel are fairly easy to see coming and you have allies for many of your fights with them.
The finale on Navarro's cargo ship. The enemies are behind indestructible cover while the cover you are given is not. They're at a range where they can kill you almost immediately. You are not given any grenades. And through it all, Navarro himself is invincible and popping shots off at you with a one-hit kill rapid-fire shotgun.
The second part of "Caravan" in Drake's Deception. The sandstorm greatly limits your depth of view and you have to kill turret gunners on Jeeps to advance forward, which wouldn't be very hard if you know where they are before they kill you.
That One Puzzle: The 'lining up the body parts' puzzle in chapter 11 of Drake's Deception. The idea is to place a make shift 'torch' into one of several holes in the ground, and the light from it is supposed to cast a certain shadow onto the wall. You can switch to first person view to line it up, and the guide hints that a shadow should be cast to help you. However in game, this doesn't happen.
They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: The revelation in Uncharted 3 that Nate isn't really Francis Drake's descendant and made up his heritage in order to live out a fantasy and escape from being an orphan whose father abandoned him and mother committed suicide could have been an epic twist that would have turned the whole series on its head. But it's only mentioned twice in a one-off line from the villains and is never touched on again.
Uncanny Valley: Largely averted, but fingers in the second game look very... rectangular. It also seems as if there are floodlights hooked up to the characters' lower eyelids. They constantly have shining, wet look to them, and look rather bug-like.
Unfortunate Implications: The series doesn't exactly treat non-Americans the greatest, with most of the mooks of the first two games being ethnic minorities, and Nathan being the only one capable of doing any actual treasure-hunting and clue-solving.
General Ironicus in Chip Cheezum's LP of the first game, as a sociology major, found said racism accusations rather ridiculous and retorted with how people should care more about how real life economic and sociological pressures are what often force minorities from various countries into lives of crime in the first place.
Visual Effects of Awesome: Uncharted: Drake's Fortune was noted at the time for it's lush and wonderful environments even though it suffered from a few graphical issues. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves fixes those issues and gives some of the best graphics you can ever have from the PlayStation 3. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception takes it a step further and refines those graphics to make it one of the most visually pleasing games for the system.
Waggle: The first game forces you to control the throwing distance of the grenades with the SIXAXIS function of the controller...making placing grenades quite awkward. Luckily, this was made optional in the sequels.