While characters with normal lifespans are usually depicted as being attracted to one gender exclusively, immortal characters often turn out to be much less picky about gender. This could be attributed to the fact that we can't know for sure how human sexuality acts over a lifespan of centuries, or a strong belief in the Kinsey Scale from the author. Mostly, this is rationalized with a belief that someone who has lived long enough can look outside the box of sexual norms, or that in that amount of time someone of an unexpected gender is bound to attract the character. Or maybe they've just been around for so long that they're running out of new things to try.
This trope does have some Unfortunate Implications however, in that it ignores the very real pattern of being attracted to one gender that is displayed by gay and straight people alike throughout their lives. Many an author also lumps it together withImmortality Immorality, feeding into the notion that bisexuality/omnisexuality isn't a legitimate orientation as much as it is promiscuity.
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
Depending on how one interprets the nature of the series, France, as well as many other cast members from Axis Powers Hetalia.
Possibly explains why all the ElfQuest elves (some immortal, some just very long-lived) are bisexual.
Chris Claremont originally intended to write Wolverine as bisexual, and although he may or may not be technically immortal, his Healing Factor definitely grants extended longevity and makes him hard to kill. Of course, at the time, fans of comic books were probably less likely to be able to grasp the idea of "a manly dude that swings both ways" and so that angle was dropped. We know better now, though.
This was semi-canonized in the Alternate Universe series X-Treme X-Men, where Wolverine, here known by his birth name of James Howlett, is bisexual and in a relationship with Hercules, which some fans interpreted as a subtle nod to Claremont's original intention.
As Claremont eventually revealed, Mystique is over a hundred years old; she has had relationships with several men, but her most enduring one was that with Irene Adler aka Destiny. Mystique is also bisexual in another way, having spent years in male shape(s). This was even how the character Nightcrawler was originally supposed to be born (with Mystique impregnating Destiny while in her male form). Marvel ultimately named the idea too controversial, so Kurt is Azreael and Mystique's son instead.
Hob Gadling from The Sandman, though it's mentioned only in passing in the final issue.
Averted at least twice in The Dresden Files: In Blood Rites it's revealed that Lord Raith, the King of the White Court Vampires (who are essentially incubi and succubi and feed on lust rather than blood) keeps House Raith in order by sexually dominating his offspring in order to enforce psychic subservience. However, as Lord Raith is one of the few White Court vampires who isn't bisexual, he instead attempts to kill his male offspring in non-direct ways (since the White Court as a whole frowns on a lack of subtly in one's evil plots).
Although, given the character is based on Woolf's own bisexual lover Vita Sackville-West, it's hinted in the book as explicitly as it can be for 1930 that the character is bisexual
For the probity of breeches she exchanged the seductiveness of petticoats and enjoyed the love of both sexes equally
In The Witcher books, one of the witches mentions that when you live that long you will try everything eventually.
One of the Light Others from Night Watch named Ignat is a master of seduction, and doesn't care about the gender of his targets. He's not quite immortal, but he and all other Others can maintain youth for up to centuries, and it's implied that his bisexuality is at least in part because he's bored. He's possibly the only bisexual Other shown, but a lot of them tend toward being The Hedonist.
He also doesn't mind having a threesome with two sorceresses, one of whom has a boyfriend in the next room.
It's pretty much stated that the Others don't abide by human rules of courtship and fidelity. Just before discovering Svetlana in Ignat's arms, Anton finds two Others sleeping after a night of passion, both of whom have human spouses. He notes that two field operatives sleeping together is no different from a female Combat Medic providing "comfort" to a soldier in a trench. His treatment of Svetlana sleeping with Ignat is likewise detached... which infuriates Svetlana to no end.
The Vampires — yes, all of them — in The Vampire Chronicles. Partial aversion though in that Rice's vampires are not capable of regular sex. Also, Lestat himself was already bisexual when he was still human, as were at least some of the other vampires.
Henry Fitzroy from the Blood Books, although he was apparently bisexual during his human lifetime anyway. Vaguely implied with another, female vampire that Vicki encounters in a short story.
Some people feel this way about Alice in Twilight. Though it's canonically stated that she's in love with Jasper, fans seem to think that's she also has feelings for Bella.
Young adult vampire novelist Amelia Atwater-Rhodeshas stated that many of the vampires in her canon are bisexual, having grown tired over the centuries of being romantically involved with a single gender.
The premise of Incarnate by Jodi Meadows sort of leans on this. Everyone is reincarnated into different bodies over and over, and there's no guarantee that you'll be the same gender every time. So sexuality isn't really an issue.
Trill in Star Trek, especially Dax in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. A Trill symbiont is passed down from host to host in either a male or female body, but the trill symbiosis commission forbids relations with a former lover. One episode Dax ignores this and kisses a woman who the symbiants in each of them were once married together, but all her other relations on the show were straight.
Possibly a forced trope. The Trill are humanoid and not immortal; the symbiont that is transplanted from body to body is virtually immortal and seems to be genderless. Once combined, the resulting personality is a combination of both; and the symbiont use the Trill to accrue life experiences that it shares with the host. It is likely that Trill candidates are chosen for some bisexuality since they will have the knowledge of both having been and loved both genders. And the symbiont would see any relationship as new experiences or knowledge.
Jack Harkness from Doctor Who and Torchwood — though he was omnisexual long before he became immortal.
Jack: You people and your quaint little categories.
It's stated that the reason for his omnisexuality is because he was born in the 51st century, where humans have spread throughout the galaxy, met other races, and "danced". While Jack has lived more in the 20th century than in the 51st, he still retains those views. This doesn't explain the other Torchwood employees, though, who are all quite mortal.
The Doctor himself, although he is also an alien. The fact that Time Lords apparently don't always stay the same sex when they regenerate probably helps broaden their standards.
True Blood: Word of God says that almost EVERY vampire out there is bisexual, gender being only a footnote to them. This is in stark contrast to the book series True Blood is based on, The Sookie Stackhouse Mysteries, where bisexuality is rare, outside of the occasional off-handed "I was bored" comments.
Spike once said of Angel in Angel: "Angel and I were never intimate. Well, except that one time..."
Pretty much every vampire in Buffy the Vampire Slayer is a Depraved Bisexual, as evidenced by their tendencies to "play" and tease their victims before killing and draining them in a sometimes highly sexualised manner. Vampires have no gender preferences when it comes to meals, and there are strong implications that they like "dancing" with their meals before having them (as displayed by Spike, Drusilla, Darla and vampire!Willow). A common way of luring their meals to their deaths is by seducing them first, regardless of their sex. A lot of vampires are pretty much portrayed as Anything That Moves.
Word of God is that Dorian Gray has this attitude in Penny Dreadful ... although it's probably the least of the ways his sexuality crosses lines.
The Exalted — if not everyone in Creation — are typically portrayed as this. The Dragon-Blooded often take homosexual lovers outside of marriage to avoid the risk of siring bastards, the Lunars have easy access to Gender Bender powers and massive fecundity, the Solars are god-kings who traverse Creation like a man walking down the block and occasionally go into states of utter debauchery, and the Sidereals live for millennia and have fate powers that allow them to assume any role they want.
In some Dungeons & Dragons supplements—those few that mention sex—elves are generally portrayed as being much more likely to be bisexual than humans and other "brief" races.
Warhammer 40,000 mostly averts this trope, as the long-lived Space Marines are asexual (although originally male). However, the Chaos God(dess) Slaanesh very much embodies this trope, being immortal and also the Chaos Deity of Sex and Perversion.
The Asari from Mass Effect are a One-Gender Race (all female, in appearance, anyway) and can have children with any gender or species. They can live to be almost 1000. They do sometimes mate with their own species, but those who do are frowned upon by creating more pureblood asari, which led to the Ardat-Yakshi.
The Drow (and presumably other Fae) of Drowtales are The Ageless that live in an Everyone Is Bi society, with purely heterosexual and homosexual people existing as minorities.
Applies to at least the highblooded trolls of Homestuck. It's normal for all trolls to be bisexual; monosexuality does exist, but it's not common or considered to be a big deal (it's kind of similar to how we'd view someone who's only attracted to redheads: not typical, but not remarkable enough to have a word for it or much of a stigma attached to it). However, the trope doesn't apply to all trolls because the lowest castes have shorter natural lifespans than humans, and somewhat higher up the hierarchy are trolls with humanlike lifespans, and so forth.