Diaper (normal voice): "—and then he silently stands there for like, twenty minutes."
Even Judge gets in on it at times, like when they go to meet Gunnbjorn Arnason.
Judge: "Hello, Chris Yaven! I am from France! Would you like to try my new invention, de french fry?"
"Watch this move! This is a move you've never seen before!" Cue Diaper completely missing both of the ships he was firing at.
Diaper manages to overcome that naval battle with a sliver of ship health left. He manages to arrive at his destination...and then promptly crashes into another ship and sinks. Without having saved after the battle.
During the quest that they're given throwing knives, Diaper tries to throw them rapid-fire, which end up hitting Raven's pirate Red Shirts in the head and instantly killing them.
Another gem from the same episode, when Diaper is trying to remember the cryptic combination of buttons to reload his gun:
Judge: "It's not in the menu, you dingbat! Nothing's in the menu!"
Diaper constantly screwing up, to the point where Judge asks him if he can even read properly.
One of the challenges presented is a "bowling" puzzle. After a long rant about how he's no less of a man if he misses, Anthony gives it a shot...and Judge promptly places a block in the way right in time.
"You Should All Pay Diaper Chri The Respect He Deserves". Yes, Diaper Chris misspelled his own name.