Someone has to take care of someone else's pet while the someone else is away. The pet ends up dying (through carelessness, though sometimes just an accident or through bad luck). The caretaker often ends up buying a replacement and trying to pass it off as the real thing. Sometimes this works great, but in most cases, the owner isn't fooled for one second, as they instantly notice changes in the pet's behavior and appearance (or even the sex, for particularly clueless caretaker).
Sometimes the pet in question is not actually dead, just missing, in which case The Reveal
often centers around the substitution succeeding until the real pet turns up. Either way, the caretaker will have some explaining to do.
Not to be confused with Monty Python
's "Dead Parrot Sketch", which is an altogether different beast
entirely... in which the Norwegian Blue Parrot was... resting. Here is an external link
to that sketch.
Done so often and often so miserably that it seems to have finally, mercifully become a Discredited Trope
See also Broken Treasure
and Of Corpse He's Alive
. While many examples of this trope involve a replacement goldfish, they generally do not involve the Replacement Goldfish
Anime and Manga
- In .hack//SIGN a girl PC asks Tsukasa to take care of her grunty (a small, pig-like virtual animal) for a couple of days while she's away. The grunty gets sick (or apparently, was already sick and she didn't notice it) and dies despite Tsukasa's heroic effort to find a cure (in a very cold place, and he's the only one who can feel the cold). He doesn't try to lie.
- A very similar scene occurs in .hack//Legend of the Twilight, but the grunty lives (and its owner is admonished for the irresponsibility of palming it off on someone else when it was sick).
- In Kiki's Delivery Service, Kiki is supposed to deliver a plush cat, but she drops it along the way. She ends up substituting her cat Jiji (who happens to be a dead ringer for the plushie), who has to act like an inanimate object until she can retrieve the real thing and deliver it.
- Detective Conan episode 413 has this done mostly straight with a bluebird owned by a guest star character. Slightly changed because the bird wasn't sick and had no reason to die. It was sick, they just didn't recognize it.
- Given a different twist in the Haiyore! Nyarko-san Flash shorts. Mahiro asked Cuuko to take care of his goldfish, and when he gets back he starts demanding to know what kind of food she fed it... because it's sprouted human legs. Cuuko, being an alien, doesn't quite understand that this isn't normal.
- There's a Ragu pasta sauce ad in which a young girl finds her hamster, which was sick, has "mysteriously" turned from gray to white. It's implied her father replaced the gray one after it died, then made her pasta for supper to further cheer her up.
- A The Three Stooges short features Moe, Larry, and Curly trying to cover up the fact that their animal hospital misplaced a valuable poodle, ending up finding a lame replacement until they can rescue the dog from dog-nappers.
- Meet the Parents with a cat. To clarify, the cat ran away and Greg spraypaints a stray to look like the escaped pet. The stray tears up everything in the room, including the bridal gown.
- Bolt, when Penny's money-hungry agent decides to replace him with a lookalike dog to keep the show going, when the star dog fails to show up for a long time. The real Bolt and his friends return to the studio, but thinks Penny has given up the search for him and took to a new dog, but he is convinced that Penny still loves him and she was forced to adopt the replacement. Bolt eventually saves his owner Penny from a fire in the studio.
- The Russian 1995 movie "Moscow Vacation" features the "Dead Dog in the plane" story below.
- A driving force behind the plot of the movie Toy Story 3, in which this is the exact reason why the Big Bad became that way.
- In the Patriot Games Jack Ryan makes a call home to tell the house keeper to check on Sally's gold fish, and if they're dead, to get new ones. When she gets home Sally is amazed by how much her gold fish have grown while she was away.
- Deuce Bigalow has the gigolo's pet fish killed by blender. They replace it with a new one, but it doesn't fool him for long.
- A throwaway line by Susan in Hogfather implies that she has successfully pulled the pet-replacement trick on Twila at least once, with gerbils. Presumably Twila herself was the one who discovered the deaths of the three that are buried in the garden.
- By Thief of Time, Susan has evidently gotten tired of playing out this trope, as she chooses stick insects as the new class pet because it's hard to tell if they are dead.
- This happens in Planet Tad, a regular feature in MAD, later released as a book. Tad and his friend Chuck lose the pet hamster, Mr. Squeakers (though Tad says "He and I know his name is Thunderclaw.") of Tad's Annoying Younger Sibling, Sophie. They buy a new hamster, Thunderclaw II, and Sophie is fooled, but then the original Thunderclaw is found dead in some Rice Krispies.
- Home Improvement, with a goldfish
- Diff'rent Strokes, Arnold's goldfish, Abraham
- Saved by the Bell, with Slater's chameleon. It backfired as two students had the idea and neither warned the other.
- Better with You, where Vicky and Joel adopt Mia and Casey's cat and then lose it
- Traffic Light, with a stuffed dog named CJ that Adam won for Callie
- Inverted in Malcolm in the Middle, where Dewey is promised a dog if he can take care of a goldfish. His parents, not wanting a dog, replace the live goldfish with a dead one. Only for Dewey to walk in the next morning with the goldfish still alive.
- Lampshaded in The King of Queens, where the dog Doug's had from childhood dies and his family scrambles to replace it. Turns out that this is actually the fourth version of the dog. When he died the first time his parents replaced it, and then kept doing it. When the truth comes out, Doug has to admit that a 32 year old dog is pretty unlikelynote -and then makes himself pretend it's the same dog as they celebrate the dog's 32nd birthday.
- Only Fools and Horses twisted this beautifully when the main characters replaced the canary only to have the owner very surprised on her return because it had died the night before.
- Everybody Loves Raymond did this, with Ray accidentally putting Ally's hamster in the freezer.
- On Taxi, Bobby fish-sits for Tony with predictable results. Tony seems happy and everyone is relieved until he says, "I hope they get along with George and Wanda [the original goldfish]."
- ''Alice has an episode where Vera bought a parrot named Birdie, who keeled over and died while she was away from the diner. The gang buy another one just like it and try to pass it off as the original — until the bird says "My name is Irving" to her.
- The Cosby Show with a hamster. The little girl wasn't fooled for a moment as this happened every time she left her hamster with somebody.
- The second episode The Cosby Show was, Goodbye Mr. Fish featuring a funeral attended by the whole family as Cliff wanted to teach the older kids a lesson in sensitivity when they made fun of Rudy for being sad about her fish's death only for Rudy to lose interest abruptly in the middle of the ceremony to go watch TV.
- My Wife and Kids, with the school's hamster. First, the family tries to convince Kady that he's just sleeping, then Michael buys a replacement. When the replacement has babies, they confess the truth; Kady is displeased ("You let me touch a dead hamster?! Eeew!!").
- Scrubs did a unique inversion wherein Carla loses Turk and J.D.'s stuffed dog Rowdy. Janitor offers to replace Rowdy by killing and stuffing another dog. After that idea was rejected, he found another, already stuffed dog, nearly the same, this one named Steven.
- Also a multi-season delayed Brick Joke, as J.D. and Turk didn't find out for a long time. When they do finally get Rowdy back, JD lets Turk keep Rowdy and keeps Steven for himself, as he got attached to him and could tell the two apart.
- Mork and Mindy, with a caterpillar. Turns out it was just transforming into a butterfly.
- Northern Exposure: When Chris in the Morning runs over a woman's dog in "Nothing's Perfect" (4.3), he falls for and tries to court her... but ends up killing all her pets.
- Kenan & Kel with Roger's (Kenan's Dad's) Cockatoo.
- Averted in another episode where the guys housesit for Chris, and his goldfish is just about the only thing in his house that isn't destroyed by the end of the episode.
- The Office subverts this in that Dwight, while supposed to be caring for Angela's sick cat, intentionally kills it to put it out of its misery. He then tells her that it was dead when he got there. (He gave it pills and put it in the freezer.) Naturally, the truth comes out and there is hell to pay.
- In MADtv's dead pet sketch, a house-sitting friend is saying goodbye to the pet parakeet when it bites him and he flings it to the floor, killing it. He then goes on to kill the friend when he returns, the friend's mother, and several bystanders including the mailman and a water deliveryman - the last of which is lampshaded as a Contrived Coincidence by the house-sitter. He also calls in a jogger across the street, claiming he's addicted to it. But, of course, at the end we find out the parrot wasn't dead, only unconscious. However, it saw all the actual murders and is killed to prevent it from telling anyone.
- Worst Week, the US adaptation of The Worst Week Of My Life, had one episode which was entirely centered around this trope. The lead character feeds his in-laws' bird an avocado... unfortunately, it turns out that avocados are deadly for that kind of bird. So the lead character then buys a replacement... and, trying to avoid suspicion, carries it back in his pocket, leading to a rather awkward moment when the bird starts moving around. He manages to kill that bird too while trying, a bit too forcefully, to keep it quiet in his pocket...
- The UK version has an hilarious arc in the first series in which Howard accidentally throws his in-laws' scottie dog into a cement mixer and is forced to find a replacement by the wedding day. Unlike most of the above examples, the in-laws are well aware of what happened to the dog.
- The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air did this once with a rabbit belonging to Nicky. Hillary bought a replacement rabbit that looked nothing like the dead rabbit.
- Just Shoot Me! plays with this one when Finch asks Maya and Jack to watch his evil cat Spartacus. Jack accidentally kills it while chasing it with a remote-controlled car and feels horribly guilty. Finch, kept unaware of how his cat died, gets it stuffed and puts it in Jack's office in appreciation of the fact Maya and Jack are being so sympathetic. Insomniac hilarity ensues.
- Played for Black Comedy in an episode of One Foot in the Grave.
- WKRP in Cincinnati: Herb accidentally spray-painted his daughter's pet frog in one episode.
- Shakey Ground (short lived Sitcom starring Matt Frewer): In-laws go to Hawaii for a week leaving their dog (which they inherited from the grandmother) with the family. Dog dies, dad gets a replacement from an animal shelter which looks exactly like the dead dog...except this one is female.
- In Arrested Development GOB feels that he would be entitled to a full refund for the pigeon he accidentally killed then stuck in the freezer. The sketch itself happens off screen, and we see GOB throwing into the sea in anger over their return policy. He does the same thing a week later with a rabbit.
- The Golden Girls does this during an Empty Nest crossover. Dreyfuss runs away when Sophia is supposed to be watching him, and she gets a replacement lookalike. The real Dreyfuss then comes back, and the girls wind up with both of them, with Rose having to ferret out the real one before Harry gets home and take back the duplicate. It's indicated, though, that the wrong dog got taken back.
- In an episode of Full House, Joey promises Michelle, who is traumatized over accidentally killing her pet fish, that the new one he bought for her is going to live for a long, long time. After she leaves, Jesse asks him what's going to happen if the fish does die, leading Joey to reveal an entire kitchen cabinet full of identical replacements on standby.
- Double Subverted in The New Normal. Shania's guinea pig dies while under David and Bryan's care, and Bryan suggest going to the pet store and getting an identical one. Rocky immediately googles to see how many sitcoms have used the exact same ploy.
- Grace Under Fire: Grace has told her daughter Libby that she could get a dog if she kept her goldfish Fishy Fishman alive for six months, thinking it was impossible, and is now dismayed that Fishy's six month birthday is approaching. However, when Fishy dies just short of the deadline, Grace feels so bad that she secretly buys another goldfish to replace him with. When she goes to make the switch, she is surprised to see that Fishy is still alive and it eventually comes out that there have been many, many Fishy Fishmans and Libby has been secretly getting a new goldfish every time her current one died, just so she could meet the deadline and get a dog.
- A rather over-the-top example in How I Met Your Mother, where in a flashback Robin's parents replace her pet dog with a turtle.
- In the 2point4 Children episode "The Deep", Bumbling Dad Ben Porter has volunteered his family to look after the pets of their neighbours, Leonard and Dora Grimes, while they are on holiday in Switzerland - without telling his wife Bill, as they have already killed several of their pets. With the Grimeses about to board their return flight, the Porters go next door to find a pond full of dead fish which they end up having to replace at great expense from a specialty shop. When the Grimeses return, they are surprised to see the fish looking so well - they were sure they had died days ago. The pets the Porters were actually asked to look after were Leonard's racing pigeons - which Bill has accidentally suffocated by closing their hutch.
- In one episode of the Israeli sitcom HaPijamot, the Local Hangout owner Gary, who has already killed some of his daughter’s pets by accident, accidentally kills another, a white mouse. When he can’t find one to replace it, he winds up stealing a mouse from a lab, on which researchers were testing the hair-growing formula Gary wanted to use and was now lost for years to come—the mouse was used as a feeder rat for the snake in his daughter’s biology class.
- In The Red Green Show, Bob Stuyvestant mentions this happening in his childhood with Fifi, his miniature French poodle.
- Nicky Ricky Dicky And Dawn: The father was caught switching goldfish by the kids in "The Secret". This was the seventh fish to be replaced. Dawn, however, is more upset that the boys have known about it since the third goldfish died than the fact that it did die (apart from accidentally being hit in the face by the dead fish when they were trying to get their father to show what was in his hands).
- Curtis did not take Michelle's demands for her spoiled cat seriously. When the cat became unresponsive, he didn't panic... until he learned that the closest thing at the pet shop was way out of his price range.
- One Sherman's Lagoon arc had Sherman eating a neighbor's pet catfish. He tries to get a new to replace it, only to learn that catfish are a pain to deal with, and the neighbor hated the pet to begin with. He ended up stuck with the replacement, up until Megan found a recipe for cooking catfish...
- Real Life Example: The original Petra on Blue Peter died after only her first appearance. Pet shops were scoured to find a replacement, as it was felt to be to upsetting for viewers. It worked too, and no-one knew for years.
- This can happen often on shows where an animal is the main character.
- Eight generations of (male) collies played Lassie.
- When Moose, the dog who played Eddie on Frasier, retired, his son took over the role.
- Averted with Married... with Children; Buck the dog died when his "actor" retired.
- When Ronald Reagan was abroad for a meeting with the Soviet Premier, two of the goldfish in the house he was staying in died. He bought two more, leaving a note for the family explaining what had happened.
- There's an old story about a woman who was flying on an airplane with her dog in a cage. She had forgotten something at home and left the dog with an airport official. The official noticed that the dog inside was dead. So he raced out and got a new dog that looked similar. When the woman returned, he gave her the new dog, and she knew right away that it wasn't her old dog. When he asked why, she told him that her dog was dead and she was taking him to his old home to be buried.
- The driver of the plot in the play The Lieutenant of Inishmore. Padraic's cat Wee Thomas is killed by rival IRA thugs, and his father and neighbor spend much of the first act trying to find a replacement. They do, but he ends up shooting it when he finds out its not really his cat.
- Strong Bad refers to this trope in Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People Episode 1: Homestar Ruiner:
: Hey, it's the Laugh Trackalicious Adventures of Guy and Girlfriend! Oh, this is the one where Guy thinks he kills Girlfriend's hamster, and tries to replace it with another hamster, but the first hamster had been dead all along, so Girlfriend thinks it came back to life! And then...the hilarity
...and the humor...and the original comedy television writing
- Sluggy Freelance Poor Frog still has no idea that his, er... girlfriend Corsica has been replaced countless times. The other members of Hereti Corp treat her as little more than a pet to be replaced in case one of them goes missing or dies. Interestingly enough the fate of the original is listed as 'unknown'.
- Alternate reality Frog does not take the revelation well .
- The Batman and Sons story arc "Ace in the Hole" is all about this. The Batfamily ends up going through five Aces before giving up - one of them, being female, apparently humped to death by Krypto.
- Rugrats, with a pillbug.
- Played with in Phineas and Ferb - Baljeet is to watch Perry and make sure he doesn't run away. Because Perry is a secret agent, he manages (with much difficulty) to escape to perform his mission, as he does every day. Baljeet is convinced that he lost Perry and weeps incessantly. When Phineas returns, Baljeet is just about to break the news to him when Perry shows up and Phineas says "Oh, there you are Perry."
- The Brak Show, Thunderclese's goldfish.
- Parodied in Rocko's Modern Life, where Filburt isn't broken up about the accidental death of his pet mynah bird because it was from an extremely short-lived species, and was going to die of old age soon anyway.
- However, at the end of the episode, Filburt is quite shocked to find out the actual cause of death for the bird: Heffer sat on it.
- King of the Hill: While minding Hank's elderly bloodhound Ladybird, Luann mistook the dog's stubborn lethargy for death and, predictably, bought a new bloodhound to replace her. The presence of the second dog roused Ladybird into a flurry of activity, leaving Luann with the new problem of identifying the correct dog.
- The Magic School Bus with a rooster.
- The Fairly Oddparents has an episode wherein we discover every time Timmy goes to summer camp, his parents are in charge of his pets. Since his parents' negligence is the reason Timmy has Fairy Godparents, you do the math. Hilarity Ensues when Timmy wishes for everything in his mom's garden to be "filled with life," and all the pets who "ran away" come back as zombies.
- Angela Anaconda with a turtle.
- Lampshaded in an episode of The Simpsons. When Bart and Lisa go off to summer camp, Lisa tells the parents not to replace the pets if they die, because she'll notice.
- Rather ironic, considering that the cat's been replaced four times. It just wasn't secret.
- The "missing pet" variant was played straight in the Franklin episode Franklin and the Two Henrys. Beaver gets Franklin to look after her hamster, Henry. Franklin accidentally lets Henry escape from the cage. So, he gets a replacement hamster. Beaver returns, and then the original Henry turns up while Franklin tries to pass the other hamster off as Henry, Hilarity Ensues.
- In the Spongebob Squarepants episode "I was a Teenage Gary", Spongebob leaves Gary in Squidward's care when he leaves, and Squidward immediately forgets about him. He doesn't try to replace him though, because he doesn't remember until Spongebob returns.
- Also the episode "Wormy" where Spongebob and Patrick petsit for Sandy, and become best friends with her caterpillar, who turns into a butterfly the next day, but they think the butterfly is a monster that ate it.
- The Recess episode "Speedy, We Hardly Knew Ye" had the kids come back after a long weekend to discover that Speedy, the class hamster, had died. During his funeral, several older kids and even some parents turn up to pay their respects to their beloved class pet. Then someone pulls out an old class photo with Speedy in it, and everyone starts noticing that the details are wrong—Speedy's feet were supposed to be white, Speedy was supposed to be a girl, etc. Ms. Grotke awkwardly admits that since the teachers thought the students would be too young to know how to cope with death, they would secretly replace Speedy with a new hamster every time the old one died. As this has happened over 40 years, several of the older mourners then begin to realize that that's rather long-lived for a hamster.
- In Fanboy and Chum Chum the titular characters have to watch over a digital pet for their friend, only to kill it. They decide to go bury it at the haunted Pet Cemetary, which makes it come back to life again! ...Only for them to accidentally kill it and bury it again several times.
- My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic has a variant in the episode "A Bird In The Hoof"; it differs in that Fluttershy literally steals the Princess' pet bird in order to give it medical attention, and the drama lies in her caring for it adequately before giving it back to her. The bird dies at the last possible moment... before it is resurrected from its own ashes, because it's a phoenix.
- The Amazing Worldof Gumball actualy did this with Penny's pet spider.
- It also has a bizarre inversion with Darwin and Gumball caring for the class hamster. They mistake a clump of Principal Brown's hair for the hamster and spend half the episode bonding with it before they realize their mistake. This being Gumball, the hamster is intelligent and forces them through an over the top action sequence before being caught. They then play the trope straight in order to let the hamster go free.
- Sagwa, the Chinese Siamese Cat did this with a cricket. Parodied in that it is the same cricket but the humans don't realize it.
- Freaky Stories: An airport crew went through a lot to find a replacement for a dog believed to have died during flight, unaware that it was already dead.
- In The Rabbit With The Checkered Ears, the episode "The Lost Parrot" sees Kriszta trying to re-capture her friend Kistöfi's pet parrot after it escapes when she opens its cage to give it a treat. Her attempts are unsuccessful, but she passes a pet shop and decides to buy Kistöfi a replacement, hoping he won't notice the difference... unfortunately, Kistöfi's parrot is pink, and the replacement bird is green. (Fortunately, the series' title character has managed to retrieve the original - who gets on quite well with the new bird.)