The sub-forum is used for discussions that adjudicate possible violations of The Content Policy. Threads here can be created by flagging a page through the sidebar "report" button and toggling "The page may violate the Content Policy".
This thread is for general discussion of pages.
Edited by SeptimusHeap on Sep 10th 2022 at 11:50:32 AM
Was the fanfic Hogwarts Exposed cut by the P5? Because the YMMV page
is still around. As is the Awesome Moments Page.
edited 8th Jun '12 8:39:14 PM by lrrose
☆♥☆
Hmm, seems like something that'd get cut, but I'm not seeing seeing it on the voting tool or announcements. Did someone else cut it?
I couldn't find it in the "P5 Decisions and Announcements" thread, but Hogwarts Exposed is empty and locked.
Hi
It's not on the decisions/announcements page.
Yeah, it was cut. I'm dooming those subpages right now. Was probably simply overlooked.
I could have sworn that it was cut, but if not, please let a cutmaster know that it was doomed mistakenly.
Apologies if I jumped the gun, and I will do what is necessary to rectify the situation if need be. -is now begging forgiveness-
edited 8th Jun '12 9:06:05 PM by DarkConfidant
☆♥☆
Should it get flagged and voted on just to make it all official?
The Demon Slayer
Found it! It was one of the works cut before P5 was formed. Cut reason in question was:
FanFic.Hogwarts Exposed: Goes way beyond just being NSFW... wow.
The Headscratchers page for the fic was also cut.
The (former) page we had here itself mentions gratuitous... Well, let's say it's not coming back. If P5 wants to just give it three devil heads, that's A-OK, and good riddance.
Porn, pedo-junk, you name it... All mentioned right on the page history...
edited 8th Jun '12 9:21:40 PM by DarkConfidant
☆♥☆
Sounds like it should be cut, I just suggested flagging and the P5 voting it cut so it's completely official and keeps anyone from asking about it.
If there's any doubt in anyone's mind that this should be cleansed by holy fire, let this excerpt from the former page clarify why a rubber stamp on the cut is all that is needed:
And before anyone asks, page history is where I got this.
edited 8th Jun '12 9:28:14 PM by DarkConfidant
Bird mom
Well it sounds creepy regardless, but it's only pedo pandering if the fic takes place before the sixth book. Is it described which year they're in?
The Crystal Caverns A bird's gotta sing.
Most of the girls are stated to be twelve - I can find another excerpt.
- In what might be a case of Hide Your Lesbians, Caitlin and Emily perform mutual oral sex on each other; Emily can't stop ogling her shy eleven-year-old dormmate Kim, emotionally manipulating her into nudism—or, indeed, forcibly undressing her; and Kim fixates on Jamie's breasts. But, they hasten to reassure the readers, it's okay, because they aren't gay. They're just curious about each other's bodies! Riiiiiight.
edited 8th Jun '12 9:32:14 PM by DarkConfidant
Bird mom
Ok. Then kill it with fire.
The Crystal Caverns A bird's gotta sing.
You gotta get yourself some marble columns
Not having read the fanfic in question or, for that matter, Harry Potter, I gather it takes place well after Deathly Hallows but the original characters are underage.
The child is father to the man —Oedipus
![[up]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]"){kind=icon}
If they're professors, Harry and Hermione are old enough to be irrelevant. But it sounds like the Sues are first years, and I'm guessing this goes into explicit detail. If that's a mistaken assumption, then it can get restored, but I doubt it.
Ninja'ed by Hershele.
edited 8th Jun '12 9:34:04 PM by Discar
Here's more good stuff right off the page:
- Shilling the Wesley: Emily is Neil's favorite character, which means we're supposed to agree with her when she dresses like a stripper to attract the attention of a twenty-year-old man (while she herself is twelve) and then insists that their love is Pure and Innocent.
Since you're the judge, Here's the whole thing.
edited 8th Jun '12 9:36:45 PM by DarkConfidant
Let's not waste our time with Hogwarts Exposed, please. The P5 need their brains intact. There's a reason this thing had three long paragraphs devoted to it in So Bad, It's Horrible. It's for the chopping block. Chopping it with a giant machete is the way to go.
edited 9th Jun '12 1:17:40 AM by lu127
"If you aren't him, then you apparently got your brain from the same discount retailer, so..." - Fighteer
Moe moe killing machine
...
My brain cells are crying in despair. I think a few of them have been unable to take the pressure and have died.
"Suffer a vicious person and you will fear vice. Suffer a virtuous one and you will soon loathe virtue itself." Tony Duvert
Hi
REDUCTO!
TV Tropes' Sonic Wiki Curator
Hogwarts Exposed... eugh. Having read it via the sporkings, yeah, the page for that pedo-pandering piece of trash ain't coming back.
Experience has taught me to investigate anything that glows.
So, all the subpages can totally be doomed to oblivion?
That's why I was asking - I cutlisted some of the subpages thinking it had already been reviewed and killed, but I was mistaken, and...
Well, I'm not trying to subvert the process, but I only made an honest mistake. :(
The Demon Slayer
Sankaku Complex has just received its third devilhead, but there's no disposition written.
Some more flagged stuff for you:
- Main.Eiyuu X Maou: A Turn Based Strategy game with RPG and Dating Sim elements, Visual Novel style storytelling, and apparently a number of H-scenes as well. On the H-Game index.
- Main.Legend Of Queen Opala: A freeware RPG with hentai content, created by hentai artist Gabe Logan. Also on the H-Game index.
Also would like feedback on Fanfic.Calvin At Camp, as I don't know why this was flagged — the series in general is rated K+ to T on Fanfiction.net.
edited 9th Jun '12 10:42:45 AM by TwoGunAngel
mis-click or troll most likely a mis-click.
^^ About those last two things that were flagged, how much adult content do they have?
Heh, the double post drives home your point: there are two or three conversations happening concurrently (on the evolving policy itself and on the works, at the least). Naturally you separated your contributions to different ones.
The child is father to the man —Oedipus