Basic Trope: Food is served with weird ingredients.
- Straight: Mary's Eatery serves pizza with blueberries and toast on it.
- Exaggerated: Mary's Eatery serves pizza with earthworms, ceviche, and deep-fried oatmeal.
- Downplayed: Mary's Eatery serves chocolate pizza; an unusual food, but something that really does exist.
- Justified:
- Mary has a Bizarre Taste in Food.
- Some of the Wacky Cravings of some of her regulars while they were pregnant turned out to be quite the hit.
- Inverted:
- Mary's Eatery doesn't serve pizza with even the most standard toppings, like pepperoni.
- Really weird food is served with traditional condiments on it.
- Subverted: Spencer places an order for pizza with blueberries. Mary tells him that they don't serve it.
- Double Subverted: But they do serve it with blackberries, which are equally weird to see on a pizza.
- Parodied: Mary's Eatery has a huge array of pizza toppings, ranging from ones that are uncommon to inedible to straight-up impossible.
- Zig-Zagged: Mary's Eatery has a big array of pizza toppings. Some are normal, some are weird, some are regional delicacies, and others seem fictional but actually do exist.
- Averted: Mary's Eatery only serves pizza with normal toppings.
- Enforced: "Let's add some weird ingredients to Mary's Eatery's menu, then we can sell those as a tie-in with Pizza Hut."
- Lampshaded: "Welcome to Mary's Eatery! We know it might be weird, but blueberry pizza really is good!"
- Invoked: Mary decides to add some non-standard toppings that she likes to the menu.
- Exploited: Mary's Eatery gains a reputation for its weird ingredients, and becomes popular for those with weird tastes in food, or just those who enjoy being grossed out.
- Defied: Mary's Eatery doesn't want to waste money supplying ingredients and toppings that customers aren't likely to order.
- Discussed: "Have you heard that Mary started her own restaurant? What are you even going to be able to get there, toast pizza?"
- Conversed: "Why doesn't any restaurant on this show serve normal stuff?"
- Played for Laughs: Mary reads off a Long List of silly ingredients that are available for customers.
Want some more lobster on your Unconventional Food Order?
