Officer Nolan and Bailey discover there's more to Fred's death than meets the eye; Officer Chen and Officer Bradford demand a treasure hunt rematch and enlist Officer Grey to help set the terms to a new bet.
Tropes:
- Face of an Angel, Mind of a Demon: Marcus Lindsey, who is as remorselessly sadistic as Judge Doom.
- Hope Spot: Officer Nolan gets a series of them during his final showdown with Marcus. When Nolan isn't intimidated by a knife, his captor produces a pistol. Then when Nolan appears to gain an advantage, his captor produces a shotgun, and later an automatic rifle.
- Improvised Weapon: Nolan scrounges a pair of scissors and uses them to ambush Marcus.
- Infinite Ammo: Averted when Marcus runs out of ammo, giving Nolan a chance to ambush him.
- A Taste of Their Own Medicine: Nolan finally subdues Marcus by running him over with his own car, just as he had been subduing all his victims.