This is based on opinion. Please don't list it on a work's trope example list.
Nightmare Fuel / Twisted Metal
Hello boys and girls! Now that I'm free, I'm going to be the greatest of all time!
Original four Twisted Metal games:
Though Narm unfortunately plays a huge part in the first game's lost endings, Calypso's design can come off as creepy to some. He is suppose to have suffered a severe burn injury to his whole face in his backstory, but it instead looks as though he is completely missing the skin on his face in general. Other than that, his design is just ridiculous.
Needles Kane's design in the first game may also count. He is drastically different in design compared to his later appearance, having green non-flaming hair, giant red lips and blue make-up around his eyes. What makes him creepy is his face, being that it looks horribly deformed and bumpy, compared to the simple clown mask in later appearances.
Captain Rodgers in the second game is ghastly in appearance. Due to being severely elderly he has tons of wrinkles, pale blue skin, and has an eerie drooped face with dull starring eyes. He essentially looks like a living corpse.
Most endings in the second game are terrifying, for example:
Mr. Grimm's ending involves him begging Calypso to make the people of Earth die faster so he can get more souls. The whole scenario is meant to reference drug withdrawal, since the lack of souls he obtains makes him weaker. Once his wish is granted, everyone on Earth begins to kill each other in an endless war until humanity becomes extinct. Mr. Grimm enjoys the large amount of souls he obtains from this war, but sadly since humanity is extinct, there are no more souls to gain, and like any other druggie, Mr. Grimm hungers for another fix...
Mike and Stu's ending, mainly the climax of it. Though the ending in general also counts as a Crowning Moment of Funny, the fact that we are given a still shot of the duo face-first against the pavement with a blood puddle forming is a bit unsettling.
Captain Rodger's ending has him wishing he had the body of a young man again, being sick of his elderly appearance. Calypso, being the cheep bastard that he is, grants his wish according to these words. Rodgers is given the body of a young man like he wished for, but his head remains the same.
Really, what in this game isn'tNightmare Fuel. Compared to the previous games and even the ones to come afterwards, Black is easily the only game in the series to take itself completely seriously. The atmosphere, character backstories, setting and premise are presented in a dark, grim, depressing and almost colorless fashion. It is also the only game in the series to be completely devoid of any humor even in the slightest.
When it comes to Nightmare Fuel heavy characters in Black, the following people are especially worthy:
For starters, this is the game that introduces Needles Kane's clown mask design. You know, the one that is used as the picture for this very page. Is an explanation even needed? The mask alone is Nightmare Fuel enough, but this is the game that also introduced his serial killer persona. No longer is Needles depicted as a goofy sociopath or an ice cream addict, but a serious bloodthirsty killer with disturbing motives. These features would become the definitive depiction of the character that would carry on in the later games.
Cage. The man's ambition? To be the greatest killer the world has ever known. But what does he want from Calypso? Brain surgery to remove that part of him that feels sad whenever he kills. Calypso's feeling generous, so he throws in something extra for a man with his consciousness literally stripped away - his hands replaced with metal razors and blades.
And his ending? Calypso breaks the boy's remote and abducts him, with the intention of raising him to take over the tournament. Oh, and guess what? The kid's big brother is Needles "Sweet Tooth" Kane.
Mr. Grimm in this game is also quite disturbing, even taking into account that he was essentially The Grim Reaper in the previous games. In Black, Grimm is a Vietnam veteran who, upon getting captured by Vietcong, is forced to eat his fellow soldier and friend Benny to avoid starvation as a form of torture by the capturers. He even sews his comrades skull to his own face as a helmet. Wanting revenge for the man who ruined his life, he fights through Calypso's contest to gain his reward. Once he wins, he is given the chance to eat his commanding advisor from the war. Afterwards, Grimm admits overtime he has gained a strange craving for human flesh.
Preacher's story is pretty creepy, especially the depiction of the "demon" tormenting his mind. The whole story gets worse once it is found out that the demon is his own psyche.
Minion doesn't have a story in this game, but looking at his close-up image◊ will probably give you nightmares on its own. (especially when you realize that the thing he's using as a mask is literally the mutilated head of a cow.) Maybe it's better that he didn't get a story after all.
While Minion does not have a proper story, his coded loaded screen messages are pretty unsettling. "We are trapped in his head." It probably says something that Marcus Kane misses the colorful world that he initially tried to run away from.
Bloody Mary. Taken just at face value, while disturbing, her plot can seem a bit silly: an overly-jealous woman who is permanently "always a bridesmaid, never a bride". What puts her over the edge, however, is her loading screen snippets. She just comes across as so cold and unnatural.
My daddy used to say I was the prettiest girl in the world. Even after he killed my mom, he still said I was beautiful.
Kristen's parents are sad she's dead. But I know when I find my true love, they'll be so happy for me.
All the music in the game (and we do mean all the music) is unsettling. Most of it falls into fast and boisterous industrial music with emphasis on Drone of Dread with plenty of loud percussion, while other pieces are slow and ominous. Some examples include:
The main menu music. It's just plain disturbing. It's very industrial and nonsensical, and the fact that it plays over some also quite creepy still shot of our drivers fighting and flying out of their cars doesn't help.
Outlaw's ending. Carl & Jamie Roberts argue over what to do about Calypso. Carl shouts "I wish you'd shut up" and Calypso... takes it literally and grants the wish. As a result, Calypso seals Jamie's mouth closed in a similar fasion to the first Matrix movie.
Twisted Metal 2012:
Calypso in this version is a lot more powerful and sinister than in previous incarnations. In other games, he gets his powers from a demon. In this one, he's the devil. That painting in his office is utterly chilling.
Sweet Tooth'sCarnivalof Carnage. After Sweet Tooth died after getting his wish, his followers built a giant clown and carnival themed moving battle fortress in his honor. The whole damn thing is horrifying to look at: for starters, its a massive tank like contraption that can only be accessed through an elevator lift at the bottom guarded by a flame spewing clown head. Once inside you have to fight through a giant pinball machine while being attacked by chainsaw wieldingmonster clowns, then race through a long tunnel filled with giant blades and saws, then finally take flight in a helicopter where you must fight essentially the Final Boss of the game. The final boss by the way is a giantfire breathing, sharp toothed, eyeless clown head that will lunge at you in an attempt to take a bite out of your helicopter if you get too close.
The Iron Maiden, Dollface's menacing flying robot she uses against Mr. Grimm. The sheer size of the thing is horrifying, especially for the fact that you have to fight it. It doesn't help that it has the ability to rotate its head from having a standard cute baby doll face to this◊.