These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
Awesome Art: The facial expressions alone are oozing with creativity and personality.
Ensemble Darkhorse: Thanks to the cast of Paranatural having eccentric traits and quirks, a lot of characters are well-favored within the fandom. Notably, Johnny, Suzy, Ed, and even Isaac, especially so as of Chapter 3 which serves to round him out as a character, even hinting that he may have a Dark and Troubled Past.
Johnny: Have you considered getting your kicks in the form of actual kicks? 'Cause I know a guy. It's me. I'm the kick guy. Let me kick you.
Growing the Beard: Chapter 1 itself started off pretty entertaining but things didn't really pick up until Chapter 2 wherein Max faces off against the Racist Whale Frog. As of Chapter 3, the fanbase has increased even more so and now Discussion section will have at least 100 participants on average.
Isaac is so anime. Explanation Thanks to Isaac displaying several tropes common to anime characters such as his spiky hair, tendency to sparkle, act akin to a brooding anti-hero completed by having, what is implied to be, a Dark and Troubled Past. All revealed in Chapter 3.
Calling Mr. Spender variations of his name such as Mr. Splendiferous, Mr. Spencer, etc. Explanation This meme most likely arose due to Max mispronouncing Mr. Spender name, Mr. Splendid in Chapter 1.
[X attack] becomes [Y!] Explanation From this strip, where Isabel's grandfather demonstrates his INCREDIBLE ABILITY to... turn spectral fists into dolphins. Huh.
The Woobie: PJ, the little ghost boy. His dialogue contains a number of hints that undeath is not exactly a bowl of cheerios.