Follow TV Tropes


WMG / I Am Legend

Go To

Ruth tricked Neville into suicide
Rather than being outright executed, he was supposed to be put on trial, with a death penalty being only an option. She played along all Robert's assumptions just to get a guaranteed kill to avenge her own husband, killed by Neville.

The story takes place somewhere in the Daybreakers universe
Not the movies but the story of the original novel itself. As the original story details Robert Neville has so many Moral Event Horizon moments he has numerous mental breakdowns throughout the 1st 2/3rds of the story. So it can be assumed that by the storys pivotal end Neville doesn't know what is truly fiction in his own mind and reality.

So by this it can be assumed that it could be possible that I Am Legend could be taking place in an alternate New York in the universe of the vampire film Daybreakers. Basically it goes like this, events that made Vampire!Humans in Daybreakers and Legend are fairly similar how ever the storys view splits after this. In one Vampires become like a overwhelming Zombie Apocalypse with only Neville able to save us all while the other is where while humanity becomes Vampires society has changed very little. People still go to work, raise families, drive cars, and make and watch Fox News. Basically the world and civilization in fact hasn't collapsed only "changed".


However Neville (due to his mental snap(s)) doesn't see this and is now only a raving lunatic driven by his own hatred and fear of the new Human!Vampire society. Essentially Neville is a Bigot in the most fantastical sense of the word. He most likely killed his own family out of fear they would become "freaks" like the rest of society. Afterwards Neville began to suffer from severe survivors guilt and mental exhaustion in where he began to break or disassociate himself from reality. After this Neville built a delusional fantasy world in were Neville is a savior of sorts in where Vampires are zombie like monsters and he is the (seemingly) last sane and non mutated man left on a ruined Earth.

However in actuality Neville is nothing more now then a serial killer and madman who has probably killed more people then anyone else in New York's history thus making him a Legend.


Although this does leave some questions that the novel would leave somewhat unanswered but can be explained such as...

  • The reason Neville appears completely alone most of the time is well he is outside Only during the day so most of NYC's populace (being vampires now) would be asleep in their homes. This would be no different then a actual intruder breaking into someones house and stabbing them while they slept.
  • Neville has probably killed more of his fair share of Subsiders (starving Vampires turned into Bat-like hybrids) so this would further confirm Neville delusion that all vampires Are bloodthirsty (no pun intended) inhuman monsters.
  • The novel takes place in Los Angeles, not New York. New York was used solely in the third adaptation of the novel in which Will Smith stars. In The Omega Man, it was set in Los Angels. In The Last Man on Earth, the city was never named nor shows noticeable landmarks to identify where it was (primarily because that film was shot in Rome, Italy).
  • Advertisement:
  • Perhaps Los Angeles was abandoned by nearly all the Daybreakers vampires because its geography and architecture were especially unsuitable for screening out sunlight. Only a few stubborn holdouts remained behind, degenerating into Subsiders/Daybreakers, which human holdout Neville proceeded to hunt by day and hide from by night.

The hero's daughter is not immune because she wasn't his.
Pity his wife cheated on him. (In the Price version at least.)

The book speculated that Neville was bitten before the story began, by a bat that carried a weakened form of the bacteria, developing his immunity.

  • That was in the Price version too. But it never said if the bat bite happened before or after he'd fathered his child.

The alternate ending is the real ending.
The ending is really the version of the story that was passed down through the centuries after mankind completely recovers, thus the name of the movie.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: