Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ThreeWishes

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Theseus gets three wishes from Poseidon, and in {{Euripides}}' play ''Hippolytus,'' he uses one of them to kill the titular character.

to:

* Theseus gets three wishes from Poseidon, and in {{Euripides}}' play ''Hippolytus,'' ''{{Hippolytus}}'', he uses one of them to kill the titular character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The first wish is one typically made in haste, perhaps not quite believing that it would be granted. Sometimes they specifically wish for something trivial, just to "test" if their wish will really be granted at all. Other times they may waste it on something frivolous, like wishing that the neighbor's damned dog would stop barking. (Granted! [[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor A car plows into the neighbor's house, killing the dog in the process]].) Sometimes the second wish may also be wasted on something equally frivolous.

to:

* The first wish is one typically made in haste, perhaps not quite believing that it would be granted. Sometimes they specifically [[MundaneWish wish for something trivial, trivial]], just to "test" "[[GodTest test]]" if their wish will really be granted at all. Other times they may waste it on something frivolous, like wishing that the neighbor's damned dog would stop barking. (Granted! [[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor A car plows into the neighbor's house, killing the dog in the process]].) Sometimes the second wish may also be wasted on something equally frivolous.



Related to the RuleOfThree.

For this to work, the person with the wishes has to not be GenreSavvy enough to know to use the first wish to wish for the knowledge and wisdom to know what to use the last two wishes for.

to:

Related to the RuleOfThree.

RuleOfThree. For this to work, the person with the wishes has to not be GenreSavvy enough to know to use the first wish to wish for the knowledge and wisdom to know what to use the last two wishes for.
for.

See MundaneWish when one of the wishes (typically the first one) is spent on something trivially minor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[http://www.explosm.net/comics/2243/ In this]] CyanideAndHappiness strip, a character [[LoopholeAbuse manages to get around the tree wishes limit]] by [[spoiler:wishing more genies!]]

to:

* [[http://www.explosm.net/comics/2243/ In this]] CyanideAndHappiness strip, a character [[LoopholeAbuse manages to get gets around the tree wishes limit]] "can't wish for more wishes" restriction]] by [[spoiler:wishing for more genies!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A story by RobertSheckley features a man who received three wishes from the Devil, with no strings attached (appparently, Hell has more than enough souls as it is). Except that his worst enemy, naturally, gets the same twice. His final wish? "I want a woman who's the limit if my desires."

to:

* A story by RobertSheckley features a man who received three wishes from the Devil, with no strings attached (appparently, Hell has more than enough souls as it is). Except that whatever he wishes for, his worst enemy, naturally, enemy will receive twice as much of it. So if he gets rich, the same twice. other guy gets richer, and this eats at him. His final wish? "I want wish is for a woman who's sexual partner whose rapaciousness is at the absolute limit if my desires."of his ability to handle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
xxxHolic example



to:

* A rather grisly example shows up in ''xxxHolic''. A woman with a Monkeys paw that grants a wish for every finger first wishes for rain. That turned out fairly harmless, except that several local swimming pools ended up running dry (That's where the water came from). Later wishes, for some work to be done for her and for an accident to happen so she has an excuse to be late, result in her handing in what is provably someone else's work and a person falling in front of a subway train. When she wishes to get out of the mess she's gotten herself into, the monkey's paw strangles her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A story by RobertSheckley features a man who received three wishes from the Devil, with no strings attached (appparently, Hell has more than enough souls as it is). Except that his worst enemy, naturally, gets the same twice. His final wish? "I want a woman who's the limit if my desires."

to:

** * A story by RobertSheckley features a man who received three wishes from the Devil, with no strings attached (appparently, Hell has more than enough souls as it is). Except that his worst enemy, naturally, gets the same twice. His final wish? "I want a woman who's the limit if my desires."
* Joan Aiken's short story "[[http://aparker.wiki.hoover.k12.al.us/file/view/The+Third+Wish+by+Joan+Aiken.pdf The Third Wish]]" has a protagonist who's GenreSavvy enough to not accidentally waste his wishes on something stupid and even pricks his tongue with a thorn to make sure he doesn't make any careless wishes. He uses his first wish for a wife "as beautiful as the forest" and does get his perfect wife - except that she's actually a shapeshifted swan who's unhappy at having left her sister and life as a swan behind, and he decides to use his second wish to [[IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy turn her back into a swan]]. After seeing what happened with his first two wishes, he decides not to use his third wish and actually lives pretty contentedly for the most part taking care of his swan wife and sister-in-law and [[GoOutWithASmile dying with a smile on his face]].



* According to {{XKCD}}, [[http://xkcd.com/152/ if you do the first wish right ...]]

to:

* According to {{XKCD}}, ''{{XKCD}}'', [[http://xkcd.com/152/ if you do the first wish right ...]]



* There is a joke about the Devil offering a {{Doom}} fan three wishes, and then he'll take him to Hell. First wish: [[GodMode IDDQD]]. Second wish: IDKFA. Third wish... what wish? '''Take me to hell now'''! A variation exists where the Devil is not stupid... and sends him to [[NintendoHard Nightmare]].

to:

* There is a joke about the Devil offering a {{Doom}} ''{{Doom}}'' fan three wishes, and then he'll take him to Hell. First wish: [[GodMode IDDQD]]. Second wish: IDKFA. Third wish... what wish? '''Take me to hell now'''! A variation exists where the Devil is not stupid... and sends him to [[NintendoHard Nightmare]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''{{Goosebumps}}'': "Be Careful What You Wish For". First Samantha Byrd wishes that she would be the strongest member of the basketball team, but everyone else becomes weak. Then she wishes for Judith to stop bugging her, but everyone disappears. After Samantha resets the wishes, Judith accidentally wishes "Byrd, why don't you fly away?", turning her into a bird.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Also, as the Genie in ''{{Alladin}}'' stresses, ''"No wishing for more wishes!"''

to:

Also, as the Genie in ''{{Alladin}}'' ''{{Aladdin}}'' stresses, ''"No wishing for more '''more''' wishes!"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Also, as the Genie in ''{{Alladin}}'' stresses, ''"No wishing for more wishes!"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There is a joke about the Devil offering a {{Doom}} fan three wishes, and then he'll take him to Hell. First wish: [[GodMode IDDQD]]. Second wish: IDKFA. Third wish... what wish? '''Take me to hell now'''! A variation exists where the Devil is not stupid... and sends him to [[NintendoHard Nightmare]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The remake of {{Bedazzled}} has the main character forced by TheDevil to make his final wish, which in this case is to make sure that the object of his affection live a good life. The Reset Button is hit, with the Devil telling him that using one of his wishes for a selfless purpose voids the contract with her and he no longer owes her his soul.

to:

* The remake of {{Bedazzled}} has the main character forced by TheDevil to make his final wish, which in this case is to make sure that the [[IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy object of his affection live a good life. The Reset Button is hit, life]]. Everything goes back to normal, with the The Devil telling him that using one of his wishes for making a selfless purpose SelflessWish voids the [[DealWithTheDevil contract with her her]] and he no longer owes her his soul.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In "[[http://gaslight.mtroyal.ca/mnkyspaw.htm The Monkey's Paw]]" by W. W. Jacobs, the characters skip straight to wishing for lots of money. The second wish is then used in an attempt to undo the side-effects of the first wish, and the third wish to lay the side-effects of the second (fortunately without creating any new side-effects of its own).

to:

* In "[[http://gaslight.mtroyal.ca/mnkyspaw.htm The Monkey's Paw]]" by W. W. Jacobs, the characters skip straight to wishing for lots of money. The second wish is then used in an attempt to undo the side-effects of the first wish, wish (namely, the horrific death of their son), and the third wish to lay undo [[CameBackWrong the side-effects side-effects]] of the second (fortunately without creating any new side-effects of its own).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{Film]}}]

to:

[[AC:{{Film]}}][[AC:{{Film}}]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{Film]}}]
* The remake of {{Bedazzled}} has the main character forced by TheDevil to make his final wish, which in this case is to make sure that the object of his affection live a good life. The Reset Button is hit, with the Devil telling him that using one of his wishes for a selfless purpose voids the contract with her and he no longer owes her his soul.


Added DiffLines:

* Another joke involves a bear and a rabbit who despise each other who both find a genie. The bear uses his three wishes to be surrounded by females to the point that his final wish is to be the only male bear in the world. The rabbit uses his first two wishes for a helmet and a motorcycle to make an escape, but not before wishing that [[FateWorseThanDeath the bear was gay]].

Added: 309

Changed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:Literature]]
** A story by RobertSheckley features a man who received three wishes from the Devil, with no strings attached (appparently, Hell has more than enough souls as it is). Except that his worst enemy, naturally, gets the same twice. His final wish? "I want a woman who's the limit if my desires."



** A variation of this joke has the wisher as a woman instead, and the genie saying that her ex-husband will get ten times the things she wishes for. The woman uses her first and second wishes on typical things like money and houses. Her third wish? "I'd like to give birth to twins."

to:

** A variation of this joke has the wisher as a woman instead, and the genie saying that her ex-husband will get ten times the things she wishes for. The woman uses her first and second wishes on typical things like money and houses. Her third wish? Well, there are at least three variations: "I'd like to give birth to twins."/"I want big breasts"/"I want a lover with a 12 inch penis."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''[[TheHollows Dead Witch Walking]]'', Rachel apprehends a leprechaun who offers her three wishes if she'll let her go. Rachel decides to take the leprechaun up on her offer, intending to use the wishes to quit the IS and set up a freelance runner firm. Ivy and Jenks, believing the IS will try to have Rachel killed, offer to come along to help her along in exchange for a wish each. Rachel uses hers to avoid getting in trouble for taking the leprechaun's bribe, Jenks wishes to become sterile (he already has lots of kids and is afraid his wife would leave him otherwise), and Ivy gives hers to a banshee who helped her once, which causes trouble a few books later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheTwilightZone'' TOS episode "The Man in the Bottle". The genie actually granted ''four'' wishes; with the first wish being used solely to test the genie, the second being "one million dollars" (which they give away to friends, before federal and state income tax claims the rest), the third being a clear Type 2, and the fourth to return everything to normal. A closing TwilightZoneTwist ultimately undoes their first wish as well, leaving them with nothing but some wisdom learned from the experience.

to:

* ''TheTwilightZone'' TOS episode "The Man in the Bottle". The genie actually granted ''four'' wishes; with the first wish being used solely to test the genie, the second being "one million dollars" (which they give away to friends, before federal and state income tax claims claim the rest), the third being a clear Type 2, and the fourth to return everything to normal. A closing TwilightZoneTwist ultimately undoes their first wish as well, leaving them with nothing but some wisdom learned from the experience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheTwilightZone'' TOS episode "The Man in the Bottle". The genie actually granted ''four'' wishes; with the first wish being used solely to test the genie, the second being "one million dollars" (which they give away to friends, before federal income tax claims the rest), the third being a clear Type 2, and the fourth to return everything to normal. A closing TwilightZoneTwist ultimately undoes their first wish as well, leaving them with nothing but some wisdom learned from the experience.

to:

* ''TheTwilightZone'' TOS episode "The Man in the Bottle". The genie actually granted ''four'' wishes; with the first wish being used solely to test the genie, the second being "one million dollars" (which they give away to friends, before federal and state income tax claims the rest), the third being a clear Type 2, and the fourth to return everything to normal. A closing TwilightZoneTwist ultimately undoes their first wish as well, leaving them with nothing but some wisdom learned from the experience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[http://www.explosm.net/comics/2243/ In this]] CyanideAndHappiness strip, a character [[LoopholeAbuse manages to get around the tree wishes limit]] by [[spoiler:wishing more genies!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A short version is given as a ShaggyDogStory in ''PlanescapeTorment'', in the Brothel of Slaking Intellectual Lusts:

to:

* A short This version is given as something of a ShaggyDogStory twist in ''PlanescapeTorment'', in the Brothel of Slaking Intellectual Lusts:a short tale from ''PlanescapeTorment'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There is also a scary anecdote out there, that goes like this:
---> An old man comes to a rest after having travelled who knows how long.
---> He is tired, his bones ache and sits down by the roadside.
---> He remembers not who he is or why he travels.
---> Suddenly a young woman comes up to him and asks:
---> ''"What be your third wish?"''
---> He remembers not having been granted two wishes before this one.
---> ''"I wish I could remember it all,"'' he says.
---> She laughs.
---> ''"Why do you laugh?"'' he asks perplexed.
---> ''"That was your first wish."''
---> ''"And why is that funny?"''
---> ''"Your second wish was to forget it all again."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''An elderly man was sitting alone on a dark path. He wasn't certain of which direction to go, and he'd forgotten both where he was traveling to and who he was. He'd sat down for a moment to rest his weary legs, and suddenly looked up to see an elderly woman before him. She grinned toothlessly and with a cackle, spoke: "Now your *third* wish. What will it be?"\\

to:

->''An -->''An elderly man was sitting alone on a dark path. He wasn't certain of which direction to go, and he'd forgotten both where he was traveling to and who he was. He'd sat down for a moment to rest his weary legs, and suddenly looked up to see an elderly woman before him. She grinned toothlessly and with a cackle, spoke: "Now your *third* wish. What will it be?"\\

Added: 642

Changed: 669

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A short version is given as a ShaggyDogStory in ''PlanescapeTorment'', in the Intellectual Brothel. An old man is sitting on a bench, with absolutely no recollection of who he is, where he is, and how he got there. A genii descends on him and offers to grant his third wish. The man replies in confusion, "I wish to know who I am!" The genii says, "That was your first wish."

to:

* A short version is given as a ShaggyDogStory in ''PlanescapeTorment'', in the Brothel of Slaking Intellectual Brothel. An old Lusts:
->''An elderly
man is was sitting alone on a bench, with absolutely no recollection dark path. He wasn't certain of who he is, which direction to go, and he'd forgotten both where he is, was traveling to and how who he got there. A genii descends on him was. He'd sat down for a moment to rest his weary legs, and offers suddenly looked up to grant his third see an elderly woman before him. She grinned toothlessly and with a cackle, spoke: "Now your *third* wish. What will it be?"\\
"Third wish?"
The man replies in confusion, was baffled. "How can it be a third wish if I haven't had a first and second wish?"\\
"You've had two wishes already," the hag said, "but your second wish was for me to return everything to the way it was before you had made your first wish. That's why you remember nothing; because everything is the way it was before you made any wishes." She cackled at the poor man. "So it is that you have one wish left."\\
"All right," he said,
"I don't believe this, but there's no harm in wishing. I wish to know who I am!" The genii says, am."\\
"Funny," said the old woman as she granted his wish and disappeared forever.
"That was your first wish."
"''

Added: 145

Changed: 443

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Genies in Disney's ''Disney/{{Aladdin}}'' movies must give whomever hold their lamps three wishes, with three restrictions: they can't kill anybody (but [[CatchPhrase you'd be surprised what you can live through]]), they can't make anybody fall in love with anybody else, and they can't bring people back from the dead ([[CameBackWrong it's not a pretty picture...]] ''[[CameBackWrong they don't like doing it!]]'') And of course, wishing for more wishes is strictly forbidden. (But they can be goaded into using their powers anyway.)
** Aladdin actually gets himself 4 wishes by tricking the Genie, essentially getting himself a free "test wish" by saying "I bet you can't get us out of this cave!" (Genie takes the dare without realizing Aladdin didn't wish for anything)

to:

* Genies in Disney's ''Disney/{{Aladdin}}'' movies must give whomever hold their lamps three wishes, with three restrictions: they can't kill anybody (but (but, [[CatchPhrase as the sequel made clear]], "[[JerkassGenie you'd be surprised what surprised]] [[LoopholeAbuse what]] [[NonLethalKO you can can]] [[OnlyMostlyDead live through]]), through]]"), they can't make anybody fall in love with anybody else, and they can't bring people back from the dead ([[CameBackWrong it's not a pretty picture...]] ''[[CameBackWrong they don't like doing it!]]'') And of course, wishing for more wishes is strictly forbidden. (But they forbidden.
** But as Aladdin proved, genies
can apparently be goaded tricked into using their powers anyway.)
** Aladdin actually gets himself 4 wishes by tricking the Genie, essentially getting himself a
without making an official wish, when he doubts whether Genie can even free "test wish" by saying "I bet you can't get us out them from the Cave of this cave!" (Genie Wonders and Genie takes the dare dare, freeing them without realizing Aladdin didn't wish never actually ''wished'' for anything)it.
** And then there's when Jafar wishes for Jasmine to fall in love with him; Jasmine fakes it, [[CrowningMomentOfFunny much to Genie's surprise]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheTwilightZone'' TOS episode "The Man in the Bottle". A variation because the genie granted ''four'' wishes, with the second and third being Wish 2 type.

to:

* ''TheTwilightZone'' TOS episode "The Man in the Bottle". A variation because the The genie actually granted ''four'' wishes, wishes; with the first wish being used solely to test the genie, the second and being "one million dollars" (which they give away to friends, before federal income tax claims the rest), the third being Wish 2 type.a clear Type 2, and the fourth to return everything to normal. A closing TwilightZoneTwist ultimately undoes their first wish as well, leaving them with nothing but some wisdom learned from the experience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In most fiction, [[MakeAWish inanimate wish-granting objects]] (such as wishbones and birthday candles[[hottip:* :though a monkey's paw is a notable exception.]]) tend to grant only one wish. But when you're fortunate enough to find a living creature that can grant wishes, you'll most likely receive three (3) of them.

to:

In most fiction, [[MakeAWish inanimate wish-granting objects]] (such as wishbones and birthday candles[[hottip:* :though a monkey's paw is a notable exception.]]) tend to grant only one wish. But when you're fortunate enough to find a living creature that can grant wishes, you'll most likely receive three (3) [[RuleOfThree three]] of them.



* The first wish is one typically made in haste, perhaps not quite believing that it would be granted. Or, they may [[BeCarefulWhatYouSay not be careful what they say]] and unknowingly wish for another character to shut up, or something equally frivolous. Sometimes the second wish is also wasted in this manner. Alternately, the first wish can be a test wish for something simple, to prove their wishes can really be granted.
* The second wish is made with much greater care than the first wish, but the LiteralGenie will still succeed in eliciting [[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor tragic consequences]] from the wish, especially since the wisher now knows what the genie is capable of and has probably gotten greedy.
* The last wish, as that famous quote puts it, "[[ResetButton undoes the harm the first two wishes caused]]." A carefully-worded {{Wishplosion}} is laid, returning everything to normal. But if nothing of consequence came of the first two wishes, the third wish, desperately made in an attempt to elicit ''some'' gain from the wish-granting enterprise, will also backfire, but with hilarious consequences rather than tragic consequences.

Related to RuleOfThree.

to:

* The first wish is one typically made in haste, perhaps not quite believing that it would be granted. Or, Sometimes they may [[BeCarefulWhatYouSay not be careful what they say]] and unknowingly specifically wish for another character to shut up, or something equally frivolous. trivial, just to "test" if their wish will really be granted at all. Other times they may waste it on something frivolous, like wishing that the neighbor's damned dog would stop barking. (Granted! [[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor A car plows into the neighbor's house, killing the dog in the process]].) Sometimes the second wish is may also be wasted in this manner. Alternately, the first wish can be a test wish for on something simple, to prove their wishes can really be granted.
equally frivolous.
* The second wish is made with much greater care than the first wish, but the LiteralGenie with full awareness of what (obvious) consequences may result; they will still succeed carefully craft their second wish in eliciting [[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor a way that results in the maximum gain and the minimum unintended side effects. But the LiteralGenie, [[DangerouslyGenreSavvy well aware of their greed]], will usually find a way to exploit the person's ExactWords and attach some measure of unforeseen tragic consequences]] from consequence to their wish all the wish, especially since the wisher now knows what the genie is capable of and has probably gotten greedy.
same.
* The last wish, as that famous quote puts it, "[[ResetButton undoes wish -- almost invariably -- pushes the harm ResetButton and returns things to the first two wishes caused]]." A carefully-worded {{Wishplosion}} is laid, returning everything to normal. But [[StatusQuoIsGod status quo]] through one precisely worded {{Wishplosion}}. However, if nothing of consequence ever came of the first two wishes, the third wish, desperately wish (desperately made in an attempt to elicit ''some'' gain from the wish-granting enterprise, will gain) may also backfire, but with hilarious consequences rather than [[HilarityEnsues hilarious]] instead of tragic consequences.

Related to the RuleOfThree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''ASongOfIceAndFire'' the assassin Jaqen H'ghar offers Arya three very specific wishes. Specifically, she can say three names, and those people will die (because he'll kill them). As is traditional she ends up wasting the first two on a petty tormentor and a soldier who, while [[CompleteMonster vile]], was no worse than several of the others. Only after doing so does she realize that she could have said ''anyone'' and she should have killed the enemy commanders. The third name she says is [[spoiler: Jaqen H'gar, after he refuses to help her free the prisoners and have her family's forces take control of the castle. She unsays it after he helps her, but because several people were killed in the uprising he considers his debt to her paid and refuses to let her pick another name. He was apparently impressed, because he essentially offers her admission to his order before leaving.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> ''"your second wish was to forget it all."''

to:

---> ''"your ''"Your second wish was to forget it all.all again."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There is also a scary anecdote out there, that goes like this:
---> An old man comes to a rest after having travelled who knows how long.
---> He is tired, his bones ache and sits down by the roadside.
---> He remembers not who he is or why he travels.
---> Suddenly a young woman comes up to him and asks:
---> ''"What be your third wish?"''
---> He remembers not having been granted two wishes before this one.
---> ''"I wish I could remember it all,"'' he says.
---> She laughs.
---> ''"Why do you laugh?"'' he asks perplexed.
---> ''"That was your first wish."''
---> ''"And why is that funny?"''
---> ''"your second wish was to forget it all."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Theseus gets three wishes from Poseidon, and in {{Euripides}}' play ''Hippolytus,'' he uses one of them to kill the titular character.

Top