Everyone Is a Suspect
"They'll give statements and be eliminated, the rest of the Badge of Honor crew will be alibied, and then we'll only have the rest of Hollywood to deal with."One of the key questions in detective stories is: who has a motive? Usually that only serves to narrow things down, as there are two or three people with a plausible motive, and even then a whole other person can turn out to be the actual killer. Sometimes the opposite happens: every single person in the general vicinity has a reason to want the victim dead. Not only was the victim a horrible human being whom everybody hated on general principle, but the victim also had specifically wronged all the other characters. The killer could have been anyone. Sometimes everyone's a suspect because Everybody Did It. Long story short, it's better to have lots and lots of suspects, because that is part of what makes it a mystery.
— D.A. Ellis Loew, regarding the murder of "crusading reporter" (read: scandal monger) Sid Hugens in L.A. Confidential.
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- Oddly enough, since victims in Umineko no Naku Koro ni tend to be... just about everyone, just about everyone also winds up being a suspect. This helps to contribute to the drama, since Battler is trying to prove that the murders weren't committed supernaturally but doesn't want to suspect his family and friends.
- Detective Conan has a few of these. Sometimes there is only one real suspect, who the audience knows is guilty because there is no one else (and Conan figures it out pretty quick too), and the question is how they did it. Then there are some episodes where you have a few suspects. Then some episodes that really define this trope.
- In the classic Spider-Man arc, The Death of Jean DeWolff, Detective Stan Carter makes a statement to Spider-man that anyone in New York was a suspect in Jean DeWolff's death. Carter even points out that he could be a suspect which is ironic since he ends up being the Sin-eater, the man who killed DeWolff.
- This was the premise of the film Drowning Mona.
- Both parodied and subverted in the movie Murder by Death. The "suspects" are all of the guests and the house staff; with the guests consisting of parodies of many the most well-known literary and movie detectives — Sam Spade, Charlie Chan, Hercule Poirot, Miss Marple, and Nick and Nora Charles — all of whom had reasons to kill the host, which come up during the course of the film. The host is killed shortly after the guests arrive; after announcing that he will be killed, and offering scathing critiques of the various tropes and devices used typically used by said detectives, via their parody Captain Ersatzs. Subverted in that the host is not actually dead, but faked his death to demonstrate the inferiority of the methods used by his guests, and his ability to outsmart them all. Or did he?
- Scream (1996). It even has a character yelling the phrase "everybody is a suspect!".
- Parodied endlessly in the Scream spoof Shriek if You Know What I Did Last Friday the Thirteenth:
- All five major characters admit that they have good reasons why they would want to kill at least one of the other four, but none of them are the killer, who is hiding out right under the table they’re convening at.
- Also, for no apparent reason both Officer Doughy and news reporter Hagatha are wearing the exact same boots as the killer, while the principal has an exact match of the killer's entire outfit just lying around.
- Boner casually mentions that he could kill all his friends if he wanted to, eliciting concerned or shocked looks on their faces. Then in a spontaneously upbeat tone he says that of course he wouldn't.
- Dawson is accused of having killed his entire family, and the others dumped him in the sea while he was wearing a deer costume, mistaking him for a real animal.
- The Thing (1982) creates its notorious sense of paranoia from this, though in this case it isn't so much "anyone could have committed the murder" as "any one of twelve men could in fact be a hostile shape-shifting alien capable of creating a perfect copy of people that it kills". Naturally, a good chunk of the plot is simply driven by the guys trying to figure out who to trust.
- In A Shot In The Dark, Clouseau has assembled all the people in the mansion, and tells his tale in preparation for having the killer confess by trying to escape the room. When the lights go off, they ALL try to escape. Every single one of them was responsible for one of the murders in the movie (or prior to it), except for one who was a blackmailer. And the killer who was repeatedly trying to murder Clouseau seemingly to get him off their trail...was actually his own boss, and they were actually trying to kill him just because they couldn't stand him and nothing to do with his investigations, except that they were so bumbling and inept that they drove his boss insane.
- Basically the premise of By Whose Hand? (1932), which opens with a man on a train being stabbed by an unseen figure and then rolls back four hours to show several different passengers all with different potential motives.
- Any of the men on the pilgrimage could have murdered the children in The Mistress of the Art of Death.
- Agatha Christie's Hercule Poirot novel Death on the Nile put the murder victim on a boat with seemingly everyone who hated her. It came so that the sufficiently Genre Savvy reader could figure out who did it, as there were only two characters who were cleared of the murder due to physical impossibility; naturally, they were our killers. And do we need to mention Murder on the Orient Express?
- An interesting subversion is in the Miss Marple story A Pocket Full of Rye, where the actual murderer deliberately plots out the murder to tie in to the "Sing a Song of Sixpence" rhyme, which would incriminate (by chain of association) a brother and sister pair who had been told every day by their mother to wreak revenge on the murder victim who had wronged them in days of yore. Miss Marple concludes, correctly, that the siblings had much better sense than to waste their lives with revenge, but deduces that the sister did get back at the murder victim by marrying his son.
- We can't forget The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Readers of today can't imagine what a shock it was in 1926 to have the culprit of a detective novel turn out to be the first-person narrator. The killer lampshades this trope in the end by admitting even they were confused by how much everyone else looked like they might have done it, and why their relatively straighforward crime was befuddled by contradictory evidence that seemed to show it could not have happened the way it really did- it turned out most of the suspects were lying or planting fake clues to hide their own secrets and crimes, which made them more suspicious.
- Another good example is Cards On The Table whose plot is familiar to anyone who has seen the Clue film. A nasty guy invites a bunch of people to a party on the premise that all of them are scoundrels (in this case, specifically that they've all committed murder and gotten away with it) and pretty much blackmails them. Naturally, the host bites it, and there is a note at the beginning of the novel to the effect that all of them would be capable of murder if pressed. It is subtley implied that the eccentrice host is in fact Satan himself.
- And who can forget the similar premise of And Then There Were None, in which ten people are invited to an island because they've all committed murder in such a way that they could not be blamed for it - deliberate neglect, emotional abuse driving a victim to suicide, sentencing an innocent man to death, etc. - and then killing them all off in the manner of the nursery rhyme?
- In the novel Never Trust a Dead Man by Vivian Vande Velde, Farold - the murder victim - is terribly depressed to realize just how many of the people he knew have plausible reasons for wanting him dead.
- In one of G. K. Chesterton's mysteries, various people try to consult the blackmailer during the day and come back claiming that he refused to stop fishing. In actuality, he had been murdered. Each one is cleared when it is revealed that they too had been his victims and so had been afraid that they would be accused.
- This happens frequently in Michael Dahl's Finnegan Zwake books, particularly The Ruby Raven.
- Marooned In Realtime uses this extensively. First, Yelen brings up dossiers of the entire human race sorted by means and motive (though at least one character insists on blaming hypothetical aliens). Later, Brierson deliberately makes himself a target to see which of the well-armed people attack him. Except for his partner, they all do.
- In Boris Akunin's Seagull, not only Everyone Is a Suspect, but there's also an alternate ending for each suspect to be the culprit. Including the detective himself.
- In Father, Forgive Them, numerous people were in the room when Dr. Curtland died, and admit to how much they would have liked to kill him, and that they had a means of doing so at the time. Predictably, the real murderer is none of them.
- In both the book and TV series of Pretty Little Liars, most of the supporting characters are suspects at some point in Ali De Laurentis' murder.
- John W. Campbell's "Who Goes There?" is the basis for The Thing (mentioned in the Film section). As noted, the problem is that you can't tell who ... or what ... might have been co-opted by the shapeshifting alien. One of the characters reasons that there must be several humans left, since if the real humans were already hopelessly outnumbered by fakes it wouldn't be bothering to hide still ... the trick is finding out which ones they are.
- In Barrayar, Simon Illyan has a short list and a long list of suspects in an attempted assassination of Aral Vorkosigan, and "Everyone's on my long list."
- A recent episode of The Glades had a murder victim who was a divorce attorney. The main character said it best: Half the state of Florida were suspects.
- In episodes of Murder, She Wrote, you can usually guess who will be the first character to die: he or she will be the one systematically making every other cast member want him dead.
- In every episode of the Clue TV series, it was explicitly set up so every character would have a reason to want the victim of the week dead.
- Get Smart has an awesome recurring character who is a detective so thorough he considered himself a suspect until he finds evidence clearing his name.
- Castle - "Everyone looks guilty to me, it's a job requirement."
- Parodied; Beckett's words are echoed by Castle, in a much more dramatic fashion than Beckett's matter-of-fact statement, later in the episode. His daughter Alexis then points out that he just a minute before asserted that someone couldn't possibly have been a suspect. Castle, slightly peevishly, tells her to just let him have his moment.
- The writers of this show love this trope. Sometimes it's an Asshole Victim, but sometimes it's just a perfectly normal person with very bad judgment in personal relationships. In one particular episode, it turned out that even though the victim was a more or less likeable person, her fiance, classmate, employer and client all had motives to kill her. The killer turned out to be her roommate.
- In the second Nikki Heat tie-in novel, when asked about who might have a motive to kill the victim (A rather vicious critic), the Castle expy suggests getting a copy of the Manhattan phone book and starting with A.
- In the Law & Order episode "Vendetta", Detectives Briscoe and Green investigate the murder of the in-story equivalent of Steve Bartman. Every fan of the relevant baseball team is a suspect.
- Another time they had a murder victim who was involved in construction. Van Buren snarks, "Construction. You've got fifty suspects before you do your first interview," alluding to the mob's involvement in that business.
- In the Fight Club episode of Vampire Prosecutor, everyone in the club is suspected of killing the victim as they had battled him one after another, piling on the life-threatening injuries.
- This is the theme of episode four in The Conditions of Great Detectives (and is parodied) as nobody in the house had a proper alibi and everybody reveals they had a perfect motive for killing him at rapid speed. Naturally the one person who didn't want him dead was mentally unwell so easily could have as well. Fujii points out that perhaps Everybody Did It but Tenkaichi dismisses it because it's boring. In the end, nobody did it. He killed himself.
- Fujii takes the opinion of everybody being a suspect in every episode and gets angry when Banzo and Tenkaichi dismiss certain characters as possibilities due to being extremely Genre Savvy. She got very angry when they both dismissed three female characters to the point of never even asking them their names and said they were obvious and boring red herrings.
- This was par for the course in Ellery Queen. Just about everyone who knew the victim would have a reason for wanting them dead.
- Midsomer Murders: not only is everyone a suspect due to everyone in Midsomer being a petty, vicious little scumbag with about three skeletons per closet, by the end of the episode half of them will be dead (not always for reasons pertaining to the original murder).
- The basis of soaps "Whodunit?" murder mysteries, as the victim is usually an Asshole Victim who has managed to piss off literally everyone in the cast before being killed.
- M*A*S*H: Hawkeye is suspected of theft after stolen items turn up in his foot locker. He calls a midnight order in the mess tent of pertinent personell and (dressed in detective garb) begins weeding out suspects. He says the thief gave himself away with the last round of thefts as Hawkeye had treated the items with a solution that turns fingernails blue. Everybody looks at their fingernails in puzzlement—everybody except the Swamp houseboy, who hides his hands. Hawkeye was bluffing to allow the thief to give himself away.
- The Mousetrap with rather predictable outcome.
- Several characters in The Bat are suspected at one time or another of killing Dick Fleming.
- In Margin for Error, even before Consul Karl Baumer is killed, Denny is keeping a running count of how many of the people in his office want him dead. Denny, Sophie, Max, Otto and Dr. Jennings all have personal motives for his murder; though Moe wasn't in the room at the time, he considers being Jewish enough for some people to suspect him for killing the Consul.
- In Dangan Ronpa, almost every case has every character as a suspect. Since all of the characters are trapped inside the school and are required to murder another student to graduate, it is inevitable that everyone would have a motive, even if they did not want the victim to be dead.
- When Team Fortress 2 fans finally meet the Spy, he's introduced by way of a rather tense realization: Since nobody killed a Red Spy on the way in, he could be in this very room. The presence of a Wrong Genre Savvy Soldier makes the situation even more hazardous than it is already.
- When you start Town of Salem everyone is pleasant to one another... But after the first night and the bodies start piling, the accusations start flying.
- Almost every character introduced in Criminal Case have a potential to become suspects — including members of the Police force. In fact, three of the Player's teammates have wound up on the suspect list, and one of them actually was guilty of the crime.
- The Accuser: When a lawyer is found dead, one of the cops assigned to the case hinted that the victim's former legal partner might have something to do with that. When another one mentioned mentioned said partner's handicap (being wheelchair bound) as a reason to rule him out as a suspect, the cop who accused the victim's partner invoked the trope.
- The "Who Shot Mr. Burns?" two-parter of The Simpsons developed motives for Homer, Bart, Smithers, Grampa, Moe, Barney, Skinner, Groundskeeper Willie — basically, everybody in Springfield (With a few exceptionsnote ) as well as popular drummer Tito Puente. Marge even says the trope name at the end of part one. It then turned out that the shooting was an accident.
- Burns did try to steal Maggie's candy...
- The hour-long Family Guy episode "And Then There Were Fewer", everyone is a suspect in the murder of James Woods because of all the dirty things he did to them. The killer turned out to be Diane Simmons.
- On Hanna-Barbera's Clue Club, Larry has Sheriff Bagley round up everyone involved in the episode's crime and peg out each's possible motive for committing it before revealing the actual criminal.
- The feudal lord of the small Spanish town of Fuenteovejuna was murdered in 1475. Since this happened during a Portuguese invasion of the region and the town was of strategic importance the Santa Hermandad put a lot of effort into the investigation of the murder, down to torturing several of the main suspects... yet they couldn't break any, and the only answers they got were pretty much that the guy was an ass, that everybody hated him and that the killer had been the whole Fuenteovejuna. The Catholic Monarchs accepted this explanation and pardoned the town. A fictionalized version of the incident is told in the 17th century play Fuenteovejuna by Lope de Vega.