- Broken Base: The Cutaway Gag with Michael J. Fox as Zorro. Fans have cited it as the point of no return with its insensitivity to people affected by Parkinson's. Then there are fans who don't mind it, saying Family Guy has gotten away with much worse.
- Signature Scene: Everyone agrees that Peter's swashbuckling "sea battle" with the British businessman is the best scene in the whole episode.
- Suspiciously Similar Song: During the scene where Peter and his pirate buddies give chase to a British guy, the music that plays in the background is similar to the theme to The Sea Hawk.
YMMV / Family Guy S 6 E 12 Long John Peter