- Funny Moments: A surprising amount, but Jeff's reaction to Smile Dog is a standout.
- Ho Yay: A possible example; Masky and Hoodie, favorites of Yaoi Fangirls, happen to share a room. Make of that what you will.
- Nightmare Fuel: It's a Creepypasta Fanime. It's to be expected.
- Vocal Dissonance: Slenderman's voice is unexpectedly high pitched.
YMMV / Proxy