Follow TV Tropes

Following

History FramingTheGuiltyParty / KnownGuiltyParties

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DarkAngel'': A gangster commits murder by [[DestinationDefenestration throwing his victim out of a window]], thus making it look like suicide. Logan [[TheCoronerDothProtestTooMuch conspires with the coroner]] to put a cap in the corpse's head, then planta the gun on said gangster as he attempts to board an international flight.

to:

* ''Series/DarkAngel'': A gangster commits murder by [[DestinationDefenestration throwing his victim out of a window]], thus making it look like suicide. Logan [[TheCoronerDothProtestTooMuch conspires with the coroner]] to put a cap in the corpse's head, then planta plants the gun on said gangster as he attempts to board an international flight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DarkAngel'': A gangster commits murder by [[DestinationDefenestration throwing his victim out of a window]], thus making it look like suicide. Logan [[TheCoronerDothProtestTooMuch conspires with the coroner]] to put a cap in the corpse's head, then has Max plant the gun on the gangster as he attempts to board an international flight.

to:

* ''Series/DarkAngel'': A gangster commits murder by [[DestinationDefenestration throwing his victim out of a window]], thus making it look like suicide. Logan [[TheCoronerDothProtestTooMuch conspires with the coroner]] to put a cap in the corpse's head, then has Max plant planta the gun on the said gangster as he attempts to board an international flight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Manga/CaseClosed'': In the "Farewell Wine Murder Case", the victim witnessed his daughter poison the wine she presented to him and dumped it. He then faked being poisoned to test his other daughter's reaction. The man's personal doctor was aware of the plan and used the opportunity to inject the victim with the same poison, killing him while framing the daughter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Web Animation]]
* ''WebAnimation/EtraChanSawIt'': [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlZeTSVekMI Akane]] accuses Azami of running a scam, and Karin also heard rumors of her stealing people's things. Because of a scamming attempt on Karin's grandmother; she and Yuri hatch a plan to catch the scammer by telling Akane that Yuri's grandmother won the lottery, with Azami nearby, eavesdropping them. Karin and Yuri then meet at her grandmother's house with her husband Katsura accompanying her, and someone under the pseudonym of "Tsubaki" calls the house in an attempt to deceive Yuri's grandmother into giving the money to her. "Tsubaki" then arrives at Yuri's grandmother's house to receive the money, which leads to Karin unmasking her face, [[spoiler: and the person who is trying to scam Yuri's grandmother turns out to be Akane.]] [[spoiler: Hilariously, it's not just Akane who attempts to steal the money; the person she framed earlier, Azami is also trying to pull the same scam trick on Yuri's grandmother, causing both of them to be arrested for fraud.]]
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After some black men are arrested for seemingly killing a bunch of cops, they "escape" custody and are eventually gun downed by Exley. Afterwards, he talks to a Mexican girl who gave evidence against them and she admits she knows they didn't do it, but they did rape ''her'' and the police wouldn't have bothered pursuing them for that since she's just a poor minority in a racist city. To get justice, she didn't hesitate to frame them for a crime the police ''would'' be interested in.

to:

** After some black men are arrested for seemingly killing a bunch of cops, they "escape" custody and are eventually gun downed gunned down by Exley. Afterwards, he talks to a Mexican girl who gave evidence against them and she admits she knows they didn't do it, but they did rape ''her'' and the police wouldn't have bothered pursuing them for that since she's just a poor minority in a racist city. To get justice, she didn't hesitate to frame them for a crime the police ''would'' be interested in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'': In ''VideoGame/KnightsOfTheOldRepublic'', Jolee Bindo's old friend Sunry is accused of murder on Manaan, and the PlayerCharacter acts as his attorney. It turns out that Sunry, a Republic war hero, murdered TheMistress when he discovered she was a Sith HoneyTrap, then called Republic Intelligence to clean up the scene. The spy's Sith handlers then planted evidence to frame Sunry all over again. It's up to the PC what they do with this information: there's little enough untampered evidence that [[AmoralAttorney it's possible to get Sunry acquitted]] without taking any of the possible Dark Side actions (mainly using {{Jedi Mind Trick}}s to [[FantasticLegalWeirdness make witnesses perjure themselves]]), or you can have Sunry plead guilty.

to:

* ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'': In ''VideoGame/KnightsOfTheOldRepublic'', Jolee Bindo's old friend Sunry is accused of murder on Manaan, and the PlayerCharacter acts as his attorney. It turns out that Sunry, a Republic war hero, murdered TheMistress when he discovered she was a Sith HoneyTrap, then called Republic Intelligence to clean up the scene. The spy's Sith handlers then planted evidence to frame Sunry all over again. It's up to the PC what they do with this information: there's little enough untampered evidence that [[AmoralAttorney it's possible to get Sunry acquitted]] without taking any of the possible Dark Side actions (mainly using {{Jedi Mind Trick}}s to [[FantasticLegalWeirdness make witnesses perjure themselves]]), or you can have Sunry plead guilty. It is probably the best long term to get Sunry acquitted through the aforementioned no Dark Side trick, since he did kill a Sith spy in defense of the Republic and the Sith themselves thought they were framing an innocent man to cover up their own spy's death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This trope is a gameplay mechanic in ''VisualNovel/DanganronpaV3KillingHarmony'' as the "Perjury" system. If you know someone is guilty but can't prove it, you can change your Truth bullet into a Lie to catch them off guard.

to:

* This trope is a gameplay mechanic in ''VisualNovel/DanganronpaV3KillingHarmony'' as the "Perjury" system. If you know someone is guilty but can't prove it, you can change your Truth bullet into a Lie to catch them off guard. Of course, if you [[BadLiar lie about the wrong thing or at the wrong time]], you'll just make yourself look stupid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/GreatGrandUncleSchimmelhornsToolbox'': Sophia uses her {{Intangibility}} powers to frame [[Literature/{{Worm}} Taylor]] up for drug possession by planting drugs in her locker and calling in the police. Taylor, who has learned a trick to see and move objects through solid stuff, grabs the drugs and plants them into Sophia's pocket, which not only lets her do this, it also paints Sophia as too dumb to actually plant the drugs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed trope name.


* Invoked in ''Series/{{Grimm}}'' with the ogre Oleg Stark, who goes on a RageAgainstTheJusticeSystem when he escapes prison because evidence against him was ignored during his original arrest. However, in this case it was ignored because the investigating officials knew he had committed the crime in question; his “alibi” had been set up by Stark himself, who arranged for someone who looked like him to be seen in another place when Stark was committing his own crimes.

to:

* Invoked in ''Series/{{Grimm}}'' with the ogre Oleg Stark, who goes on a RageAgainstTheJusticeSystem RageAgainstTheLegalSystem when he escapes prison because evidence against him was ignored during his original arrest. However, in this case it was ignored because the investigating officials knew he had committed the crime in question; his “alibi” had been set up by Stark himself, who arranged for someone who looked like him to be seen in another place when Stark was committing his own crimes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/SaintsRow: The Third'', the S.T.A.G. Initiative is sent to put a stop to the gang violence by declaring martial law in the city. [[RootingForTheEmpire Thing is, they're entirely correct]]: the player-character is pretty much somewhere between SociopathicHero, PsychoForHire, and AxeCrazy. However, [[spoiler:in the penultimate mission, [[TheDragon Kia]] tries to fake a terrorist attack by the Saints]], and whether it succeeds or not is [[MultipleEndings up to the player]].

to:

* In ''VideoGame/SaintsRow: The Third'', ''VideoGame/SaintsRowTheThird'', the S.T.A.G. Initiative is sent to put a stop to the gang violence by declaring martial law in the city. [[RootingForTheEmpire Thing is, they're entirely correct]]: the player-character is pretty much somewhere between SociopathicHero, PsychoForHire, and AxeCrazy. However, [[spoiler:in the penultimate mission, [[TheDragon Kia]] tries to fake a terrorist attack by the Saints]], and whether it succeeds or not is [[MultipleEndings up to the player]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''[[Literature/{{Wilt}} Wilt on High]]'', Inspector Flint uncovers the drug-smuggling ring, but has only the perps' testimonies which, he knows, aren't a solid proof but allow him to receive a search warrant. Just after the warrant is signed, Flint has Sergeant Yates borrow the sample of captured drugs from the same case and visits the three of main suspects, planting minuscule amounts of the stuff at their homes (and notably doesn't even bother to visit the fourth one because he's fully sure the experts will find traces of drugs at her place without any "help"), stating that if these four are put on trial, they'll drag the entire gang down with them. When Yates laments that planting evidence isn't exactly a high moral standard, Flint doesn't disagree but notes that his scheme wouldn't work if the suspects weren't guilty: an innocent person would raise a fuss, while the real criminals would chalk it up to an accidental spill and blame their own clumsiness (as they really do in the end).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It turns up in "Rise from the Ashes", with [[spoiler: the Joe Darke case, in which the corrupt police chief ''committed a murder himself'', then set things up to look like an innocent was the unintentional culprit, so that said innocent's sister would frame the aforementioned Darke, a SpreeKiller against whom there would otherwise have been insufficient evidence]].
** The fourth case in ''[[VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyJusticeForAll Justice for All]]'' shows [[DeconstructedTrope the possible consequences of this trope]]. [[spoiler:Adrian Andrews planted evidence to frame Matt Engarde for the murder of his rival because she suspected that he had something to do with it. Indeed, he was the man who hired the assassin. But Phoenix manages to expose the contradictions and prove that she framed him... and suddenly ''she's'' the prime suspect in a murder she never committed!]]

to:

** It A complicated variant turns up in "Rise from the Ashes", with [[spoiler: the Joe Darke case, in which the corrupt police chief ''committed a murder himself'', then set things up to look like an innocent was the unintentional culprit, so that said innocent's sister would frame the aforementioned Darke, a SpreeKiller against whom there would otherwise have been insufficient evidence]].
** The fourth case in ''[[VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyJusticeForAll Justice for All]]'' shows [[DeconstructedTrope the possible consequences of this trope]]. [[spoiler:Adrian Andrews planted evidence to frame Matt Engarde for the murder of his rival because she suspected that he had something to do with it. Indeed, he She was the man who right; he'd hired an assassin to kill the assassin.guy for him. But Phoenix manages to expose the contradictions and prove that she framed him... and suddenly ''she's'' the prime suspect in a murder she never committed!]]she's genuinely innocent of.]]

Added: 793

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''Series/{{Victorious}}'' fic "[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10678828/1/Double-Trouble Double Trouble]]" (focusing on a world where Jade and Tori are dating), after an alternate Jade and Tori visit their timeline, upon returning to their own reality the alternate Jade is attacked by the alternate Beck, who here is an abusive boyfriend who evidence suggests raped past girlfriends and has been abusing Jade for months. After the alternate Beck is [[spoiler:left trapped in another universe, the "prime" Beck agrees to assist the others in posing as his counterpart to create a fake trail of evidence suggesting that his counterpart died in a car accident while trying to run away, ensuring that nobody will question where the "local" Beck went and giving the others a solid alibi]].



** A rather twisted example with Kay's actual killer in the film giving this reason for framing Kay's boyfriend for the crime (he has leverage on Dormer to cooperate with him), arguing that he beat her and "would have killed her someday anyway". [[{{Hypocrite}} Never mind that he is the one who violently beat her to death over the course of 15 minutes.]]

to:

** A rather twisted example with Kay's actual killer in the film giving this reason for framing Kay's boyfriend for the crime (he has leverage on Dormer to cooperate with him), arguing that he beat her and "would have killed her someday anyway". [[{{Hypocrite}} Never mind that he is the one who violently beat her to death over the course of 15 minutes.]]minutes]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Fanfic/TheCuttingEdge'', after [[spoiler:Laurel, Nyssa and Sara abduct Malcolm to answer for his crimes before the League of Assassins, Nyssa leaves a knife in the table to give the impression that Malcolm was abducted by the Triad or another local gang]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheIllusionist'': [[spoiler:The Crown Prince has beaten and possibly even killed women before. But the murder accusation that eventually [[DrivenToSuicide drives him to suicide]] is actually false.]] The frame-up is so good, even he believes that he did it.

to:

* ''Film/TheIllusionist'': ''Film/TheIllusionist2006'': [[spoiler:The Crown Prince has beaten and possibly even killed women before. But the murder accusation that eventually [[DrivenToSuicide drives him to suicide]] is actually false.]] The frame-up is so good, even he believes that he did it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Holmes quickly figured out the "murder victim" had committed suicide in an attempt to frame a man for her death, as there was no proof of his guilt in another crime, but his curiosity is roused to uncover the real crimes the man committed.

to:

** Holmes quickly figured out the "murder victim" had committed suicide in an attempt to frame a man for her death, as there was no proof of his guilt in another crime, but his curiosity is roused to uncover the real crimes the man committed. When the man keeps hindering their investigation Sherlock seriously considers planting evidence to get him into police custody. Watson is able to talk him down enough for him to work out how to genuinely prove the man's guilt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/StrangerThings'': Part of Season 2. In an attempt to get justice for Barb, and give her family some closure. They can't just say that Hawkins was performing experiments that caused them to open a tunnel into an alternate dimension, unleashing a monster into our world that devoured Barb. Instead, they frame Hawkins for a toxic chemical leak, telling everyone Barb was killed by it and they disposed of her body to cover it up.

to:

* ''Series/StrangerThings'': Part of Season 2. In an attempt to get justice for Barb, and give her family some closure. They can't just say that Hawkins was performing experiments that caused them to open a tunnel into an alternate dimension, unleashing a monster into our world that devoured Barb. Instead, they frame Hawkins for a [[GasLeakCoverUp toxic chemical leak, leak]], telling everyone Barb was killed by it and they disposed of her body to cover it up.

Added: 819

Changed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mentioned in ''Film/LAConfidential''. Captain Smith tells Lt. Exley that Exley won't be able to handle being a detective precisely because he wouldn't be willing to frame a suspect he knew to be guilty. After murdering a gangbanger in cold blood for kidnapping and raping a girl, Bud White actually plants a gun on him to make the execution look like self-defense.

to:

* Mentioned in ''Film/LAConfidential''. ''Film/LAConfidential''.
**
Captain Smith tells Lt. Exley that Exley won't be able to handle being a detective precisely because he wouldn't be willing to frame a suspect he knew to be guilty. After murdering a gangbanger in cold blood for kidnapping and raping a girl, Bud White actually plants a gun on him to make the execution look like self-defense.self-defense.
** After some black men are arrested for seemingly killing a bunch of cops, they "escape" custody and are eventually gun downed by Exley. Afterwards, he talks to a Mexican girl who gave evidence against them and she admits she knows they didn't do it, but they did rape ''her'' and the police wouldn't have bothered pursuing them for that since she's just a poor minority in a racist city. To get justice, she didn't hesitate to frame them for a crime the police ''would'' be interested in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/StrangerThings'': Part of Season 2. In an attempt to get justice for Barb, and give her family some closure. They can't just say that Hawkins was performing experiments that caused them to open a tunnel into an alternate dimension, unleashing a monster into our world that devoured Barb. Instead, they frame Hawkins for a toxic chemical leak, telling everyone Barb was killed by it and they disposed of her body to cover it up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Scandal}}'': In "Hell Hath No Fury", Pope & Associates takes on the case of a man charged with rape. Harrison discovers that the man's accuser had a best friend who killed herself after being raped by their client, and the accuser is framing him for her own rape as revenge. While the client beats the rape charges, Olivia is able to convince his mother to turn him over to the police for the rape he actually committed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Series/Liar}}'': Laura attempts this, along with Vanessa, against [[spoiler:Andrew]] to prove he raped them when legal evidence isn't forthcoming. It fails though.

to:

* ''{{Series/Liar}}'': ''Series/Liar2017'': Laura attempts this, along with Vanessa, against [[spoiler:Andrew]] to prove he raped them when legal evidence isn't forthcoming. It fails though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Played with in the backstory for ''VisualNovel/TheGreatAceAttorney'', with [[spoiler:Tobias Gregson]] planting evidence to prove that the Professor, [[spoiler:or rather Genshin Asogi]] had killed Klint van Ziek. The reason that it was partial was that while [[spoiler:Genshin had killed Klint, he wasn't the true Professor as Gregson thought]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now Flame Bait and Darth.


** Used in "Redrum," when Catherine, Brass, and [=McKeen=] fake the murder of a snitch so the forensics will point at a suspected murderer. The goal is [[BluffingTheMurderer to get the murderer to unwittingly reveal evidence]] for the murders he actually ''did'' commit. Their own team members (who initially think that Internal Affairs is just messing with them) eventually discover the conspiracy. It only falls apart because [=McKeen=] was ''supposed'' to let the judge and D.A. in on the scheme, but neglected to do so [[spoiler:(which may be FridgeBrilliance as much later he turns out to be TheMole)]]. They still get the bad guy, though, because he really was [[WhatAnIdiot stupid enough to fall for it]], and it turned out that he was the killer of the B-plot as well, and they had stronger evidence pinning him for that crime.

to:

** Used in "Redrum," when Catherine, Brass, and [=McKeen=] fake the murder of a snitch so the forensics will point at a suspected murderer. The goal is [[BluffingTheMurderer to get the murderer to unwittingly reveal evidence]] for the murders he actually ''did'' commit. Their own team members (who initially think that Internal Affairs is just messing with them) eventually discover the conspiracy. It only falls apart because [=McKeen=] was ''supposed'' to let the judge and D.A. in on the scheme, but neglected to do so [[spoiler:(which may be FridgeBrilliance as much later he turns out to be TheMole)]]. They still get the bad guy, though, because he really was [[WhatAnIdiot stupid enough to fall for it]], it, and it turned out that he was the killer of the B-plot as well, and they had stronger evidence pinning him for that crime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This was more or less the standard operating procedure of the LAPD (and possibly other police departments all over the US) — "We know who did it, so let's fabricate further evidence to ensure a faster and smoother trial". This is a large part of why O.J. Simpson went free, and that embarrassment has at least seemingly put an end to its wide-scale use.

to:

* This was more or less the standard operating procedure of the LAPD (and possibly other police departments all over the US) — "We know who did it, so let's fabricate further evidence to ensure a faster and smoother trial". This is a large part of why O.J. Simpson UsefulNotes/OJSimpson went free, and that embarrassment has at least seemingly put an end to its wide-scale use.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Manga/InoHeadGargoyle'': Saejima is fully prepared to do this if he and Shizuka can't find any evidence to incriminate her BadBoss.

to:

* ''Manga/InoHeadGargoyle'': Saejima [[DirtyCop Saejima]] is fully prepared to do this if he and Shizuka can't find any evidence to incriminate her BadBoss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Manga/InoHeadGargoyle'': Saejima is fully prepared to do this if he and Shizuka can't find any evidence to incriminate her BadBoss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fourth case in ''[[VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorney Justice for All]]'' shows [[DeconstructedTrope the possible consequences of this trope]]. [[spoiler:Adrian Andrews planted evidence to frame Matt Engarde for the murder of his rival because she suspected that he had something to do with it. Indeed, he was the man who hired the assassin. But Phoenix manages to expose the contradictions and prove that she framed him... and suddenly ''she's'' the prime suspect in a murder she never committed!]]
** The first case of the fourth game, ''{{VisualNovel/Apollo Justice|Ace Attorney}}'', plays it straight two ways: [[spoiler:Phoenix is accused of a murder he didn't commit. The evidence has been destroyed, but Phoenix forges it to convict the real killer (he set up a HeadsIWinTailsYouLose situation, since the killer knows that the evidence is forged, but saying it out loud confirms that he ''was'' at the crime scene when it happened, thus having no alibi). Apollo is less than happy when he finds out about it. Olga Orly and Shadi Smith planted a card to make Phoenix look like a cheater; while the accusation is false, Phoenix occasionally cheated by relying on Trucy's ability to perceive the tells of opponents]].

to:

** The fourth case in ''[[VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorney ''[[VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyJusticeForAll Justice for All]]'' shows [[DeconstructedTrope the possible consequences of this trope]]. [[spoiler:Adrian Andrews planted evidence to frame Matt Engarde for the murder of his rival because she suspected that he had something to do with it. Indeed, he was the man who hired the assassin. But Phoenix manages to expose the contradictions and prove that she framed him... and suddenly ''she's'' the prime suspect in a murder she never committed!]]
** The first case of the fourth game, ''{{VisualNovel/Apollo ''VisualNovel/{{Apollo Justice|Ace Attorney}}'', plays it straight two ways: [[spoiler:Phoenix is accused of a murder he didn't commit. The evidence has been destroyed, but Phoenix forges it to convict the real killer (he set up a HeadsIWinTailsYouLose situation, since the killer knows that the evidence is forged, but saying it out loud confirms that he ''was'' at the crime scene when it happened, thus having no alibi). Apollo is less than happy when he finds out about it. Olga Orly and Shadi Smith planted a card to make Phoenix look like a cheater; while the accusation is false, Phoenix occasionally cheated by relying on Trucy's ability to perceive the tells of opponents]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a variant on the theme in ''ComicBook/JusticeSocietyOfAmerica'', Wildcat reveals he once framed a man for the murder of his own family, because the man had, in retribution, killed the actual murderer and his innocent family, but there wasn't a way to get (or apparently plant) the evidence linking him to the crime of killing the other family. It's still played as being an act of MoralDissonance for Wildcat, and he pays for it with [[spoiler:all but the last of his supernatural nine lives]].

to:

* In a variant on the theme in ''ComicBook/JusticeSocietyOfAmerica'', Wildcat reveals he once framed a man for the murder of his own family, because the man had, in retribution, killed the actual murderer and his innocent family, but there wasn't a way to get (or apparently plant) the evidence linking him to the crime of killing the other family. It's still played as being an act of MoralDissonance MoralEventHorizon for Wildcat, and he pays for it with [[spoiler:all but the last of his supernatural nine lives]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: Radio]]

to:

[[folder: Radio]][[folder:Radio]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''[[Manga/GreatTeacherOnizuka GTO: 14 Days in Shonan]]'', Urumi frames Sakurako's abusive father for counterfeiting, since there's no guarantee that he'd be sent to prison for long, even with the evidence they have of his physical and sexual abuse of his daughter.

Top