The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Yes. Zap all that bullshit.

Eddie's on it. Anything that needs to be reflagged will be in time.

edited 11th Jul '12 2:02:01 AM by shimaspawn

Well we shouldn't zap it all. Some of it is cut-worthy.

"*Porn with Plot: Or more precisely, "Porn with characterization" - you can tell that both friends care deeply for each other, even though you pretty much only ever see them having sex together."

I'd say this is an exaggeration. Maka Maka got more non-sex than this says.

edited 11th Jul '12 2:05:22 AM by Adannor

Komodin, you deserve a hug. Sorry about all this mess. You do way too much hard work for us. Thank you.

Now that that's cleared up. Is it okay if I re-flag the 5 I think are worth looking into?

I feel for ya, Komodin. *hugs*

Well, now that that rush is done with. Anything new that can be looked at?(or old to clear up the queue.)

SO, back to the old queue:

• Hell MOO has an entire site to perlustrate: http://hellmoo.org/. Its page mentions rape, but from a quick perlustration of the site I can't see it being important - although it seems to have a "rape" command. I also saw a thread on Something Awful, but I am not reading through that awful formatting...
• Wicked City has plenty of You Tube videos, a Wikipedia page. From GIS it seems to have Body Horror and nudity but no outright porn. Now that I see dvdtalk.com mentions that it has people being raped, but has a plot too.

edited 11th Jul '12 2:30:43 AM by SeptimusHeap

Wicked City doesn't have anything remotely pedo-pandering, there's a definite plot, and IIRC the sex is fairly graphic but never crosses over into X-rated territory. I would call it a "keep w/cleanup as needed".

Maka Maka's characters are all in college IIRC, so it's covered on that angle. It has a lot of nudity and most chapters have one explicit yuri scene, but it's also very character-driven and is more about the relationship between the two women than the sex. It probably needs to be reviewed, but even if it's cut, I'd still recommend it.

edited 11th Jul '12 4:21:58 AM by Willbyr

Under our content policies, Manga.Negimaru needs to be cut. It is hardcore porn.

What's more, it is hardcore porn involving Japanese 3rd year middle-schoolers, which is equivelent to American high school freshmen. While I'm perfectly fine with having an ecchi fanservice heavy series with teens of that age, like the actual Negima series, or even a work with some mild teen-on-teen sex discretely presented, we don't need the stuff in Manga.Negimaru.

Also, we have the following two works from April 27 (the start of the flag list ) with two angels and no devils. Can anyone think of a reason not to give them one more angek and resolve them?

Manga.Kamisama Dolls

Manga.Nana To Kaoru

edited 11th Jul '12 4:40:54 AM by Catbert

Since our P5 have been getting tired, tdgoodrich1 has been promoted to occupy the vacant position.

Congratulations. Lets us commemorate this event with gallons of Brain Bleach. We'll need them.

My condolences, tdgoodrich1.

edited 11th Jul '12 5:41:39 AM by Ramidel

I was expecting it

Good luck and lots of Brain Bleach too

Congrats, tdgoodrich1, I'll start preparing a funeral for your liver.

Anyways, I'm not really sure why Karismia Dolls was flagged, but then again I've only read a bit of the manga, and from what I've seen its worst crime is being violent as hell at times...and for having a robot that looks vaguely similar to Kyubey. It's fairly safe, otherwise. Easy angel.

edited 11th Jul '12 5:46:51 AM by Raidouthe21st

Firstly: Congratulations to tdgoodrich1 on his new position. We all saw that coming a mile away.

Next: Okay, I missed the barrage of flaggings, but some of those do warrant review sooner or later. To address Septimus's concerns:

Just had a look through the first two volumes of Princess Lucia. It's very ecchi, but Barbie Doll Anatomy is in full effect and there's no actual sex involved. The trouble is that there's some major art dissonance here, so bear with me.

The main cast is supposedly 13-15 in their human forms. (2 angels, 2 demons as of the second volume.) The problem is that they definitely don't look prepubescent (seriously, whoever wrote that MAL entry needs to be beat over the head with a dictionary) - or even at the younger end of the 13-19 age range, with one exception. Seo Kouji's characters tend to look the same regardless of character age - see Suzuka and Kimi No Iru Machi for comparison - and the female cast in this one could probably pass for any age up to their early twenties.

Leviathan (the one on the right) is a tricky case. She's got the mindset of a younger child (mistaking the male and female leads for her parents) and a casual approach to nudity due to ignorance of social norms, and the body of what's apparently supposed to be a relatively younger teen compared to the other characters - or at least a less-developed one compared to the buxom main cast. Her scenes probably aren't supposed to be overtly sexual in nature, barring the occasional use of Innocent Innuendo, but even that's a little problematic.

All things considered, I'm leaning towards keeping this one unless new evidence arises - although the page could probably benefit from a little clean-up. Pretty close call, though, and it could've gone either way.

Before I forget:

• Demographic (according to Baka-Updates): Shonen
• Magazine: Comic Blade
• Also serialised: Peacemaker Kurogane, Amanchu, Elemental Gelade, Binchou-Tan

Now, on to other things - I apologise for calling 5P's decision into question, but I'm very surprised that Iron Virgin Jun received two devilheads, especially since I didn't see anything overtly wrong (in terms of content violation) with it, and the OVA is actually quite clean. Did I miss something?

edited 12th Jul '12 2:27:02 AM by Pyrite

The Jun thing was described in a review to have surprisingly little sex but also a premise involving rapists for hire.

Thanks for the kind words. I accept bribes in the form of US currency, Treasury bonds, and liquor.

On a serious note: Gave Kamisama Dolls its third angel. Any of you other P5'ers want to argue about the disposition, or just keep it? Also resolved Ro-Kyu-Bu with disposition of "Blatant pedopandering, do not restore."

Also: Unfortunately, I will be leaving the country tomorrow and won't be returning until the 20th. I will try to get done what I can today, but I have preparations for the trip to make still.

edited 11th Jul '12 7:15:56 AM by tdgoodrich1

I am currently looking back on some items way behind in the queue:

• Fill The Moon is not porn, judging by a random sample of fanfiction.net pages. It was flagged for Senayax being impregnated, apparently.
• Jungle de Ikou! has Mii with giant breasts (Gag Boobs apparently) but it doesn't look like paedobait. No mention of porn so far
• Legend of the Blue Wolves is Yaoi with censored and uncensored versions. The plot doesn't sound porn-ey despite being called hentai and GIS providing some pornographic images
• Silver Chaos 2 Artificial Mermaid has pornography, but is apparently not pure porn. It's a sequel to Silver Chaos - was that cut for content policy violations?

AFAIK, Jungle De Ikou's only possible offense is that the 10-year-old protagonist Natsumi has to do a Magic Dance for her Transformation Sequence that gradually becomes more sexually suggestive in its movements and sounds. Observe (starts at 00:42).

edited 11th Jul '12 8:20:22 AM by MarqFJA

Zapped Main.Sarah Kennedy. Presumably a misclick.

edited 11th Jul '12 8:27:38 AM by tdgoodrich1

Seems like comedy to me. Comments: but you can see her panties. also, she squeezes her chest, but there's nothing there.

I wasn't here to do this earlier, but congratulations to tdgoodrich1 on making the P5. It's really wonderful news.

I don't know if I should congratulate or pity tgoodrich1, but I wish him all the best and enough Brain Bleach. Let's hope that having a full panel takes some pressure from the other members.

edited 11th Jul '12 8:33:41 AM by jkbeta

Oh good we finally have another P5 member. Congratulations, tdgoodrich. Now all we need is for Catalogue to return.

Congrats, tgoodrich; your work's been exemplary.

edited 11th Jul '12 8:54:01 AM by Willbyr