|
Basically a comic trope where someone says Your Honor, I Object!, followed by a non-reason, such as "I object on the grounds that it sucks for me" or "I object for it being objectionable!". Can be used as a reply for almost anything, ranging from "normal stuff" such as having to do the dishes to being fed to the sharks.
Not solely a subset of Courtroom Antics; is also commonly used in normal dialogue. Compare I Take Offense to That Last One. Intentionally excessive use of this (see Real Life below) can be a type of Chewbacca Defense. See also Disregard That Statement.
Examples
open/close all folders
Fan Works
- Turnabout Storm has Twilight objecting during the trial on the grounds of "This can't go on!". Of course, considering the target of and the circumstances behind the objection, is anything but Played for Laughs.
Film
- Liar Liar has the most honest version, naturally — and the most honest response to the inevitable overruling:
Fletcher: Your Honour, I object!
Judge: And why is that, Mr. Reede?
Fletcher: Because it's devastating to my case!
Judge: Overruled.
Fletcher: Good call!
- This one goes way back, as shown in the Marx Brothers movie Duck Soup (1933):
Prosecutor: Chicolini, you are charged with high treason, and if found guilty, you will be shot.
Chicolini: I object.
Prosecutor: You object? On what grounds?
Chicolini: I couldn't think of anything else to say.
- In Inherit the Wind, Drummond objects to Brady's title of Colonel, saying that it makes Brady look more important than Drummond and "predudicing the case in favor of the prosecution." Drummond ends up becoming an honorary Colonel on the spot.
- In The Exorcism of Emily Rose, the attorney for the priest accused of criminal neglect of Emily Rose puts on a "demonology" expert to testify that Emily was possessed. The prosecutor objects. When the judge asks for a reason, he says, "How about silliness, your honor?"
- Though he could have phrased it better, that's still a reasonable objection.
- A borderline example in A Few Good Men. The prosecution puts on a doctor to give his opinion as to the cause of Willie Santiago's death. Lt. Cmdr. Galloway objects on the basis of his qualifications. When the judge overrules her, she "strenuously objects" and is again overruled. She ends up just making it look like they're afraid of the doctor's testimony.
Lt. Weinberg: Strenuously object? Is that how it's done now? "Objection." "Overruled." "No, I strenuously object." "Well, if you strenuously object, I guess I'd better reconsider, then."
- Newsies:
Spot Conlon Your Honor, I object!
Judge On what grounds?
Spot Conlon On the grounds of Brooklyn, Your Honor.
- A Civil Action combines this with Ironic Echo Cut. One of the defense attorneys, who is also a law professor, is shown giving a lecture to his students:
Facher: A plaintiff's case depends on momentum. The fewer objections he gets, the better a case will go. ... Relevance - objection. Hearsay - objection. Best evidence - objection. Authenticity - objection. If you should fall asleep at the counsel table, the first thing out of your mouth should be...
- In Idiocracy, Joe's lawyer tries to object to the judge's clear bias, forgets and objects that "he won't be able to pay ME after he gives back all the money he stole from the hospital!"
- Underrated Coen Brothers comedy Intolerable Cruelty does this brilliantly; a witness gushes an endless stream of incredibly incriminating testimony that could easily get the case thrown out. The other side's attorney responds with "OBJECTION! IRRELEVANT!"
- Also hilariously: "Objection! Strangling the witness!"
- Even better (at least in the trailer) the Judge's response: "I'll allow it."
Literature
- Dave Barry Hits Below The Beltway includes a few ridiculous objections in a courtroom scene representing one of the trials over the 2000 Presidential election recount in Florida. This is one of them:
Lawyer: Mr. Glompitt, can you state your name for the court?
Witness: Sure.
Lawyer: Objection, your honor! Hearsay!
Lawyer: How is that hearsay?
Lawyer: I heard him say it!
(Laughter.)
Judge: Sustained.
- The illustrated version of The Wee Free Men includes a transcript of the case "Princess Sandy of Brokenrock vs. Fairy Nettle". When the wicked witch is mentioned, her lawyer jumps up and says "I object!" on the grounds she isn't actually wicked. The judge responds "Oh good. I was hoping someone would."
- In The Rats, The Bats, and the Ugly, there is a oddly phrased but technically valid objection during Chip's second court martial
Prosecuting Attorney: You claim that the accused attempted to persuade Ms. Shaw not to accompany you. When he went, had you not gone and had she, if she had wanted to and were able, and if there were no restraints on her to go, would Ms. Shaw not have been brought forcibly, meaning along with the Korozhet that you state was carried, netted to the tractor?
Defense Attorney: Objection! That question should be taken out and shot, Your Honor. It's a traitor to the English language.
Judge: Indeed. Rephrase it please, Captain Tesco.
- Subtle example in The Krytos Trap. The setting is a military trial, where Tycho Celchu has been charged with the murder of Corran Horn. Commander Ettyk, the prosecutor, is direct-examining a witness (Iella Wessiri) who had partnered with Horn in the past, and who had also participated in the retaking of Coruscant with Horn. The direct examination concluded more or less as follows:
Ettyk: So you had no reason to believe that Corran Horn might be mistaken?
Wessiri: Actually, there was one thing that bothered me.
Ettyk: ...Move to strike as nonresponsive * According to Wikipedia, a "nonresponsive" objection is made because the witness answered a question that was not asked; this was not the case here. , Admiral.
Ackbar: No, Commander, you asked one more question than you should have, and now you must deal with the consequences.
- Ettyk later admitted that she had been reaching, and knew it, making it an example of this trope.
Live Action TV
- On Unhappily Ever After, Ryan once rattled off three or four of these in a quick montage. The most memorable one was this: "I have contempt for this court!"
- Alan Shore on The Practice, and later Boston Legal. A lot. On one occasion, he objected when the court stenographer read out her transcript of him insulting the judge on the basis that her reading "lacked nuance".
- Happens with Denny Crane in Boston Legal season 3 episode 10 "The Nutcracker" after opposing counsel badgers a witness
Denny Crane: Objection! She-She's being... objectionable.
Judge: (quite seriously) Sustained!
(badgering continues)
Denny Crane: Objection!
(some more badgering)
Denny Crane: Your honor!
Judge: Ms. Ford, that's enough.
- An interesting variant in Picket Fences. After Wambaugh pulls a completely legal but morally slimy legal maneuver, Judge Bone orders him jailed for contempt. When he asks why, Bone replies "for being contemptible."
- Played with on The Closer. The lawyer gives two perfectly reasonable objections, then follows it with a silly one for kicks.
" . . . and it ended with a preposition."
- In an episode of Las Vegas an Amoral Attorney tries to net a hefty salary by encouraging his client to pursue a Frivolous Lawsuit against the Montecito. He objects during a meeting with the casino's bosses and main lawyer when he's not even in a courtroom, which is duly pointed out to him.
- In the Red Dwarf episode "Justice", Kryten's defence of Rimmer on 1,169 counts of manslaughter is to present him (accurately) as a sad incompetent. Naturally, Rimmer can't bring himself to let this slide, and repeatedly objects to his own defence. After he's found innocent, he objects again. YouTube clip
Kryten: What are you objecting about now?
Rimmer: I want an apology.
- Star Trek: The Next Generation: In the episode Measure of a Man Picard defends Data in a courtroom process, objecting to a plan that would see him labelled as Starfleet "property" and dismantled. The prosecution, for their case against Data, requests to remove the defendant's hand. Picard is immediately on his feet with his objections before realising that he can't actually object in a legal manner -in typic Picard style, he just doesn't like the idea of them removing his second officer's body parts- and withdraws his objection.
- In the episode "Devil's Due", Picard argues a court case against a woman claiming to be the Ardra, a supernatural being in Velexian myth, with Data arbitrating. Ardra objects when Picard leads a witness, while Data himself objects to Ardra's Courtroom Antics in displaying her "powers" ("The advocate will refrain from making her opponent disappear"). When the Enterprise crew get hold of her technology and Picard starts displaying the same powers, Ardra objects again, but Data decides he's allowed some leeway in the circumstances.
- In an The Addams Family episode, where Gomez is participating in a trial with the family observing, the entire family drives the judge nuts, including Uncle Fester who sounds "I Object!" just so he can participate in the trial, despite the fact that he is in the audience and thus obviously not supposed to interfere.
- Happened on Bones when Brennan's father was on trial for murder.
Caroline: Objection, your honour!
Judge: On what grounds?
Caroline:...I'm thinking...
- Parodied in Extras in the Orlando Bloom episode, which opens as usual with a scene from the movie-within-a-show that's being filmed, which appears to be a courtroom-drama-romantic-comedy-of-manners. Bloom, the prosecuting attorney: "It seems very odd that you would send your wife flowers and not include a card. Whenever I send my wife flowers, I always write a card." Up pops the defense attorney: "Objection! When did you ever send me flowers?" This escalates into an argument, which the judge resolves by declaring, "I order you two to kiss and make up!"
- In one episode of Gilligan's Island, during a mock-courtroom scene, the following exchange occurs:
Mr Howell: I would like to press charges against Mary Anne.
Professor: For what?
Mr Howell: Murder. Her testimony is killing me.
- On The Good Wife, Alicia Florick is up against her former boss Stern. Stern is in the early stages of Alzheimer's Disease, something he's only told Alicia and she can't tell anyone else because he told her at a previous time when he was her client. She gets around this by repeatedly raising frivolous objections during one of Stern's cross-examinations, causing him to become confused and forget what he was going to ask next.
- An accidental one in Law & Order: SVU, Novak objects that the lawyer is leading the witness on cross-examination. This is allowable and expected. The witness already told their story on direct, the opposing counsel is now giving their side. In some cross-examinations the only word the lawyer wants to hear from their witness is "Yes" as they confirm what's being said.
Newspaper Comics
Radio
Video Games
Web Comics
- There was a Ctrl-Alt-Del comic about Metal Gear Ac!d where a guard, after facing a card which allows him to be shot, says "I object on the ground that it sucks for me".
- From Looking for Group:
Richard: Objection!
Judge: On what grounds?
Richard: I wish to stab him [the prosecutor].
- Two different cases in General Protection Fault.
- Case 1, Fooker's trial in the Ubersoft crossover.
Fooker: ...I object!
Judge: I told you before, you can't object to your own testimony.
- Case 2, Man vs. Mold. Upon being told that her plaintiff (Trent) had been convicted for attempted murder before:
Mercedes: I object! ...the plaintiff did not share this information with me!
Judge: I'm afraid that isn't acceptable grounds for an objection. Overruled. Now take your seat, counsel. Another outburst like that and I'll hold you in contempt.
Mercedes: Then I object on the grounds that the plaintiff is a complete idiot.
Judge: As much as I agree, that isn't sufficient grounds either. Overruled.
Western Animation
Real Life
- Los Angeles defense attorney Irving Kanarek, whose most famous client was Charles Manson, was infamous for dragging cases out with long speeches and continuous objections. He once objected when a witness on the stand was asked to identify himself; when asked the grounds, Kanarek stated that since the witness had first heard his name from his parents, asking him to give his name was hearsay.
- In the Manson trial, Kanarek's closing statement (for one defendant out of four) consumed seven court days of time. The jury actually sent a note to the bailiff asking for NoDoz for themselves and sleeping pills for Kanarek.
- Also in the Manson trial, prosecutor Vincent Bugliosi actually got objections sustained to questions for being "ridiculous", "nonsensical", or repeated "ad nauseam". (These objections might more properly be phrased as questions being "prejudicial" or "asked and answered," but are the spirit of them is reasonable.)
- Supposedly a Real Life account:
Ms Olschner: Your honor, I wish to swat Mr. Buck in the head with his client's [deposition transcript].
Judge: You mean read it?
Ms Olschner: No, I wish to swat him in the head with it. The [Rules of Procedure] clearly state that a deposition may be used for "any purpose" in court, and this is the purpose for which I want to use it.
Judge: Well, it does say that. (he pauses)
Judge: There being no objection, you may proceed.
Ms Olschner: Thank you your honor. (she swats Mr. Buck in the head with a copy of deposition.)
Mr. Buck: But Judge...
Judge: Next witness.
Mr. Buck: We object!
Judge: Sustained. Next witness.
- Common in Mock Trial competitions, where people will often object simply to break the flow of someone's questioning as mentioned in A Civil Action above. Or where they're sure that there is an objection to be made, but can't quite remember which one it is until too late.
- A witness examination competition, presided by an actual judge...
Attorney: I Object!
Judge: On what grounds?
Attorney: It's... it's... the question's ***KING RETARDED.
Judge: ... you know what, I'll sustain that. (Turns to opposing counsel.) It's otherwise known as a "Prejudicial" question. * Basically, a question where the answer is so obvious the question is irrelevant, e.g. "Is the sky blue?" "Is the Pope Catholic?"
Opposing counsel: uhhhh... OK?
|
|
