Manga/Fairy Tail

Noticed there wasn't a thread and figured a double-chapter release was a good time to start one:

http://mangastream.com/read/naruto/168-35/1

So is this regular Fairy Tail suffering a Freaky Thursday from getting sucked into Edoras, or is Edoras a full-blown Bizarro Universe? If it's the later, I'm guessing they don't have counterparts to the Dragon Slayers.
Speaking of Dragon Slayers, I was left wondering what was going on with Gajeel's sudden disappearance (assuming he got left under the dust pile)... until I also noticed Mystogan suddenly disappearing. Mystogan can probably take himself and Gajeel to Edoras and show up half way through the arc.

Gajeel....that's Gerard, right?

I draw this comic-like thing sometimes.

@New Cope: Are you genuinely confused by my choice of romanization (I'm talking about the iron Dragon Slayer, also spelled Gazille), or are you just suggesting Gerard's reappearance is more likely?

Mistgun and Gazille (I stubbornly refuse to use the official spelling for them) may be simply buried like Natsu was, but since they were in different part of town, Wendy didn't find them like she did Natsu. Also, it's possible that it was the connected to the cats that saved Wendy and Natsu, and Mistgun and Gazille got sucked in as well. And Given Mistgun, it seems likely that Edoras is a bizarro universe

@Gilphon: What do you mean "Given Mistgun"? He wasn't in Edoras.

I mean that Mistgun's words last chapter seemed to imply he was from an alternate universe, so it seems likely that he's Gerald's Edoras counterpart

Ahhh, right. All the different names makes this manga hard to follow ar times.

I draw this comic-like thing sometimes.

@Gilphon: Oh... I wonder how he's the opposite of Gerard. Really, Gerard's personality isn't that strongly oriented in on direction for which there is an "opposite" of.

My personal theory is that Edoras!Erza is Brainwashed and Crazy, and possibly responsible for the whole 'Anima' thing. That would be a pretty complete way of reversing their interactions.

New Chapter!

http://mangastream.com/read/fairy_tail/170-42/1

I Knew It!. Edoras!Erza is evil. And it seems not everyone is opposite in Edoras.

I think Edoras Mirajane is just opposite in some way that hasn't been demonstrated yet. Also, I wonder what happened to Edoras Natsu and Makarov. And if they have their own version of Wendy, they probably have a Gajeel.

Edoras!Mirajane is already opposite. It's just since Lisana never died, her personality never changed. And it's not just Natsu and Makarov who're missing. I want to see Edoras!Gildartz!

edited 30th Jan '10 9:07:21 AM by Gilphon

New Chapter

Well it looks like we won't be seeing the rest of Edoras Fairy Tail, as it seems they're not off somewhere else, they're dead.

That's a shame, that is. Well, I'm still hoping Edoras!Gildartz gets a Big Damn Heroes moment later.

In other news, if Natsu and Wendy can't use their magic in Edoras, they're kind of screwed, since Lucy seems to be the only FT member willing to help, and all other mages are controlled by The Empire. They should see if they can't find Mistgun, he can probably help.

edited 9th Feb '10 10:05:18 AM by Gilphon

Well, Natsu can probably hold his own without magic until they find a way to... how the hell do you distribute magic?

edited 10th Feb '10 7:10:14 PM by thatother1dude

New chapter is up, although you can tell the scanlator was rushing.

Well I guess that answers my question: magic can only be contained in objects in Edoras and it acts like a universal fuel, so they just took all of them for themselves (thus explaining why Mystogan had the large number of staffs on his person)
And Lucy's back. Yeah!

I'm guessing that Lucy's still able to use her magic because of two factors:

• she was already relying on magic items to use it.
• The stellar spirits draws their power from an entirely separate world.

I'm really wondering where Mistgun's got to now, though. So... he saved Lucy, got her in Edoras, and then just vanished? Hmm... maybe he's working to save all the FT members, one by one, and decided to start with Lucy because she'd be able to use magic?

Those were my first thoughts as to why she could use magic, but given that no one else is saying that in-series I'm guessing it could be something else we have not been told yet.

I thought Lucy said she saved herself by hiding inside that grandfather clock stellar spirit?

Oh, right. Damn my memory's bad today. Well, Mistgun still got her into Edoras, so it's still kind of strange that he's MIA.

New chapter!
Hell yeah EdoNatsu! Wondering what his personality is like? Probably calm and sort of laid back.
10:1 that the "Exceed" Lucy read about turns out to be important to a next arc, if not this one.

New chapter!... and no has posted since I posted the last one.

Chapter 174

OK, who wants to beat that Edo-Natsu will get around his fear while out of his car by pulling a Big Damn Heroes by ramming someone with his car?

Once again new chapters. Once again, no one else is responding this time.

So given that Happy has no memories like Charle does, is it possible that he's not from Edoras?

Looks like you were right about Exceed being important. And personally, I think Happy doesn't have any memories of Edoras because he was born was born (or hatched, I guess) in Earthland, while Charlie left Edoras at some time after birth.

edited 9th Mar '10 8:16:48 AM by Gilphon

So, is Charle actually betraying them or is this a case of Amnesiac Dissonance, and her memories are giving her info that works out badly for the Earthland types?

I have a message from another time...

Why does everyone keep talking as though Lucy is normally useless? She's previously been shown to be much more powerful than the average Fairy Tail member. Then again, maybe that's the point; Natsu is just being an idiot.

Currently taking a break from the site. See my user page for more information.