An Angel for Christmas: It's strongly implied that Angela, a little girl, and Wilfred, a wolf, have been alive at least since the birth of Jesus Christ. Justified, being that Angela is an angel, and all.
Kida in Atlantis: The Lost Empire is said to be old enough to forget her original written language. Milo estimates her age as somewhere around 8,500 years. She replies "yes", as though this isn't anything to be surprised about. One Atlantean year is equivalent to 300 human years. This would mean that if Kida's age was compared to that of a normal human's, then she would approximately be 28 years old.
Mother Gothel from Tangled is stated to be several centuries old.
The LEGO Ninjago Movie: Master Wu is 167 years old according to Cole, and he's considered the younger brother of Garmadon, who claims to be 174 years old.
Zigzagged with Lady Amalthea in The Last Unicorn. While she is the immortal unicorn turned human (she Really Was Born Yesterday) and initially plays this trope to a T, her human self slowly overwrites her unicorn self. By the end of the story, she is the young woman she appears to be. When the unicorn becomes herself again, Amalthea 'dies.'
Minions hints that at least some of the titular creatures may be as old as the Cretaceous period, if not older.
Crush from Finding Nemo is a hundred fifty years old, and is still young.note Truth in Television for large turtles; even snapping turtles can live over seventy-five years, and tortoises and sea turtles have been known to live to 200.
Sheriff Woody from Toy Story just happens to be the leader and the oldest member of Andy's toys (he was created in the 1950s). Jessie, Bullseye, and, Stinky Pete, who are part of Woody's Roundup show, are on the same box (though since Stinky Pete appropriately looks like a grandpa, he can be considered an aversion).
Although WALL•E is seven hundred years old, he is actually still working even after the day humanity left Earth. Somewhat justified in that he's seen replacing damaged parts using components from other robots of the same model, of which there are hundreds or thousands lying around. It's likely he's replaced every part of himself many times over, save for his motherboard, RAM and memory.
Jack Frost in is at least 300-years-old — but he barely looks past his late teens. He sacrificed himself to save his little sister as a human — because of this, he gained immortality and the power to control ice and snow.
All of the Guardians are even older than Jack, who is the youngest member of the group. While Santa, Easter Bunny, and Tooth Fairy all appeared in historical times, it seems that the Sandman has existed since humans first started to dream, as has his Evil Counterpart, Pitch, putting them closer to Time Abyss territory. Then there is the Man on the Moon, who is probably as old as the Moon itself...
Aisling from The Secret of Kells is a fairy (with supplementary materials confirming her to be one of the Tuatha Dé Danann) and in her opening monologue she says that she's "lived through many ages". However, she has the appearance of a little girl who doesn't look any older than Brendan, the 12-year-old protagonist. Towards the end of the film, when Brendan is now an adult, she doesn't look any older despite how many years have passed.
Live-Action
In 7 Faces of Dr. Lao, the eponymous doctor is technically an example of this trope, in that he looks rather old, but not nearly his true age of seven thousand, three hundred and twenty-two.
Doctor Baron Volmer is almost 300 years old and Hannah is around 200 in A Cure for Wellness.
Bit: Duke turns out to be somewhere in her sixties, as she was twenty-something during the early 1970s. Vlad is centuries old, while it's possibly implied he is meant to be Dracula. If so, he'd be around 580 years old.
Near the end of Blade (1998), the titular character discovers that his mother Vanessa Brooks, who he thought died during childbirth, is still alive and is a vampire, not looking a day older from when she gave birth to him. Indeed, her actress is actually nine years younger than Wesley Snipes, Blade's actor, and one year younger than the actress playing Dr. Karen Jenson, the film's female lead who reminded Blade of his mother.
Additionally, Blade's nemesis Deacon Frost turns out to have been the one who attacked Blade's mother all those years ago, while he looks to be about Blade's age. Of course, since the films are about vampires, it's pretty much a guarantee that this trope will be in effect for a good number of them.
Diana/Wonder Woman looks like she stopped aging in her 30s. She is also millennia old (being a demi-goddess helps) — in 1984 and 2015, she looks the same as in 1918 while Etta Candy has aged and died in the meantime.
SHAZAM! (2019): The Wizard who transfers his powers to Billy Batson is old enough to remember Black Adam's rampage millennia ago.
Darkseid (as Uxas) led the Apokoliptian forces in ancient times and rules Apokoplips thousands of years later.
SHAZAM! Fury of the Gods has the Daughters of Atlas, with the worst case being Anthea, who looks like a schoolgirl (played by 20 year old Rachel Zegler) but is 6,000 years old.
The titular character in Dracula 2000 is significantly older than Bram Stoker's version, being about 2000 years old, as he's actually Judas Iscariot.
The Dungeons & Dragons (2000) film has this interaction between Snails and Norda the elf, when Snails is chatting her up:
Norda: How old are you? Snails: Twenty-three. Yeah, I know I'm a little young for you, but what if I get my hands on an aging potion, huh? I'll sacrifice a couple of years for you. Norda: I'm two hundred and thirty-four.
In Frankenstein Island, Dr. Van Helsing does not look like a young man, but Doc is astounded to learn that he is over 200 years old.
In the film version of The Green Mile, Mr. Jingles the mouse is still alive, albeit very elderly, after an unprecedented sixty years. Mice normally only live for one to three years, making the little guy older than Methuselah when adjusted for species. Paul Edgecomb is 108 years old at the end of the movie, which is nothing too impressive yet, but the implication is that he may live to see his thousandth birthday, a thought that keeps him up at night.
Hancock: Hancock and Mary are both several thousand years old.
Miriam and John in The Hunger, since they're both vampires. She turned him, and the trouble in the movie starts when his years begin to catch up with him, as eventually and invariably happens to all her companions...
In Time: The aging gene has been disabled and Immortality Begins at Twenty. This would logically provide people with immortality, but the average lifespan hasn't actually gone up that much, though; due to lifespan replacing money it's only the rich that really live forever. Will and Sylvia are as old as their appearances suggest, while Will's mother is double that, making her Older Than They Look. However, Sylvia's father, Phillipe, states during his birthday party that he is "25 for the 85th time", which means that he is 109 years old.
The Invitation (2022): Deville is implied to be Dracula, so he's at least seven hundred years old, while Viktoria says she's four hundred. Lucy is a hundred years old. Mr. Field, Mrs. Swift and the Harkers are all around a hundred years old at least as they appear unchanged in photographs from the 1920s.
The giants from Jack the Giant Slayer are long-lived, with many being the original invaders during their first invasion of Earth.
Frank AKA Francisco from Jungle Cruise, who turns out to be one of Aguirre's conquistadors who has been cursed to never leave the river (even though he turned against Aguirre himself). As he himself puts it, he's been around for roughly 390 years, having built a whole town along the river and watching many people come and die along the way. Much like Aguirre and the other conquistadors, he is also unkillable due to the curse, which is how his secret is found out.
All the Abrasax siblings in Jupiter Ascending, and potentially any monied character Jupiter encounters in space. Kalique in particular just turned 14,004 years old and her mother was in her 91st millennium when she died (and not of old age).
Pai Mei from Kill Bill, maybe. If the story about him causing the Shaolin massacre in the year 1003 AD was completely true and not a case of In-Universe case of Memetic Mutation, yes.
Monk: She's 3,000 years old. Kull: She said she was 19!
The main character of The Last Witch Hunter is eight hundred years old in the present day part of the plot, thanks to immortality he gains in the flashback part. He has surprisingly little trouble fitting in with modern society.
Dorian Gray, in the film version of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. His exact age isn't given, but curmudgeonly old Allan Quartermain (played by Sean Connery) mentions that as a boy, he saw Gray giving a lecture at Eton College. In the original novel, Gray is never said to be immortal or invulnerable; he just retains his youthful appearance.
Abby from Let Me In looks like a 12 year old girl, but she is a vampire. She was with her caretaker Thomas since childhood and he is a middle-aged man during the film. A deleted scene shows her being turned into a vampire by her uncle. This would give her an age of several centuries.
In The Lord of the Rings films, like the books, many characters are Older Than They Look, but the Elves, Ents and Wizards are all hundreds or thousands of years old.
Elrond is featured in the opening prologue, which happens three thousand years before the story proper starts. When we meet him in the "present", he looks exactly the same.
Galadriel (as explained in the books) is even older; she's the only Elf remaining in Middle-earth who is mentioned before the first rising of the Sun, about seven thousand years ago. She's played by Cate Blanchett, who was in her early thirties at the time of filming.
Arwen was 2901 years old when she died. She didn't look any older than her mid-twenties. Likewise, Legolas was probably around her age when the Fellowship was active, and... well, there is a pattern.
The Wizards (and Sauron) are all Maiar, and so are literally older than the universe, having sang it into being.
More a case of Older Than They Look, Aragorn: in an Extended Edition scene from The Two Towers, Eowyn is surprised to learn that he is actually 87 years old. He doesn't look ageless, however: he looks like a very fit and active man in his late 40's, his hair flecked with a little gray. This is because he is a Dunedain, "blessed with long life" - but not eternal life. The books explain that the Dunedain live about three times longer than regular humans (Aragorn ultimately lived to be over 210 years old).
John from The Man from Earth looks like a regular guy in his mid-30s, not like the 14,000-year-old former caveman that he actually is.
In The Man Who Could Cheat Death, Gerrard estimates Bonnet's age as being around 35. He is actually 104, having extended his youth by means of his elixir.
Thor: Asgardians can live hundreds, if not thousands of years and still be physically capable of feats of strength. The same thing applies to Frost Giants. If Loki was born about the same time as the battle in the prologue, that makes him over 1040 years old. In the sequel, he comments that Asgardians can live for approximately 5000 years. In Infinity War Thor states he's 1500 years old; Loki is likely about the same age given they grew up together.
Thor: Ragnarok: The Grandmaster says he would be considered millions of years old on any other planet. On Sakaar — surrounded as it is by time-warping wormholes — he appears to be merely a Silver Fox (he's played by Jeff Goldblum, who was in his mid-60s at the time).
Avengers: Infinity War: Red Skull has been living in Vormir for more than seventy (Earth) years and still looks the same as he did in Captain America: The First Avenger. Compare this with Steve and Bucky who are merely Older Than They Look since it's still possible for them to live today. Red Skull, on the other hand, was already a middle-aged man back then; he would be something like 120 years old today.
Speaking of Infinity War, Big Bad Thanos was confirmed to be well over 1,000 years old. Although age doesn’t seem to slow him down in the slightest, if anything just makes Thanos more deadly as he puts his millennia of experience to good use when thrashing the heroes. Thanos even defeated both Thor (initially) and Loki despite them being at least five centuries older than him.
In Eternals, the titular Eternals look the same as they did when they arrived on Earth at approximately 5000 BC. This frustrates Sprite who has the appearance a young girl for many millennia and is treated as such.
Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Movie has Dulcea, the green bikini-clad master warrior of Phaedos who guards the Great Power and is at least 10,000 years old, but maintains the appearance of a teenage girl. However, after she gives the Rangers their new powers, she explains she can't walk towards the Ninjetti temple or it'll age her rapidly.
Nanny McPhee: The titular Nanny McPhee perpetually looks like a middle-aged woman, despite the first and second films being more than sixty years apart.
Once Bitten: The Countess is around four hundred years old, while Sebastian her butler is about the same since he knows her true age. Both look about forty at most, due to being vampires.
In The Santa Clause, all the elves are played by children, one of whom informs Scott that she has "pointy shoes that are older than you". Judy, one of the head elves, looks to be about ten years old. When she mentions that it took her 1,200 years to perfect her cocoa recipe, Scott Calvin/Santa Claus tells her, "You know I must say, you look pretty good for your age," to which she hilariously responds, "Thanks... but I'm seeing someone in wrapping," eliciting a stare, a look of shock and a silently-mouthed "ooookay..." from Scott/Santa.
In Shandra: The Jungle Girl, Shandra looks like she is in her mod-20s, but is at least 90 years old, and there are strong hints that she is actually far, far older.
Yoda: When 900 years old you reach, look as good you will not, hm? [chuckles]
The vampiric Anzati, who appear in many Expanded Universe novels, are an entire race who qualify. They can live to be up to a millennia.
Special mention goes to Chewbacca, who by the time of A New Hope is 200 years old.
Andre Linoge, from Storm Of The Century. It's never made clear how long he's been around, but it's implied to have been at least since Biblical times. Toyed with in that, though he is old and still has at least another century to live (stating to the town that he will still be alive when the youngest among them has grown old and died), even others of his kind consider him to be nearing death. Which makes sense; if you've been around for at least 1000 years, another 100 is going to seem like just a few months.
Sweet, Sweet Lonely Girl: Beth is far older than she looks, as a Life Drinker who drains other people's youth. She is shown at the end in photos with Dora years back when the latter was a young woman and appears no older than at present.
Theresa & Allison: Allison was turned at age seventeen, though Theresa calculates she's really sixty nine by now, but still looks just the same. The vampire who gives her orientation also was turned in the time of the Black Plague (which started during the mid 1300s) while looking around thirty five, maybe forty at most.
The Tin Drum: The main character, Oskar, willingly stops aging, resulting in an adult male in the body of a toddler. Towards the end of the film, he meets a dwarf who appears to be an adult, but reveals that he's really close to one hundred years old. Like Oscar, he decided to stop aging, and says there are others like him. They mention that they could essentially become immortal if they wanted, invoking this trope.
Transformers: Revenge of The Fallen: Alice, who at first glance looks like a human college student who's in her early 20's at most. In reality, she's actually at least several millennia old, being a Decepticon Pretender. A tie-in media (to the third film shows that she was around in Russia during the Cold War under a similar alias (Alisa Morosov).
The Captain Ersatz for Vulcans in the german comedy Traumschiff Surprise can get up to 400 years old. It's how Mr Spuck is still alive after they jump from the 21st to the 24th century.
Mr Spuck: I am a Vulcanette Vulgaris and they can age to 400 because they belong to the same genus as the Galapagos Tortoise!
Wadatuzin from Ultra Q The Movie: Legend of the Stars, an alien who blends in society in the form of a human woman in her 30s, but had actually existed since the Yayoi period - or 300 AD.
Vampires and Lycans in the Underworld series can be centuries old without looking it. The main character, Selene, is explicitly stated to be roughly 600. None of the others have their ages stated even in ballpark figures, though it's obvious that most, if not all, of the other named vampires and Lycans are at least older than Selene.
Vamps: Goody was born in the early 1800s, but looks no older than her thirties. Stacy turned at 20 in the early '90s and still looks the same two decades later. Other vampires like Cisserus and Tepes do look old, but don't show the centuries they actually are. Others appear to be even older.
We Are the Night: Louise is more than two hundred years old, but appears to be at most forty. Charlotte is over a hundred, but looks around thirty. Nora is thirty seven, but still appears to be about twenty.
In The Witch Files, Jules is really more than 300 years old, and has been returning to Brunswick every 17 years to renew her immortality.
With a Kiss I Die: Juliet was born before 1303 sometime, but looks no older than thirty or so in the present, centuries later. The Greek vampires who turned her are even older, but don't look it either.
Wolverine in the X-Men Film Series, because of his Healing Factor. He was born in 1823, but for most of the series, he still physically appears to be a buff as hell man in his mid-to-late 30s. His powers constantly rejuvenate his cellular integrity rendering him seemingly ageless. He's not by any means immortal, he just ages at an incredibly slow rate, if at all. In Logan, which is set in 2029, his healing powers are beginning to fail, and he looks much more aged as a result.
