These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
Megan Fox, to the point he does not even consider her an actress at all, instead regarding her as nothing more than Window Dressing and Eye Candy.
Since the announcement of her playing April O'Neil, ERod took the opportunity to make jokes about her casting in the Michael Bay directed TMNT movie.
Actors Seth Rogen, Shia LaBeouf and Ashton Kutcher have been used as punchlines for "It could have been a worst option for [insert role here]" (like having Ashton as Max Payne or Rogen as Doctor Who). In Shia's case, ERod admitted he used him because Shia was an easy target thanks to the Transformers movies and the 4th Indiana Jones, while he snarks at Seth Rogen because he always plays the same character with a different shirt.
Broken Base: Judging from the reactions to his first video on That Guy with the Glasses, some find him very entertaining while others find him unfunny and accuse him of ripping off other reviewers (mostly he's Linkara's Irate Gamer).
It probably didn't help that one of his earliest videos on the site was his Atlantis review, in which he made fun of other contributors.
It's short, but in his Superman Returns review, he criticizes the fact Superman is hinted to have impregnated Lois Lane by pointing out the Man of Steel, Woman of Kleenex trope. In truth, weither Superman is subject or not of this trope is a huge case of Depending on the Writer, and as pointed out by Linkara in his Dark Knight Strikes Again review, he has complete control over his strenght, so the trope would most likely not apply.
Designated Hero: as much as he tries playing himself off as a superhero, he acts a lot more like a bully to movies. The Little Vampire and Robots come to mind, but honestly just watch the Robots one to see his running gag just for celebrity cameo-voices.
Even more hilarious when you realize that the supposed "Evil" version of him actually did less than he implies he does. What exactly did he do when he's first introduced? He admits he likes Spider-man 3 most of all out of the Spider-man series. Apparently just doing that is punishable by being trapped in the phantom-zone. The rest of his actions could easily be described as a revenge-trip
Dude, Not Funny!: Met this reaction when E Rod (In character) threatened to kill himself to stop Lazarus by pointing a gun to his head. Some fans noted that Jew Wario killed himself the same way not three months prior.
Genius Bonus: While most people can tell that ERod is Latin just by his name(Eric Rodriguez), savvy viewers can tell he's specifically Puerto Rican from various hints in his videos.
In one video, he's wearing a shirt for El Conquistador, one of Puerto Rico's most luxurious hotels.
El Lover. His English is very Puerto Rican-accented(his talking speed and pronunciation of certain words are giveaways), his Spanish is completely Puerto Rican in accent and vocabulary, and he's shown from time to time reading Turey El Taino, a popular 90s Puerto Rican comic book.
Not only Doug Jones doing a cameo for ERod's review of Rocky and Bullwinkle is awesome and adorable when Doug recognized ERod's appreciation for his filmography, ERod also highlighted Jones' participation in Rock Jocks, which was directed by Paul (Panda Bear / Dr. Nemesis), his best friend.
Periphery Hatedom: He says that he hates kids movies, but he still reviews them. At least the Nostalgia Critic has the excuse that they're nostalgic films, when you have literally thousands of other targets to go after to fit his MO instead than these easy targets.
ERod has clarified his stance, stating that he doesn't hate movies aimed at children in general (he has praised several Pixar and Disney films), but he dislikes "movies aimed for kids that are stupid because [the creators] don't care", and also because the kid's movies that he reviews are adaptations, they fall in his criteria.
Tear Jerker: His review ofMan of Steel. He refuses to go by ERod or give it a score, just addressing with a sad and down voice the mayor failures of the movie and how every time he watched it, he liked it even less.
Unfortunate Implications: In Film/Dracula2000, he complains that Series/Elementary replaced "Relatable Dr. Watson" with an attractive woman. He also goes on to praise Benedict Cumberbatch (an attractive man) for being Sherlock. Sure, he says Lucy Liu is a good actor, but her character doesn't matter apparently.
Unpleasable Fanbase: At times, he shows to be the most outspoken one of these on That Guy With The Glasses, where he also gets the most split base comparing with his youtube or blip comments section.