FE

If you're posting examples to show the absurdity can I genuinely suggest you don't. Eddie doesn't like straw men like that, only post stuff if you are genuinely unsure whether or not it would be up for the axe. I think there was a big fuss on one of the other forums with the ban hammer being wielded over the use of straw men (or possibly straw dogs I think it was called, can't be sure).

I mean, in response to him. When he started cutting stuff the universal reaction was "Hey wait a minute we can think of a better plan". I'm just wondering if there was anybody who was on the same "nuke everything" page.

P Down was, apparently.

Apparently Janitor was as well.

Really?

That reminds me, isn't there pedophilia in Straw Dogs?

And I'd nuke this entire wiki rather than let it stay a pedophiles-get-in-free zone.

edited 11th Apr '12 8:22:10 PM by PDown

I'm totally happy that those pedophilie animes finally got the axe, though.

I'm not strawmanning per this order, these works would need to be removed. I'm bringing this to peoples attention, I've never argued for their removal. I've said under this order they would need to be removed.

I was si8mply clarifying that I find that absurd, and am not in support of doing so

Don't know about Straw Dogs, but there is pedophile stuff in Forrest Gump.

P Down: then thank ${deity} it's not your call. For one, "pedophiles get in for free zone" is... quite different than what we are trying to do. Quite some levels down the scale.

Whoa? I thought it was parental abuse, not flat out pedophilia...

edited 11th Apr '12 8:24:44 PM by SilentReverence

@ 1080: No one's seen Janitor in a year or more. When she makes a post here, I'll believe it.

@Catbert: Okay, let's cut that then.

All we know about Janitor's stance is that they agree that pro-pedophile stuff needs to go. I totally agree with that, I just don't think that "cut first, ask later" is a good policy for dealing with it, because a lot of legitimate works will get caught in the crossfire.

Dude, we are only cutting stuff with explicit pedophilia. Not any work where it's mentioned or stated to happen off screen. Only works that show pedophilic content are getting the axe.

edited 11th Apr '12 8:26:39 PM by JapaneseTeeth

I re-added Lolita to School Study Media given that it is widely studied in schools, you know, being a classic and all.

This isn't a G-rated site(No Lewdness, No Prudishness), and while I agree there are some ENTRIES in some works that need to be removed, that doesn't make the whole page itselff XXX.

Let's do this in just one thread.