Needs Help: Ladies And Germs

Ladies and gentledudes and others of note, we've gathered here because this suggestion◊ did not reach consensus in the crowner. Any ideas?

EDIT: The topic here is for the trope Ladies and Germs but I forgot to add in the page title, my bad. Should I make a new thread or should this thread go as is?

Edited by anza_sb on Jan 2nd 2021 at 5:33:07 PM

Seems fine to me.

Suggestion seems fine to me. Normally I'd hold off on this, but we have a backlog the size of North Dakota, so I think it's fine to start talking about it now.

I wish there was a way we could focus more on the text, but it works.

I didn’t have a problem with the OP.

Looking at the examples, I slightly prefer the last panel of this [1] (from Bruno the Bandit).

That’s okay, but at the same time I’d prefer to not have to use another webcomic image, especially one that’s colorless and grainy.

I prefer 6 to OP.

I don't really like either suggestion, but I'd go with OP if I had to choose. 6 itself is alright, but the quality is a grainy mess.

I prefer 6. Four panels seemed a little overkill for what OP was trying to get across.

since one of the other threads mentioned Garfield, i'm reminded of something...

first panel of this?

EDIT: there's actually a ton of Garfield strips that open with "ladies and germs" it turns out, i just googled "ladies and germs garfield" and got like 6 strips.

Edited by anza_sb on Jan 5th 2021 at 11:07:35 PM

That just shows the trope title, but lacks the context that would tell what it's really about. An image that's just a talking head repeating the title is not really good.

6 is funnier and probably easier to read at wiki size, but the graininess is a bit hard on the eyes as well. I don't mind OP being a bit long because the length of the introduction is a common gag with the trope.

He’s introducing himself on a stage to a crowd. There’s even a spotlight. How’s it talking heads?

I tried improving the quality of 6.

I like that.

Not a fan. The Mistaken for Racist part takes up half of the content while being extraneous to the trope at hand.

i just remembered something.

how about this?◊ from this Overly Sarcastic episode.

bump. no takers?

It's nice but the colors hurt my eyes. I'll go with the OP.

Edited by cute_heart on Jan 10th 2021 at 10:07:08 PM

Crowner?

sure, i guess.

Hooked, thanks.

out of curiosity's sake, here's 18 at wiki size.

This one's already at super-consensus level. It's in and tagged; caption?