Tropes present in this episode:
- Christmas Episode: The events of the episode took place on Christmas Day.
- Freudian Slip: Gnome, the Grinch here, makes one when trying to defend herself.Grinch: I did all my murders completely independently of him! I mean... uh... I'm innocent!
- Hollywood Tone-Deaf: Player tells Veteran not to sing 'Jingle Bells', saying that he's heard Veteran sing before. Later, Veteran sings off-key in the credits.
- Narrator All Along: Bro, who is narrating, turns out to be Freezy, the second Impostor.
- Nice Job Breaking It, Hero: Player leaves the game as a Christmas gift to make it easier for Captain (who he believes is the Impostor) to win. Unfortunately, Captain is not the Impostor.
- Mistaken Identity: Veteran, who is wearing an angel halo, is mistaken for Angel. Twice.
- The Bus Came Back: Subverted with Angel. It turns out to be Veteran with an angel halo.
- Yet Another Christmas Carol: The Gentleman is visited by the Ghost of Christmas Past (Mother), the Ghost of Christmas Present (Mr. Egg) and The Ghost of Christmas Future (Poopyfarts).
