Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
** All the comparisons made between this film and ''Film/DrStrangelove'' becomes this when Armando Iannucci was announced to be adapting ''Dr. Strangelove'' on stage in 2024.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
** After Khrushchev gives Malenkov the charge sheet with the detailed lists of all Beria's sexual assault victims, the latter turns and walks away. Is Malenkov doing this out of disgust at Beria's rapes? Out of disgust at the trial? Or just out of cowardice?
Changed line(s) 12 (click to see context) from:
* AwesomeEgo: Zhukov exudes a deserved arrogance on account of being the supreme leader for the victorious Red Army during World War 2, and knows exactly how far he can push his political invulnerability in social circles when being a general troll and gadfly. His EstablishingCharacterMoment is him throwing open a trenchcoat to reveal a ChestOfMedals, demanding a drink and then holding his ground against Beria. In his very ''next'' scene he punches Vasily, Stalin's son, in the gut and kicks him while he's down, telling him to ''"Fucking'' behave!" and freely admitting what he did to Svetlana, who can't do a thing in response.
to:
* AwesomeEgo: Zhukov exudes a deserved arrogance on account of being the supreme leader for the victorious Red Army during World War 2, II, and knows exactly how far he can push his political invulnerability in social circles when being a general troll {{troll}} and gadfly.[[TheGadfly gadfly]]. His EstablishingCharacterMoment is him throwing open a trenchcoat to reveal a ChestOfMedals, demanding a drink and then holding his ground against Beria. In his very ''next'' scene he punches Vasily, Stalin's son, in the gut and kicks him while he's down, telling him to ''"Fucking'' behave!" and freely admitting what he did to Svetlana, who can't do a thing in response.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 12 (click to see context) from:
* AwesomeEgo: Zhukov exudes a deserved arrogance on account of being the supreme leader for the victorious Red Army during World War 2, and knows exactly how far he can push his political invulnerability in social circles when being a general troll and gadfly. His EstablishingCharacterMoment is him throwing open a trenchcoat to reveal a ChestOfMedals and demanding a drink.
to:
* AwesomeEgo: Zhukov exudes a deserved arrogance on account of being the supreme leader for the victorious Red Army during World War 2, and knows exactly how far he can push his political invulnerability in social circles when being a general troll and gadfly. His EstablishingCharacterMoment is him throwing open a trenchcoat to reveal a ChestOfMedals and ChestOfMedals, demanding a drink.drink and then holding his ground against Beria. In his very ''next'' scene he punches Vasily, Stalin's son, in the gut and kicks him while he's down, telling him to ''"Fucking'' behave!" and freely admitting what he did to Svetlana, who can't do a thing in response.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AwesomeEgo: Zhukov exudes a deserved arrogance on account of being the supreme leader for the victorious Red Army during World War 2, and knows exactly how far he can push his political invulnerability in social circles when being a general troll and gadfly. His EstablishingCharacterMoment is him throwing open a trenchcoat to reveal a ChestOfMedals and demanding a drink.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
** Are Beria's executioners [[EvenEvilHasStandards genuinely horrified]] by his [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil sex crimes]] and brutality? Or are they power-hungry cretins who just want to save their hides while being not much better than Beria? Or is it a mix of both?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed line(s) 7 (click to see context) from:
* AluminiumChristmasTrees: There was a real Dr. Lidiya Timaschuk who was a KGB informant, acted as the main witness of the Doctor's Plot, and was arrested when the case was abandoned. Everything else is presumably fictional.
to:
* AluminiumChristmasTrees: AluminiumChristmasTrees:
** There was a real Dr. Lidiya Timaschuk who was a KGB informant, acted as the main witness of the Doctor's Plot, and was arrested when the case was abandoned. Everything else is presumablyfictional.fictional.
** Besides Jason Isaacs' torso not being wide enough to comfortably accommodate all of the real-life Zhukov's decorations, the sheer ''number'' of them would have caused uninitiated viewers to see Zhukov more as a GeneralFailure with an unscrupulously-earned ChestOfMedals than as the FourStarBadass he really is.
** There was a real Dr. Lidiya Timaschuk who was a KGB informant, acted as the main witness of the Doctor's Plot, and was arrested when the case was abandoned. Everything else is presumably
** Besides Jason Isaacs' torso not being wide enough to comfortably accommodate all of the real-life Zhukov's decorations, the sheer ''number'' of them would have caused uninitiated viewers to see Zhukov more as a GeneralFailure with an unscrupulously-earned ChestOfMedals than as the FourStarBadass he really is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"What an Idiot!" is now Flame Bait. Renamed one trope.
Changed line(s) 2 (click to see context) from:
* AlternateCharacterInterpretation:
to:
* AlternateCharacterInterpretation:AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
Deleted line(s) 33,37 (click to see context) :
* WhatAnIdiot: After the trains are restarted and over a thousand people are killed by Beria's security forces, the Presidium gathers together with Krushchev (who restarted the trains) and Beria hurling blame at each other. Beria already knows that Krushchev is trying to manoeuvre against him and knows that this was an attempt to weaken his position. While they argue, Malenkov suggests that they blame the ground members of the NKVD, while the other members point out to Beria that they can close ranks to shield him from the majority of the blame, thus ensuring that Krushchev's attempt failed.
** '''You'd Expect:''' For Beria to diplomatically agree with this and try to work with the other members to frame Krushchev as the main culprit, pointing out that it was him who restarted the trains. This would clear himself of blame and strengthen his position among the members of the party.
** '''Instead:''' Beria proceeds to have a meltdown and scream abuse and threats at the other members of the Presidium, including his main ally Malenkov. He then digs up all the dirt he has on them and threatens to leak all the information.
** '''The Result:''' Beria alienates what few allies he had left and convinces everyone to ally against him. This directly leads to his arrest and execution.
** Justified, since it's pretty clearly established that Beria is a vain psychopath with rather poor impulse control and likely isn't used to having to navigate a situation like this without Stalin to back him up.
** '''You'd Expect:''' For Beria to diplomatically agree with this and try to work with the other members to frame Krushchev as the main culprit, pointing out that it was him who restarted the trains. This would clear himself of blame and strengthen his position among the members of the party.
** '''Instead:''' Beria proceeds to have a meltdown and scream abuse and threats at the other members of the Presidium, including his main ally Malenkov. He then digs up all the dirt he has on them and threatens to leak all the information.
** '''The Result:''' Beria alienates what few allies he had left and convinces everyone to ally against him. This directly leads to his arrest and execution.
** Justified, since it's pretty clearly established that Beria is a vain psychopath with rather poor impulse control and likely isn't used to having to navigate a situation like this without Stalin to back him up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added DiffLines:
* AluminiumChristmasTrees: There was a real Dr. Lidiya Timaschuk who was a KGB informant, acted as the main witness of the Doctor's Plot, and was arrested when the case was abandoned. Everything else is presumably fictional.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
** Perhaps justified, since it's pretty clearly established that Beria is a vain psychopath with rather poor impulse control.
to:
** Perhaps justified, Justified, since it's pretty clearly established that Beria is a vain psychopath with rather poor impulse control.control and likely isn't used to having to navigate a situation like this without Stalin to back him up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reverting edit by serial ban evader
Added DiffLines:
* WhatAnIdiot: After the trains are restarted and over a thousand people are killed by Beria's security forces, the Presidium gathers together with Krushchev (who restarted the trains) and Beria hurling blame at each other. Beria already knows that Krushchev is trying to manoeuvre against him and knows that this was an attempt to weaken his position. While they argue, Malenkov suggests that they blame the ground members of the NKVD, while the other members point out to Beria that they can close ranks to shield him from the majority of the blame, thus ensuring that Krushchev's attempt failed.
** '''You'd Expect:''' For Beria to diplomatically agree with this and try to work with the other members to frame Krushchev as the main culprit, pointing out that it was him who restarted the trains. This would clear himself of blame and strengthen his position among the members of the party.
** '''Instead:''' Beria proceeds to have a meltdown and scream abuse and threats at the other members of the Presidium, including his main ally Malenkov. He then digs up all the dirt he has on them and threatens to leak all the information.
** '''The Result:''' Beria alienates what few allies he had left and convinces everyone to ally against him. This directly leads to his arrest and execution.
** Perhaps justified, since it's pretty clearly established that Beria is a vain psychopath with rather poor impulse control.
** '''You'd Expect:''' For Beria to diplomatically agree with this and try to work with the other members to frame Krushchev as the main culprit, pointing out that it was him who restarted the trains. This would clear himself of blame and strengthen his position among the members of the party.
** '''Instead:''' Beria proceeds to have a meltdown and scream abuse and threats at the other members of the Presidium, including his main ally Malenkov. He then digs up all the dirt he has on them and threatens to leak all the information.
** '''The Result:''' Beria alienates what few allies he had left and convinces everyone to ally against him. This directly leads to his arrest and execution.
** Perhaps justified, since it's pretty clearly established that Beria is a vain psychopath with rather poor impulse control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 28 (click to see context) :
* {{Bathos}}: {{Inverted}}. Many bleak black comedy moments that are supposed to be funny are so bleak, they instead fall short and turn into emotionally-compelling dramatic moments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* {{Bathos}}: {{Inverted}}. Many bleak black comedy moments that are supposed to be funny are so bleak, they instead fall short and turn into emotionally-compelling dramatic moments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More like Bathos than So Bad It's Good
Deleted line(s) 28 (click to see context) :
* SoBadItsGood: A positive, strange and occasional example regarding some of the jokes. A normal So Bad It's Good moment is "good" because an attempt at drama or action fails and becomes extremely funny. In this movie, you get a weird inverse: rather bleak black comedy moments that are supposed to be funny are so bleak, they instead fall short and turn into emotionally-compelling dramatic moments. This does not hurt the film overall, and might even enhance it for some people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 29,30 (click to see context) :
* TearJerker: Since this is a movie about Stalinist oppression, there are some genuinely gut-wrenching moments.
** When the police start shouting his name, the conductor solemnly tells his wife [[ShootTheDog to denounce him as a traitor]] so she won't be arrested either. Of course, he turns out to not be in trouble, but it speaks volumes about the kind of place Russia is that he expects that kind of thing to happen to him.
** When the police start shouting his name, the conductor solemnly tells his wife [[ShootTheDog to denounce him as a traitor]] so she won't be arrested either. Of course, he turns out to not be in trouble, but it speaks volumes about the kind of place Russia is that he expects that kind of thing to happen to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
proper Red Link
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
** Zhukov beating Vasily become this when considering some ''Franchise/StarWars'' fans were unhappy Rupert Friend replaced Creator/JasonIsaacs as the Grand Inquisitor in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.
to:
** Zhukov beating Vasily become this when considering some ''Franchise/StarWars'' fans were unhappy Rupert Friend Creator/RupertFriend replaced Creator/JasonIsaacs as the Grand Inquisitor in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
** Zhukov beating Vasily become this when considering some ''Franchise/StarWars'' fans were unhappy Creator/RupertFriend replaced Creator/JasonIsaacs as the Grand Inquisitor in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.
to:
** Zhukov beating Vasily become this when considering some ''Franchise/StarWars'' fans were unhappy Creator/RupertFriend Rupert Friend replaced Creator/JasonIsaacs as the Grand Inquisitor in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
** Zhukov beating Vasily become this when considering some ''Franchise/StarWars'' fans were unhappy Creator/RupertFriend replaced Creator/JasonIsaacs as the Grand Inquisitor in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Didn't seem to fit with the trope, and Beria's already covered pretty well in the already existing entry for Complete Monster
Deleted line(s) 30 (click to see context) :
** Beria is a truly horrible person, not just for having people executed, but for being a sociopathic monster who forces himself on women.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* MagnificentBastard: UsefulNotes/NikitaKhrushchev begins as one of UsefulNotes/JosefStalin's inner circle, playing a delicate game to survive his insane leader's violent whims. Upon Stalin's death, Khrushchev enters into a power struggle with the monstrous [[TheSociopath Lavrentiy Beria]] who usurps his plans to free political prisoners and restore the church. Upon realizing the [[UsefulNotes/MoscowCentre NKVD]] has replaced the Red Army, Khrushchev orders the borders reopened so the resulting flood of people trigger the NKVD to violence, killing many people and ruining Beria's public image. Khrushchev then has Beria arrested after allying with [[FourStarBadass Georgy Zhukov]] of the Red Army and organizes Beria's complete downfall, show trial and execution to eventually take total control of the Soviet Union and reform it.
to:
* MagnificentBastard: MagnificentBastard:
** UsefulNotes/NikitaKhrushchev begins as one of UsefulNotes/JosefStalin's inner circle, playing a delicate game to survive his insane leader's violent whims. Upon Stalin's death, Khrushchev enters into a power struggle with the monstrous [[TheSociopath Lavrentiy Beria]] who usurps his plans to free political prisoners and restore the church. Upon realizing the [[UsefulNotes/MoscowCentre NKVD]] has replaced the Red Army, Khrushchev orders the borders reopened so the resulting flood of people trigger the NKVD to violence, killing many people and ruining Beria's public image. Khrushchev then has Beria arrested after allying with [[FourStarBadass Georgy Zhukov]] of the Red Army and organizes Beria's complete downfall, show trial and execution to eventually take total control of the Soviet Union and reformit.it.
** [[FourStarBadass Field Marshal Georgy Konstantinovich Zhukov]] is the [[LargeHam bombastic]] war-hero head of the [[UsefulNotes/RedsWithRockets Soviet Red Army]]. First introducing after the NKVD replaces the Red Army in security and announcing "I'm smiling but I am very fucking furious," Zhukov wastes no time in putting the sniveling Vasily Stalin in his place. Upon hearing Nikita Khrushchev's plans, Zhukov [[TheGadfly takes the chance to tease him]] before assisting his plot to see the fall of Lavrentiy Beria, gleefully punching out the sadistic rapist before initiating his plot to completely purge the NKVD and see Beria executed.
** UsefulNotes/NikitaKhrushchev begins as one of UsefulNotes/JosefStalin's inner circle, playing a delicate game to survive his insane leader's violent whims. Upon Stalin's death, Khrushchev enters into a power struggle with the monstrous [[TheSociopath Lavrentiy Beria]] who usurps his plans to free political prisoners and restore the church. Upon realizing the [[UsefulNotes/MoscowCentre NKVD]] has replaced the Red Army, Khrushchev orders the borders reopened so the resulting flood of people trigger the NKVD to violence, killing many people and ruining Beria's public image. Khrushchev then has Beria arrested after allying with [[FourStarBadass Georgy Zhukov]] of the Red Army and organizes Beria's complete downfall, show trial and execution to eventually take total control of the Soviet Union and reform
** [[FourStarBadass Field Marshal Georgy Konstantinovich Zhukov]] is the [[LargeHam bombastic]] war-hero head of the [[UsefulNotes/RedsWithRockets Soviet Red Army]]. First introducing after the NKVD replaces the Red Army in security and announcing "I'm smiling but I am very fucking furious," Zhukov wastes no time in putting the sniveling Vasily Stalin in his place. Upon hearing Nikita Khrushchev's plans, Zhukov [[TheGadfly takes the chance to tease him]] before assisting his plot to see the fall of Lavrentiy Beria, gleefully punching out the sadistic rapist before initiating his plot to completely purge the NKVD and see Beria executed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.
Changed line(s) 9 (click to see context) from:
* CompleteMonster: [[ManipulativeBastard Lavrentiy Beria]], the head of the [[UsefulNotes/MoscowCentre NKVD]], desires control over Russia, using his position to murder, torture, and [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil rape]] whomever he wants, regardless of age. After discovering that [[UsefulNotes/JosefStalin Stalin]]'s dead, Beria crafts his own enemy list to replace Stalin's, has the NKVD take over city security duties from the Soviet Army, and appoints weak-minded Deputy General Secretary Georgy Malenkov as Premier of Russia to be used as a political puppet. Refusing to allow Stalin's mourners into Moscow for his funeral, once 1,500 of them are slaughtered by his soldiers, he instead [[NeverMyFault blames the mourners]] for being there against his orders, and refuses to allow his NKVD troops to act as scapegoats for fear that it'll tarnish his reputation.
to:
* CompleteMonster: [[ManipulativeBastard CompleteMonster:
**UsefulNotes/JosefStalin himself is the sociopathic, overly paranoid master of the Soviet Union. A cruel despot who trusts and loves none, Stalin is [[SmallRoleBigImpact responsible]] for nightmarish prison camps that hundreds of thousands have been sent to, tortured and eventually murdered. Stalin regularly sends out lists of individuals to be purged, along with their innocent families, and allows the wicked Lavrentiy Beria to operate with impunity. [[BadBoss Even his inner circle is not immune]], with the completely loyal Molotov set up to be murdered before Stalin's own death after Stalin had long imprisoned his wife.
**[[ManipulativeBastard Lavrentiy Beria]], the head of the [[UsefulNotes/MoscowCentre NKVD]], desires control over Russia, using his position to murder, torture, and [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil rape]] whomever he wants, regardless of age. After discovering that [[UsefulNotes/JosefStalin Stalin]]'s dead, Beria crafts his own enemy list to replace Stalin's, has the NKVD take over city security duties from the Soviet Army, and appoints weak-minded Deputy General Secretary Georgy Malenkov as Premier of Russia to be used as a political puppet. Refusing to allow Stalin's mourners into Moscow for his funeral, once 1,500 of them are slaughtered by his soldiers, he instead [[NeverMyFault blames the mourners]] for being there against his orders, and refuses to allow his NKVD troops to act as scapegoats for fear that it'll tarnish his reputation.
**UsefulNotes/JosefStalin himself is the sociopathic, overly paranoid master of the Soviet Union. A cruel despot who trusts and loves none, Stalin is [[SmallRoleBigImpact responsible]] for nightmarish prison camps that hundreds of thousands have been sent to, tortured and eventually murdered. Stalin regularly sends out lists of individuals to be purged, along with their innocent families, and allows the wicked Lavrentiy Beria to operate with impunity. [[BadBoss Even his inner circle is not immune]], with the completely loyal Molotov set up to be murdered before Stalin's own death after Stalin had long imprisoned his wife.
**[[ManipulativeBastard Lavrentiy Beria]], the head of the [[UsefulNotes/MoscowCentre NKVD]], desires control over Russia, using his position to murder, torture, and [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil rape]] whomever he wants, regardless of age. After discovering that [[UsefulNotes/JosefStalin Stalin]]'s dead, Beria crafts his own enemy list to replace Stalin's, has the NKVD take over city security duties from the Soviet Army, and appoints weak-minded Deputy General Secretary Georgy Malenkov as Premier of Russia to be used as a political puppet. Refusing to allow Stalin's mourners into Moscow for his funeral, once 1,500 of them are slaughtered by his soldiers, he instead [[NeverMyFault blames the mourners]] for being there against his orders, and refuses to allow his NKVD troops to act as scapegoats for fear that it'll tarnish his reputation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* TearJerker: Since this is a movie about Stalinist oppression, there are some genuinely gut-wrenching moments.
** When the police start shouting his name, the conductor solemnly tells his wife [[ShootTheDog to denounce him as a traitor]] so she won't be arrested either. Of course, he turns out to not be in trouble, but it speaks volumes about the kind of place Russia is that he expects that kind of thing to happen to him.
** Beria is a truly horrible person, not just for having people executed, but for being a sociopathic monster who forces himself on women.
** When the police start shouting his name, the conductor solemnly tells his wife [[ShootTheDog to denounce him as a traitor]] so she won't be arrested either. Of course, he turns out to not be in trouble, but it speaks volumes about the kind of place Russia is that he expects that kind of thing to happen to him.
** Beria is a truly horrible person, not just for having people executed, but for being a sociopathic monster who forces himself on women.