In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Homestar Runner, The Ditzy God (Homeslice, Kevin DuBrow, Mr. Dee Williams, The Deckeman, Homestarrunner.com, Lionel Richie) as an Intermediate God under Mindsets (House of Knowledge)
- Marzipan, Self-Proclaimed Official Goddess of Political Correctness (Marzy, Fox's mother) as a Lesser Goddess under Order and Chaos (House of Philosophy)
- Strong Bad, God of Reading Fan Mail Beyond the Fourth Wall (Strong Bad: Stong Band, Professor Tor Coolguy, Tip Tappers, Vance Mudgeman, Cara Carabowditbowdit, Dr. Marvin Rubdown, The Leg, Dangeresque) as an Intermediate God under Metafiction (House of Narrative)
- Bubs Concession Stand, Divine Owner of the Only Shop in Town (The Thnikkaman, The ThnikkaStan, King Bubsgonzola Supreme, Baron Darin Diamonocle, Big Green Job, The Thin Green Duke, MC Green Beans) as a Demigod in the Hall of Businesses and Corporations (House of Commerce)